Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Baudrillard’s theory cannot distinguish between the productive politics of the aff and the mass snooze of commodification—the affirmative disproves the simulation thesis by producing content that ruptures and interrupts the droning message of the war on terror.

Rojek 1993 (Chris, Senior Editor in Sociology at Routledge Forget Baudrillard? P. 120

Yet to imply that poetry excludes politics is surely eccentric Observing and communicating cannot be satisfactorily understood as unchanging constants. There is an historical dimension to them, as unchanging constants. There is an historical dimension to them. Baudrillard’s sociology is fatally immune to this because it is bluntly ahistorical. So it ignores how observing and communicating have changed and minimizes the stratified difference sbetween communicators and observers. Baudrillard correctly stresses that the distraction factories of the gflobal communications industry confuyse our sense of change and our awareness of difference. But the minimalist picture of humans as ‘monitroing screens’ or ‘terminals in mass communication networks’ which his sociloygy supplies is an unsuitable answer to this confusion. It does not even take seriously the circulation processes which his work identifies. For circulation involves not only repetition but also reaction. Benjamin’s sociology allows for reaction. His discussion of mass reproduction and the global circulation of images, bodies and commodities does not negate a political response; on the contrary it demands one. The decline of aura, the homogenization of culture and the manipulation of the masses are all things which Benjamin opposes. There may be a note of melancholy in his assessment of the prospects for successfully opposing these historical tendencies but he does not waver in his commitment to struggle and resistance. In contrast, Bduarillard discusses mass reproduction , homogenization, and manipulation as immoveable facts of life. One relates ot them through irony, play, seduyction and movement. Commitment in Baudrillard’s aleatory, reversible universe is always a sign of stuborrness. It closes down one’s range of response to the isness of hyperreality.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.