Political deliberation is based more on how metaphors animate policy than rational choices
Heidt 13 Heidt, Stephen J. Department of Communication, Georgia State University. "Presidential Rhetoric, Metaphor, and the Emergence of the Democracy Promotion Industry." Southern Communication Journal 78.3 (2013): 233-255. rishi
Presidential rhetoric always ignores policy details partially because presidents don’t like to speak in specifics, but also partially because metaphoric appeals are easier to extend. Presidents turn to metaphor because they recognize the power of metaphor, the ability of metaphor to connect complicated public policy proposals to broader themes and representations of America, and the difficulty opponents have in countering metaphorical depictions of public policy. In this way, public decision making is premised not on the evaluation of specific policies but instead on the assessment of the archetypal metaphors utilized by advocates and the ability of those metaphors to animate empty, incomplete, or poorly defined policy agendas. The danger reflected by this analysis is that the use of metaphor to extend public policy pushes an ultimately uncritical perspective, one that asks audiences to accept the policy not on its merits but on its relationship to generalized conceptions of the human experience. The danger of uncritical acceptance is such that, over time, advocates and publics come to believe their characterizations of international situations, the necessity and inevitability of democracy, and the U.S. role as benevolent assistant. These rhetorical processes allow for the appropriation and use of policy by those less interested in the ideals that serve as the genesis for the policy and instead desire to redirect the policy toward their own ends. This is precisely what occurred during the George W. Bush administration, leading one expert to fear that ‘‘the close association of democracy promotion both with the war in Iraq . . . and with the War on Terrorism . . . has badly hurt the legitimacy of democracy promotion.’’105 Critical inquiry into the rhetorical forms like metaphor that authorize, extend, or reassert public policy can usefully expose those forms as antidemocratic tools that sanitize public conceptions and convert well-intentioned public policy into something else entirely. These conclusions suggest that more essays explaining metaphor’s role in public policy would be welcome.