Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The politicization of identity requires categorization – generates disciplinary regimes which neutralize differences within identity categories and reinscribes relations of domination

Brown, 1995. (Wendy, Professor of Political Science and Rhetoric at UC-Berkeley, States of Injury: Power and Freedom in Late Modernity, published by Princeton UP, p. 65-66; spp)

Contemporary politicized identity is also potentially reiterative of regulatory, disciplinary society in its configuration of a disciplinary subject. It is both produced by and potentially accelerates the production of that aspect of disciplinary society which "ceaselessly characterizes, classifies, and specializes," which works through "surveillance, continuous registration, perpetual assessment, and classification," through a social machinery "that is both immense and minute. "19 An example from the¶ world of local politics makes clear politicized identity's imbrication in¶ disciplinary power, as well as the way in which, as Foucault reminds us,¶ disciplinary power "infiltrates" rather than replaces liberal juridical¶ modalities. 20¶ Recently, the city council of my town reviewed an ordinance, devised¶ and promulgated by a broad coalition of identity-based political groups,¶ which aimed to ban discrimination in employment, housing, and public¶ accommodations on the basis of "sexual orientation, transsexuality, age,¶ height, weight, personal appearance, physical characteristics, race, color,¶ creed, religion, national origin, ancestry, disability, marital status, sex, or¶ gender. "21 Here is a perfect instance of the universal juridical ideal of¶ liberalism and the normalizing principle of disciplinary regimes conjoined¶ and taken up within the discourse of politicized identity. This¶ ordinance-variously called the "purple hair ordinance" or the "ugly ordinance" by state and national news media-aims to count every difference¶ as no difference, as part of the seamless whole, but also to count¶ every potentially subversive rejection of culturally enforced norms as¶ themselves normal, as normalizable, and as normativizable through law.¶ Indeed, through the definitional, procedural, and remedies sections of¶ this ordinance (e.g., "sexual orientation shall mean known or assumedhomosexuality, heterosexuality, or bisexuality") persons are reduced to observable social attributes and practices defined empirically, positivistically, as if their existence were intrinsic and factual, rather than effects of discursive and institutional power; and these positivist definitions of persons as their attributes and practices are written into law, ensuring that persons describable according to them will now become regulated through them. Bentham couldn't have done it better. Indeed,¶ here is a perfect instance of how the language of recognition becomes the¶ language of unfreedom, how articulation in language, in the context of liberal and disciplinary discourse, becomes a vehicle of subordination through individualization, normalization, and regulation, even as it strives to produce visibility and acceptance. Here, also, is a perfect instance¶ of the way in which "differences" that are the effects of social power are neutralized through their articulation as attributes and their circulation through liberal administrative discourse: what do we make of¶ a document that renders as juridical equivalents the denial of employment¶ to an African American, an obese woman, and a white middleclass¶ youth festooned with tattoos, a pierced tongue, and fuchsia hair?

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.