Politicized identity relies on a negation of an ostensible universalism –dooms their project into recreating the impacts of the aff
Brown, 1995. (Wendy, Professor of Political Science and Rhetoric at UC-Berkeley, States of Injury: Power and Freedom in Late Modernity, published by Princeton UP, p. 64-65; spp)
Contemporary politicized identity in the United States contests the terms¶ of liberal discourse insofar as it challenges liberalism's universal "we" as a¶ strategic fiction of historically hegemonic groups and asserts liberalism's¶ "I" as social-both relational and constructed by power-rather than¶ contingent, private, or autarkic. Yet it reiterates the terms of liberal discourse¶ insofar as it posits a sovereign and unified "I" that is disenfranchised by an exclusive "we." Indeed, I have suggested that politicized identity emerges and obtains its unifying coherence through the politicization of¶ exclusion from an ostensible universal, as a protest against exclusion: a protest premised on the fiction of an inclusive/ universal¶ community, a protest that thus reinstalls the humanist ideal-and a specific white,¶ middle-class, masculinist expression of this ideal-insofar as it premises itself upon exclusion from it. Put the other way around, politicized identities¶ generated out of liberal, disciplinary societies, insofar as they are premised on exclusion from a universal ideal, require that ideal, as their exclusion from it, for their own continuing existence as identities.