Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The affs engagement in post-structural feminism culminates in the reification of enlightenment thinking and capitalist hierarchies.

Willey 14- Marilynn is a passionate supporter of Wellesley and its mission to prepare students to make meaningful contributions to the world through disciplined thinking and engagement with diverse perspectives. She is thrilled to support the Freedom Project's efforts to be a beacon of tolerance and pluralism both on campus and beyond file:///Users/ethancooper/Downloads/WCTC_2014_WilleyMarilynn_ACritiqueofPostmoder.pdf

In attempting to expound upon the thinking behind poststructuralist feminism, Alcoff explains, “The mechanism of power referred to here is the construction of the subject by a discourse that weaves knowledge and power into a coercive structure…on this view, essentialist formulations of womanhood, even when made by feminists, ‘tie’ the individual to her identity as a woman and thus cannot represent a solution to sexism.” 94 The problem with this view, when it is applied to social and political movements, is that it places the individual’s ability and desire to subjectively create and design their own identity and purpose as the highest moral good - there is not higher order or meaning beyond what the individual creates as part of their autonomous and non-essential identity. As Alcoff explains, “The political struggle can have only a ‘negative function:’ rejecting ‘everything finite, definite, structured, loaded with meaning, in the existing state of society.’”95 Such a view might be helpful when addressing individual psychological or social difficulties, but it is a problematic way to lead a social movement and a destructive way to lead people in understanding their role in a social, humane world. Alcoff’s criticism is rooted in the philosophically challenging aspect of such a view: “Applied to the concept of woman the poststructuralist’s view !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 93 Ibid, 8. 94 Ibid. 95 Ibid, 11. 48 results in what I shall call nominalism: the idea that the category of ‘woman’ is a fiction and that feminist efforts must be directed toward dismantling this fiction.”96 Alcoff explains that the appeal of post-structuralism to feminist thinkers is twofold: “First, it seems to hold out the promise of an increased freedom for women, the ‘free play’ of a plurality of differences unhampered by any predetermined gender identity as formulated by either patriarchy or cultural feminism. Second, it moves decisively beyond cultural feminism and liberal feminism in further theorizing what they leave untouched: the construction of subjectivity.”97 Interestingly, Alcoff notes the extent to which poststructuralist feminism is a direct descendent of classical liberal views on the individual: “Despite rumblings from the Continent, Anglo-American thought is still wedded to the ideal of a universalizable, apolitical methodology and set of transhistorical basic truths unfettered by associations with particular genders, races, classes, or cultures.” 98 Alcoff sees the generic human idea, promoted in Enlightenment thinking, as closely related to post-structuralism’s designation of “individual particularities such as subjective experience as a social construct,” and claims that “post-structuralism’s negation of the authority of the subject coincides nicely with the classical liberal’s view that human particularities are irrelevant. (For the liberal, race, class, and gender are ultimately irrelevant to questions of justice and truth because ‘underneath we are all the same.’)” Perhaps Alcoff’s most relevant and pressing question is the one that points to the primary problem facing any proponent of poststructuralist feminism: “A feminist !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 96 Ibid. 97 Ibid. 98 Ibid, 13. 49 adoption of nominalism will be confronted with the same problem theories of ideology have, that is, Why is a right-wing woman’s consciousness constructed via social discourse but a feminist’s consciousness is not?”99 It has been recognized by many feminists in academia that disagreements among feminists are cause for concern, especially those who wish to see feminist ideas of any form succeed. The editors of Conflicts in Feminism note in their introduction that, While feminists have in principle tended to agree that difference is a more productive theoretical and political category than either universalizing consensus or divisive oppositions, in practice, actual differences within feminist discourse have tended to erupt into separate camps. At this moment in time, some of these conflicts have proven so divisive that they seem to foreclose rather than stimulate debate, even at times appearing to threaten the very viability of contemporary feminism as a political and theoretical venture.100 The problems that result from such a stifling intellectual climate are apparent not only to those dealing with feminism in theory, but also among those putting it into practice in the classroom or in the public sphere. The editors of Conflicts in Feminism also echo Alcoff’s observation that “A common divide keeps forming in both feminist thought and action between the need to build the identity ‘woman’ and give it solid political meaning and the need to tear down the very category ‘woman’ and dismantle its all-too-solid history.”101 They recognize that neither approach is without fault: social construction does not seem plausible to the average person, and “to assert that the body has no enduring, natural language often !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 99 Ibid, 12. 100 Marianne Hirsch and Evelyn Fox Keller, “Introduction,” Conflicts in Feminism, (New York: Routledge, 1990), 4. 101 Ann Snitow, “A Gender Diary,” in Conflicts in Feminism, 9. 50 seems like a rejection of common sense.”102 Not only is it a tough sell to a mainstream audience, but also the poststructuralist approach is logically problematic, in that “By definition social construction theory cannot offer a securely bounded area for the study of gender; instead it initiates an inspiring collapse of gender verities.”103 Alcoff offers a similar sentiment, asking, “If gender is simply a social construct, the need and even the possibility of a feminist politics becomes immediately problematic. What can we demand in the name of women if ‘women’ do not exist and demands in their name simply reinforce the myth that they do?”104 Such an approach eventually leads to an almost nihilistic nothingness - a void in which there is no need for women’s liberation because women do not exist. The editors also touch on an important dichotomy in feminist thought, somewhat analogous to Alcoff’s cultural feminism and poststructuralist feminism: Equality and difference are broad ideas and have included a rrange of definitions and political expressions. Equality, for example, can mean anything from the mildest liberal reform to the most radical reduction of gender to insignificance. Difference can mean anything from Mary Daly’s belief in the natural superiority of women to psychoanalytic theories of how women are inevitably cast as “the Other” because they lack penises.105 Clearly, even within two polarized categories - equality and difference feminism - there are still more opportunities for polarization and disagreement. !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 102 Ibid. 103 Ibid. 104 Linda Alcoff, “Cultural Feminism Versus Post-Structuralism: The Identity Crisis in Feminist Theory,” 13. 105 Ann Snitow, “A Gender Diary,” in Conflicts in Feminism, 26. 51 It is clear from Alcoff’s essay and from the essays in Conflicts in Feminism that this issue is deeply troubling for feminists who are committed to an academic and logically sound feminism that is rooted in reality: A subjectivity that is fundamentally shaped by gender appears to lead irrevocably to essentialism, the posing of a male/female opposition as universal and ahistorical. A subjectivity that is not fundamentally shaped by gender appears to lead to the conception of a generic human subject, as if we could peel away our ‘cultural’ layers and get to the real root of human nature, which turns out to be genderless. Are these really our only choices?106 I argue that they are not the only choices, and that both cultural feminism and poststructuralist feminism adhere to and even depend fundamentally on an underlying and flawed liberation from essence view. The problem with the liberation from essence view, as it is found in both cultural feminism and poststructuralist feminism, is that, in dealing with issues of broader social and political relevance, it ultimately places the individual’s autonomy and subjectivity as the highest moral good. Whether it follows the cultural feminist line of thinking, which views women’s interests and men’s interests in opposition to each other and does not presuppose or allow for any mutual interests or synergy beyond the individual woman or man’s happiness, or the poststructuralist feminist’s view of denying the category of “woman” in the first place, neither view takes larger societal goods into consideration. Neither view considers a purpose outside of the individual’s own identity, self-definition in relation to community or tradition, and subjective experience in the world. !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 106 Linda Alcoff, “Cultural Feminism Versus Post-Structuralism: The Identity Crisis in Feminist Theory,” 16. 52 While such views may have value in a therapeutic or psychological setting, they are destructive ways to view social interactions and to interpret one’s role in society and relationships and duties to others. Cultural feminism sees masculinity and femininity as “at war,” and can be traced to the type of matriarchal feminism promoted by Charlotte Perkins Gilman, while poststructuralist feminism faces serious logical inconsistencies that threaten to eliminate the notion of women in the first place. Hoff Sommers’ offers a more classical liberal and moderate feminism centered on freedom and individual liberties. Thus, we have three primary schools of feminist thought to consider. There are the two that are accepted on the left: poststructuralist feminism and cultural (matriarchal) feminism. Then there is the more right leaning blend of freedom and maternal feminism promoted by Hoff Sommers. This chapter has identified the difficulties that contemporary feminists face in attempting to develop an underlying philosophical impetus for the movement; next I will consider how they are addressing feminism as an academic discipline with a role in educational institutions.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.