Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Neoliberalism must be addressed before the aff’s identity politics—their performance only gets coopted by the capitalist system otherwise

Pook 18 (Zooey Sophia, “QUEER IS THE NEW CAPITALISM: NEOLIBERAL TECHNOLOGIES AND A BLUEPRINT FOR THE LEFT BEYOND IDENTITY POLITICS,” Dissertation for a PhD in Philosophy, New Mexico State University)

Although Butler and company have made it clear that they do not wish to put the burden of social change on the backs of the least off, instead, carefully relegating their actions as potential strategies for academics, there does at least seem to be a kind of sensationalism that appears, at the very least, as an effect of such inquiries. Similarly, it is important to note efforts taken by Butler to delegitimize the flimsy perceptions of agency drawn from Gender Trouble that were addressed, most notably, in Bodies That Matter, and through the addition of her concept of precarity, which I will specifically address in the following chapter. In Bodies that Matter, Butler reiterates and strengthens her claim that performativity is not a matter of personal choice but of a subject already decided through the repetition/regularization of cultural norms (p. x). In Dispossession, performativity is compounded by the notion of precarity and the ways different bodies are specifically dispossessed in relation to neoliberal power. But even with these updates and nuances, the central tenants and problems of performativity and performative transgression remain, as does the impact of Gender Trouble, whether read thoughtfully or otherwise. This is the reason that I took the time to offer evidence of the specificities of the kinds of performative being done- so a reasonable analysis could be made about the ethics and effectiveness of performativity and identity-based politics when considering the situations of queer bodies. For the majority of women and gender studies students privileged and 62 educated enough to make sense of these works, reading about poor transgender inmates and impoverished queer people of color, for example, written by presumably safe and comfortable academics, lends itself to a kind of utopian thinking where the revolution is to come from a distressed and magical “other” at the deepest and darkest margins of our culture. And this is obvious enough if you’ve spent any time in a cultural studies department or in an LGBT center on most college campuses in the United States, as much excitement is generated from the possibilities of queer bodies serving as resistance tools. One should not underplay the excitement they had the first time reading Judith Butler as an undergrad, after all. In response, I think it is fair to say that queer theorists engaged in these projects would echo something not unlike Patricia Hill Collin’s (2004) defense of feminist standpoint theory- that it is more about the social conditions that a group faces than individual experiences (p. 247), but it is hard not to see how the damage is done. This is why Uma Naryan (2004) warns theorists of acquiring a kind of “double vision” where we transfer some kind of magical notions of truth and revolutionary knowledge to those who are most oppressed by the social forces and institutions we pit ourselves against (p. 233). This is an ironic twist because it seems not unlike the high theory equivalent of figures like “the magical negro” and others who have been well noted by cultural theorists as minority figures in works of popular culture who exist solely to advance the white narrative of a film, often completely devoid and separate from the logic of the film (Glenn, 2009). These are important points to consider because of the condition of LGBT+ people in the United States and in the world, as transgender people, 63 specifically, face enormous wealth disparities and are the target of murder on a quite disproportionate level (Longo, 2017). The challenges and institutional hardships of LGBT+ people are, of course, also exacerbated for LGBT+ people of color and for women, especially non-cisgender women. What should be raised at this point, are serious questions of ethics- both of the researcher in engaging such populations for political and strategic purposes and for readers and activists interested in drawing tactical conclusions from, or in tandem, with the group of inquiry. If we compare the previous works mentioned to similar works in Sociology, for examples, such as Unspeakable Love: Gay and Lesbian Life in the Middle East or Kristen Schilt and Laurel Westbrook’s “Doing Gender, Doing Heteronormativity: ‘Gender Normal’s,’ Transgender People and the Social Maintenance of Heteroesexuality,” we see much more careful attempts to make light of sensitive issues such as gay and lesbian experience in the middle east, violence towards transgender women, and the experience of transgender men in the workplace, followed by pragmatic examination of policy and law and their possibilities. This is far removed from the kind of sensationalizing or drawing undo political consequence or importance from the other’s body or experiences, despite being analysis bom of the same kind of inquiry and concern. Beyond what Hill-Collins proclaims about examining the shared social conditions of a group, it is more worthwhile to turn to the conditions of power themselves, as doing so will reveal a shift in the forms and distributions of neoliberal power, and more importantly, the changing technologies through which our lives are mediated. At such a time, identity politics will really be beside the point, and 64 performativity will need to be reassessed as a process of digital appropriation. Queer theorists have long been engaged in a kind of project to flesh out Foucault’s Discipline and Punish, acknowledging that while all bodies are disciplined by institutions and social formations of the state, they aren’t done so equally. Here, each scholar takes a turn yelling out a different minority group to which the specific particularities of oppression will be examined, along with the possibilities of resistance that coincide. It is probably long past time to turn back and diagnose power again; things have changed. Ironically, Foucault did this in very meaningful ways in his later work, arguing powerfully against self-identification and distinctions of gender and sexual identity he saw as problematically developing in the aftermath of ’68 (1978). It is, after all, one of Foucault’s major accomplishments, from his very earliest works, to illuminate the connection between the emergence of positive knowledge of human bodies and the corresponding institutional techniques that would follow to manage them (Behrent, 2013, p. 77). Now, it is neoliberalism in full bloom, and its technologies of appropriation that we must address against identity-based political resistances. The kind of compelled disclosure that Foucault draws a history of in the confessional and in medicine is now a relation of culture; it is decentralized and surrounds us, comprising our activity on the internet and between each other. The expectation of offering or being asked for a preferred pronoun in the transgender community is a serious example of this. Such an expectation transcends trust and autonomy thus reproducing the demands of information capital, rather than allowing identity to emerge or to not emerge on one’s own terms. Shannon Winnubst’s (2012) 65 work, for example, which utilizes the work of Foucault from this period to draw critique of the new ontological condition that neoliberalism produces is a useful and important work linking identity studies to postfordist being is particularly necessary in cultural studies, as is transcends the gap between technology, micro and macro political concerns, and locates neoliberal power via their connection

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.