The AFF’s identity politics only serve as a distraction from challenging capitalism—and even worse, the distraction does nothing to solve for structural inequalities at all.
Pook 18 (Zooey Sophia, “QUEER IS THE NEW CAPITALISM: NEOLIBERAL TECHNOLOGIES AND A BLUEPRINT FOR THE LEFT BEYOND IDENTITY POLITICS,” Dissertation for a PhD in Philosophy, New Mexico State University)
Identity politics have altered the way we speak about politics and in what ways. Neoliberalism does not employ the exclusionary tactics of the disciplinary age, but embraces diversity and inclusion as a means to neutralize hostis and to flatten 94 identity into a singular postfordist way of being. Discipline today is an interpersonal tool of neoliberal culture, in which individuals may take up the baton of political correctness and become an honorary member of the p.c. police, challenging inflammatory and discriminatory language, while also serving the goals of neoliberal order. Dean (2009) writes, quoting Zizek, The true victory (the true ‘negation of the negation’) occurs when the enemy talks your language. In this sense, a true victory is a victory in defeat. It occurs when one’s specific message is accepted as a universal ground, even by the enemy, (p. 7) The true victory of the post-1968 Left is the instatement of a universal language of neoliberal multiculturalism. Is this not what presents itself in all facets of culture today? A superficial respect of difference is afforded and policed omnipotently. A TV host makes a racist or sexist comment and he is fired. A store clerk tells a transgender woman she can’t use a restroom and the store is boycotted and put out of business. A movie does not promote women in the right way and it’s written about in a well-read blog and it flops in theaters. Meanwhile, the institutional injustices suffered by queer, black, and female bodies remain untouched. Identity politics serve neoliberalism because they orient us towards pacifism, and a focus on interpersonal abuses, reducing politics to speech, and directing us away from the functions of economics and politics. What identity politics have effectively served to create is an impotent language of multiculturalism that privileges victimhood and orients the disenfranchised toward superficial battles rather than towards direct action, subversion, and violence. Dean (2009) explains, 95 The position of victim (rather than victor) grows out of a prominent strain of contemporary American politics, namely, the rights discourse associated with movements for civil rights, women’s rights, and the rights of sexual minorities.7 Although often linked to left political correctness, speaking as a victim is at odds with the long history of the labor movement as well as with the politics of the new left. One need but recall a whole series of claims to power: ‘Black power,’ ‘Sisterhood is powerful,’ ‘We’re here; we’re queer; get used to it,’ ‘Power to the people.’ Reducing political speech to testimony to the suffering of victims inverts these claims to power and subverts the movements’ activist spirit, (p. 5) The discourse of victimhood does not produce institutional change. It produces social milieus. Today’s identity politics are vacuous. They have been reduced by neoliberal technologies to a microcosm of what they once were. Today’s “social justice warriors” are self-aggrandizing, going through the motions, and their digital protests are in direct symmetry with the emptiness of academic social critique. Frances Lee’s widely circulated (2017) blog article, “Kin Aesthetics: Excommunicate Me From the Church of Social Justice” mirrors LaTour’s (2004) critique of cultural studies, evidencing that identity politics movements today have become a divisive lifestyle which uncritically promote elitist and superficial language/analysis and attachment to “sacred texts” that fail to meaningfully challenge capitalist logics. When once Stokely Carmichael (1967) called for direct action and violence, citing the ways that civil rights movements become coopted, today #BlackLivesMatter is a savvy political brand aimed at shaping the modem platform of the Democratic Party, unconcerned with neoliberal imperialism (Dixon, 2015). When transgender women once threw bricks at the Stonewall Inn and physically defended themselves against police bmtality, today the LGBT+ movement musters its collective force to fail movies that 96 don’t adequately address the perception of their history (Smith, 2015). Identity politics have become problematic, as social justice warriors might say. Neoliberal technologies are particularly good at orienting us towards digital milieus. Identity politics have become hashtags and Facebook arguments. They have become circulation; more information capital lost in the flow on neoliberal networks. Jodi Dean (2009) explains her notion of circulation, Any particular contribution remains secondary to the fact of circulation. The value of any particular contribution is likewise inversely proportionate to the openness, inclusiveness, or extent of a circulating data stream: the more opinions or comments that are out there, the less of an impact any given one might make (and the more shocking, spectacular, and new a contribution must be in order to register or have an impact). In sum, communication functions symptomatically to produce its own negation, (p. 26) Today, issues of social justice and culture are taken up in endless ways on the internet by ever fracturing groups of individuals, constantly reimagining their space, positionality, and identity. Social media, blogs, group pages, and more direct lines of communication swell with hashtags, petitions, and arguments lined with a language of social justice ripe with lingo and abbreviation specific to the causes of internet activists. They remain detached from means of power and economics, and are instead easily swept into the currents of network, producing ever more information capital for the system they wish to challenge. The internet is a cozy and comfortable place for the disenfranchised to dump their proclivities for change. The Invisible Committee (2007) writes of activists organizations as “empty structures, which, in spite of their grand origins, can never be filled. In all their affairs, at every level, these organizations are concerned above all with their own survival as organizations, and 97 little else,” but “Far more dreadful are social milieus, with their supple texture, their gossip, and their informal hierarchies. Flee all milieus. Each and every milieu is oriented towards the neutralization of some truth” (p. 100). Digital milieus are no different: they form a language, a culture, sublimate a revolutionary message, and finally, punish and attack anyone who fails to perform their message the way they have deemed to be fashionable. These milieus and fractioned identity politics groups fail to convert any particulars into a universal cause or coherent Left capable of challenging neoliberal power. They are divisive and often simply serve as a vehicle to dump one’s rightful fears and anger about social injustices, producing a hard sardony, as their digital contributions are appropriated and exchanged as information capital. Dean (2009) writes, Contestations today rarely employ common terms, points of reference, or demarcated frontiers. In our highly mediated communications environments we confront instead a multiplication of resistances and assertions so extensive as to hinder the formation of strong counterhegemonies. The proliferation, distribution, acceleration, and intensification of communicative access and opportunity result in a deadlocked democracy incapable of serving as a form for political change. I refer to this democracy that talks without responding as communicative capitalism, (p. 22) The digital milieus of identity politics cannot serve us. They fracture, rather than connect, and convert useful resentment against the system into circulation. They squander revolutionary potential. Digital milieus are the internet equivalent of activist organizations and thus exacerbate the already existent problems of management, exclusivity, and production, through the reach, scope, and capture of neoliberal technologies. 98 Identity politics and digital milieus converge with neoliberal technologies to orient us to nonviolence, toward issues of culture rather than institutional awareness, and toward matters of the interpersonal, because this is what is achievable via the method of digital milieus and the internet, such as through petitions, social media, etc. Identity politics are particularly attuned and skilled in making it known that a particularly movie might be racist or even that an act of police brutality has occurred, but not in highlighting or addressing the ways in which systems function. Digital milieus, in short, orient us to matters of subjective, rather than objective violence. Slavoj Zizek (2008) explains the difference, as The catch is that subjective and objective violence cannot be perceived from the same standpoint: subjective violence is experienced as such against the background of a non-violent zero level. It is seen as a perturbation of the ‘normal,’ peaceful state of things. However, objective violence is precisely the violence inherent to this ‘normal’ state of things. Objective violence is invisible since it sustains the very zero-level standard against which we perceive something as subjectively violent. Systemic violence is thus something like the notorious ‘dark matter’ of physics, the counterpart to an all-too-visible subjective violence. It may be invisible, but it has to be taken into account if one is to make sense of what otherwise seem to be ‘irrational’ explosions of subjective violence, (p. 2) Digital identity politics address egregious shows of force that emerge and appear on top of the regular functions of economics, politics, and our daily routines, which disappear in mundanity. We can stop a bill from passing that would victimize transgender women, or get a cop put on trial for killing an unarmed black man, but identity politics cannot address the imperial and domestic violence of capitalism; it cannot impede the rhythm of empire. Politics are thus reduced to subjectivized dilemma, and often reduced further to the smallest microcosm of interpersonal 99 interaction since internet technologies allow even the most ordinary civilian to hold a lens at all places and times in the public sphere. Identity politics becomes lost in the exchange of all things that the neoliberal shift from capital as wage relation to social relation produced. Digital milieus cannot challenge the flows of information and capital in network because it is contributing to them through the conversion of their revolutionary anger to circulation. However, I would like to consider what form resistance might take to disturb and counteract the flows of empire. In the following section I will examine what kind of force might make way against the objective violence and processes of desubjectivation through which neoliberalism sustains itself. I will attempt to offer solutions.