Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The aff’s insistence that we should all “embrace vulnerability” overcodes the way black vulnerability is manifest constantly as abjection––it relies on antiblack grammars of relationality centered around the Human

Mukasa Mubirumusoke 2022 [Assistant Professor in the Intercollegiate Department of Africana Studies at Claremont McKenna College “Black Hospitality A Theoretical Framework for Black Ethical Life” https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-95255-6]//sheima

We all share in vulnerability argues Butler, even on this global geopolitical scale and it’s rooted in a ‘social vulnerability.’ Against Butler’s idea of a shared ‘social vulnerability’, this chapter argues human vulnerability in its various guises and comparable quantifications is not of the same quality as black vulnerability. Black vulnerability is of a different kind then even the extreme vulnerability Butler identifies as imposed by the war on terror. Black vulnerability has an abject quality because of its non-relationality that expels the experience of black people from the realm of the human by means of an objectifying violence. The extralegal policies issued by the United States state department seemingly defy all modern legal precedence domestically and internationally, culminating in the practice of indefinite detention at Guantanamo Bay—which still holds thirty-nine people as of January 2022. And yet, these conditions still discursively refer to a human subject insomuch as these persons retain some form of cultural historical integrity and a political ontology that can identify and punish transgressions of its normative orders, even if these transgressions are generally seen as acceptable by a broader human coalition. Undeniably a shared vulnerability of the human gets manipulated and contorted to produce an intensification of vulnerability for the brown, deceitful, ‘terrorist’, both abroad and in the United States. The profound degradation of the Middle Eastern person, however, is not the same as the abject black object and this distinction must be considered beyond the discourses of colorblindness, protest size, or even the unfathomable unconstitutional practices of the US government toward an entire religion and region post 9/11.¶ “This chapter began by recounting black experience at the beginning of the twenty-first century not merely because it describes a black vulnerability that overlaps temporally with the hostility toward Middle Easterners, which is the signature of the never-ending war on terror that framed Butler’s reflections of vulnerability. Indeed, these two historical examples are worthy of comparison for their temporal overlap and conceptual distinction, but also a look at the beginning of the twenty-first century and the right ‘now’ for black people also calls attention to an eerie repetition of the same, whereby the spectacular horror of violence that is attached to the names Trayvon, Tamir; Taylor, Floyd, seem all too familiar and even now more than ever seem almost necessary for the functioning of the political order of America, even if it is not clear why. In describing the peculiarity of black (political) vulnerability this chapter will also need to address what appears to be this compulsion of antiblack violence and the spectacle that obscures it. Butler’s reimagination of subjectivity through vulnerability is an attempt to reform the ethico-political presumptions that encourage individualism, nationalism, and dichotomous self-constructions, suggesting American aggression and Middle Eastern resentment are notes in the same chord. The concept of vulnerability supposedly can unveil the harmony of humanity even when its violent hypocrisies are loudest. Yet the hostility toward blacks and their vulnerability resonates in a different key; the interminable ‘war on terror’ is different from the positionality of the slave that must be reaffirmed regardless of, and illegible to, more prominent narratives in American political discourse and political economy.Through the lens of afropessimism, Frank Wilderson III and Jared Sexton—along with others—allow us to conceptualize the uniqueness of black vulnerability, or rather its illegibility and objectifying nature, over and against the spectrum of shared political vulnerability described by Butler and others. The key to understanding black vulnerability and its extraordinary character is a notion of social death—which will be recategorized as political death in the next chapter—that positions black people not merely at the edge but on the outside and antagonistic to a political community that is structured by antiblack white supremacy. Wilderson provides the most comprehensive conception of black social death working primarily from, with modification, Orlando Patterson’s definition in the seminal work Slavery and Social Death, in addition to inspiration from Frantz Fanon, Saidiya Hartman, and Hortense Spillers. Through social death, black people occupy a positionality—not a subjective identity—that refuses legibility as human. This is accomplished under the parameters of dishonor, natal alienation, and gratuitous violence. The black positionality is unique in its’ non-relation to all other positionalities inasmuch as its degradation is an absolute abjection, in other words modern political ontology denies all relationality to black people. It is not contingently maintained through possible transgressions, but structurally constitutive through negation in the formation of proper political subjectivity, from the most valued to the least valued political subjects. Social death as abjection is necessary to maintain the world of the human. Jared Sexton offers the helpful description of a general economy to conceptualize the excess and need for repetition as a non-rational affective investment in the abjection of black people. From these perspectives emerges a concept of black vulnerability that goes beyond Butler’s homogenized conceptualization of a collective ontological vulnerability. Through a loss of what was never there, a loss that is gratuitously reified through repetition, we can better understand what is specific to antiblack violence. David Marriott employs the term abjection to signify a loss that was never present (Marriott 2007, 123).¶ Gratuity compliments abjection, as it explains the excessive repetition of antiblack violence, since there are no legible norms to be transgressed in a loss that was never present and thus no ultimate rationality or foundation to rest on except bare assertion. As Wilderson describes in the first chapter of Red, White, and Black: “This (gratuitous ) violence which turns a body into flesh, ripped apart literally and imaginatively, destroys the possibility of ontology because it positions the Black in an infinite and indeterminately horrifying open vulnerability, an object made available (which is to say fungible) for any subject. (Wilderson III 2010, 38; my emphasis) In describing black vulnerability as ‘infinite’, ‘indeterminate’, and ‘horrifyingly open’, Wilderson provides a conceptual framing and analytic undoing that demands rethinking who may belong to the spectrum of human vulnerability and what does not. This chapter next turns to an explication of the excessive ‘extra-ordinary’ nature of the illegible, fungible, accumulative, and abject object of blackness that characterizes black vulnerability.”¶ II. The General Economy of White Supremacy and Extra-ordinary Black Vulnerability Following in the spirit of Butler’s innovative refguring of subjectivity via vulnerability, Catriona Mackenzie, Wendy Rogers, and Susan Dodds, in the introduction to their 2014 reader titled Vulnerability: New Essays in Ethics and Feminist Philosophy, also call for the displacement of the traditional role of rationality for describing the essence of humanity, proclaiming “Human life is conditioned by vulnerability” (Mackenzie et al. 2014, 1). While vulnerability may have universal applicability for human life, they argue it does not come in one standard universal form. They make a welcomed contribution to Butler’s intervention by breaking down vulnerability into a helpful taxonomy that situates the different ways it manifests itself through our materiality as needy bodies, through the social and affective nature of our being open to others through grief, humiliation, or through our socio-political nature as open to exploitation and oppression. Also, vulnerability can emerge from a different variety of sources, that is, inherent, situational, or pathogenic, as well as exist in different states, that is, dispositional or occurrent. These distinctions are constructive and yet limited when it comes to black people. Under this rubric, the experience of black vulnerability would fall under an occurrent state, meaning that it is not a matter of dispositional possibility of becoming vulnerable, for example, some physical disabilities, but rather black vulnerability is manifest constantly. Furthermore, its source would be pathogenic entailing a systematic oppression that is not simply inherited by means of being human or strictly situational. Makenzie, Rogers, and Dodds explain, “a key feature of pathogenic vulnerability is the way that it undermines autonomy or exacerbates the sense of powerlessness engendered by vulnerability in general” (Mackenzie et al. 2014, 9). At first glance their taxonomy appears more than sufficient to account for black vulnerability. Black vulnerability would be one among many forms of occurrent and pathogenic conditions that plague a plethora of identities that fall short of the generally accepted zero-sum position of white cisgender heterosexual ablebodied bourgeois men. However, there is a marked difference for the experience of black people: their autonomy and ‘sense of power’, at least as traditional subjects, is not undermined but illegible because of an original lack of political ontological stature. Singularly, the pathology that characterize black vulnerability is abjection, whereby black people are banished from the metrics of humanity that would render their suffering, and therefore their vulnerability, irrational, that is beyond sublation, and non-relational. Perhaps the most insidious component of black vulnerability from a philosophical perspective follows from the fact that antiblackness elides any appeal to an ultimate justification or rationality. When confronted with the machinations of antiblackness in everyday life, for example, with hate crimes, police brutality, disproportionate wages, and so on, these manifestations at first appear as if they can make sense in some larger context or rationale. As if there is some identifiable reason why black people deserve repercussion, as if they had transgressed some cultural normative arrangement or even economic preserving ideology. These racist ‘events’ appear in a taxonomy of violence that point toward antiblackness, but what if the underlying justification beyond their expression from a restricted perspective escapes any ultimate justification or rationality beyond the bare assertion of black abjection? We may say that Michael Brown would be alive if he had not stolen from that convenient store (if indeed that was the case), if he were not poor (although this too of course plays a role), if he had not charged like ‘the Hulk’, if he were not jay walking, but those ancillary reasons only obscure the reality that his violation ultimately needs no reason. It was not simply a ‘sense of powerlessness’ or lack of autonomy, but instead abject inhumanness, his non-relationality, that brought him to the alter for sacrifice in the name of white supremacy. His blackness made him vulnerable beyond belief—or, to be more specific, only on the grounds of belief—because it was his blackness that brought Darren Wilson to that neighborhood, as with many other officers, and it was his blackness that turned the 18-year-old into the Hulk, it was blackness that turned 12-year-old Tamir Rice into an armed and dangerous adult, it was blackness that turned Rodney King’s shielding forearms into aggressive pursuit and falling pants into sexual assault. Jared Sexton articulates the structure of a ‘libidinal economy of white supremacy’ using the insightful heuristic of the general economy. The libidinal economy refers to the affective and subconscious desires and investments that informs one’s self-identifications. For ‘white supremacy’ these are the arrangement and distribution of desires and affects, positive or negative, that support the formation of any identity over against blackness. Now, a general economy challenges the logic of traditional economic models that are considered essentially rationalized laws of exchange, since its grounding principle is instead exuberant expenditure, without any ultimate reason. Sexton describes white supremacy as a general economy in the 2003 essay co-authored with Steve Martinot titled “The Avant-Garde of White Supremacy,” but he explores the concept with greater depth and by name in his 2008 book Amalgamation Schemes: Antiblackness and the Critique of Multiracialism. While in the former essay he uses the term ‘hyper economy’, in the latter he uses the term general economy explicitly, citing Arkady Plotnitski’s Reconfgurations as his source. For this discussion, however, it is worth considering the more familiar, and the inspiration of Plotniski’s analysis in his book, twentieth-century French theorist and eroticist Georges Bataille.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.