Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The weaponization of Black vulnerability for the political agendas of junior partners sustains a bottomless well of antiblack violence

Mukasa Mubirumusoke 2022 [Assistant Professor in the Intercollegiate Department of Africana Studies at Claremont McKenna College “Black Hospitality A Theoretical Framework for Black Ethical Life” https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-95255-6]//sheima

This is not to imply that there is not class difference among black people. The black people listed at the beginning of the chapter as so-called beacons of progress do indeed live a much different life than the poor and working-class victims of violence that were named soon after (although a few of the former did not always live with money and may not continue in the future. There are real consequences for these class distinctions; for example, Skip Gates ultimately had a beer summit with the first black president after his confrontation with a police officer; meanwhile, Brionna Taylor did not even get a knock at the door before her demise. These different class experiences cannot be conflated and the black poor and working classes experience life differently, but that experience does attend to the ontological. The few black Americans that owned slaves, for instance, were not whitened; they had more money. Nevertheless, they were always vulnerable in a way that was not the same as even the poorest white people who may indeed perish from the consequences of their poverty. The qualitative distinction between white and black exceeds calculations and again only an appeal to the general economy of white supremacy can make sense of this distinction. The vulnerability of any proletariat can be overcome through hard work (some harder than others), but black vulnerability at the ontological level—which includes sudden death for no reason at all except the fact that one is black—cannot be ultimately mitigated by labor regardless of the neighborhood. Therefore, while it may not be the literal case that black people can be purchased as chattel slaves in 2020 (although the conditions in Libya may challenge even this contention), the nonrelation of blackness as vulnerable to anyone was set by a diremption between black and non-black centuries ago and this antagonism is constituted by the extra-ordinary, that is, illegible, accumulative, fungible, abject, objectifcation, and the open vulnerability that follows from it. From a materialist perspective, it is often argued that racism and sexism are used to obscure true class relations and create inessential hierarchies and intraclass confict. A Marxist or class critique may indeed allow one to see the exploitation at work behind the hypnotic light of our computer screens, but will that unmask the ‘ugliness’ of the affective economy and larger ethical dilemma of white supremacy? Let’s hear Wilderson explain in his own words: Anti-black violence is vital to the psychic well-being of White (and nonBlack) people everywhere. Violence against black people provides a sanctuary for White people, a guaranteed matrix of safety, security, and respite—respite from the otherwise unbearable hydraulics of their own family lives, and from the unbearable hydraulics of an ugly world that they have created and which they know, in the collective unconscious, to be ugly, though they can’t bring themselves to admit it is beyond redemption. (Wilderson III 2015, 148) Antiblack violence is vital in maintaining the hierarchy of the antiblack world, but as the parenthetical term intimates, the human also extends to those non-blacks, which Wilderson identifes as the ‘junior members’ of white civil society (Wilderson III 2007, 26) and who may also attend to the bottomless well of anti-blackness for their own constitution. These junior members are the familiar marginal political groupings, whether they be other people of color, other categories of identity regarding gender, sexual orientation, or even the  previously discussed political economic positions, such as the worker. It is hard not to recognize that this sort of malleability in terms of self-fortifcation is once again an attribute of the excessive economy of white supremacy as the gift that keeps on giving. In contemporary times we see the proliferation of identities that make claim to their marginal status over against the status quo and their legibility is not just symbolic differentiation. This may indeed mark their legibility as a given ‘exceptional’ categorical possibility, but the vitality of their stature is enriched or stabilized by comparing and distinguishing from blackness. All these junior members participate in the fortification of white civil society, only marginally, but still by way of anti-blackness. This is indeed a polemical contention, but it need not be so reductively interpreted as a ranking. Rather, the constitutive primacy of antiblackness serves as a tracing of the conceptual landscape, whereby it becomes clear where the ever so replenishing life force of what we recognize as the human or civil society springs from. Wilderson provides a number of examples of how such parasitic anti-blackness arises in everyday life from junior members. For instance, in the previously cited “Prison Slave” essay he cites the sort of anti-black subjection that Assata Shakur describes in her biography via a white woman in the abolitionist movement, concluding, “The verisimilitude between Assata’s well known police encounters and her experience in civil society’s most nurturing nook, the radical coalition, raises disturbing questions about political desire, black positionality, and hegemony as a mode of struggle” (Wilderson III 2007, 24). One question may be: what are the limits of non-black prison abolitionists when it comes to sacrificing for the greater good? Carceral punishment for even the most heinous crimes appears to be one thing that must go with the abolition movement, but even then, antiblackness cannot help itself from flourishing even in the most radical places. Also, in another example of the ever-expanding list of who finds respite in antiblackness, one may turn back to the essay “Afro-Pessimism and the End of Redemption,” where Wilderson recalls a conversation with a Palestinian friend whose cousin had died constructing a bomb. The friend then confded, in a moment of unfiltered grief, that the humiliation of the full body searches conducted by Israeli soldiers was worse when it was an Ethiopian Jew. Wilderson goes on to explain: I was faced with the realization that, in the collective unconscious, the Palestinian insurgent has more in common with Israeli state and civil society than s/he does with Black people. What they share is a largely unconscious consensus that Blackness is a locus of abjection to be instrumentalized on a whim. At one moment Blackness is a disfigured and disfiguring phobic phenomenon; at another moment Blackness is a sentient implement to be joyously deployed for reasons and agendas that have little to do with Black liberation … My friend’s and his country’s women’s and men’s negrophobogensis, is the bedrock, the concrete slabs upon which any edifice of human articulation (whether love or war) is built. (Wilderson III 2016) Antiblackness necessarily shades even the ‘micro-aggressions’ in the examples of Assata and Wilderson’s friend above. The white prison abolitionist and the Palestinian insurgent can sense the absolute abjection of blackness, and they gesture toward it to give themselves a glimpse at their own humanity, however much degraded by the violence they are subjected to via contingent violation as opposed to the gratuitous violence that black people may meet at a whim. Black vulnerability is of the same quality as theirs. While black people and the junior members share the category of occurrent, it is not pathogenic in the way of undermining autonomy or exacerbating any sense of powerlessness through particular actions that circumscribe their subjection. Instead, it is a vulnerability that is abject, that is discursively illegible or without origin, objectifying, psychically replenishing, and fortified by the dominant and marginal constituents of civil society, gratuitously, that is, without reason or dialectical reconciliation. Black vulnerability marks the parameters of human or subjective capacity through a broad coalition of policing the contours of the human and hardly human in a collective unconscious of antiblackness.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.