Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Their invocation of the feminine/masculine dichotomy confines black women into the archive of gender founded upon humanist categories that renders the black gender silent

Mukasa Mubirumusoke 2022 [Assistant Professor in the Intercollegiate Department of Africana Studies at Claremont McKenna College “Black Hospitality A Theoretical Framework for Black Ethical Life” https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-95255-6]//sheima

When regarding the functioning of the spectacular, it also cannot go unmentioned that black cisgender men have garnered the most attention and although the considerations here will avoid focusing on any event in too much detail, it should be noted this group is not exclusively subject to such violence. Patrice D. Douglass gives a very nuanced reading of gender and afropessimism as it follows in the wake of Spillers’ invocation of (un)gendering and the fashion in which femininity and masculinity are misnamed and misrecognized under white supremacy. Douglass explains: Juxtaposing the hyper-visibility of the death of Black men against the invisibility and silencing of the death of Black women opens a litany of trap doors. Placing the lens on how Black women die is not to demand that visual images of their deaths are repeated on social media networks and the nightly news at the behest of the pleasure of viewing Black suffering. In fact, the issue of Black gender is more complex than the dichotomization of death. Furthermore, to bifurcate Black gender, Black women up against Black men, achieves nothing more than reifying gender stratifcations that historically and experientially have never been made available to Black people. By shifting perspective, we might ask, how Black feminist politics account for the dead and dying inclusive of all genders? (Douglass 2018, 108) ¶ This concluding call, asked of and inspired by black feminism, thus demands, not the dismissal of gendered violence, but rethinking the juxtaposition and ossifcation of such identities that are never afforded through proper terms of gender, since they are only created through a violence to separate these black identities from the political ontology of the human. Black (un)gendering thus exposes with greater depth the ways in which black vulnerability exceeds all principles and categories of the human. To refer to Douglass one more time at length she elaborates: ¶ The archive of gender is structurally anti-black. Its assumptive logic, whether explicit in its presentation or not, maintains that all women have the same gender. This orientation of thought does more than render Black gender invisible or silent. It makes it conceptually impossible to think of gender violence as orienting more than the realm of gender. Rather than engaging a politic fixated on what binds women together in life, I want to draw focus to what separates Black women in death. What creates the conditions of (im)possibility for Black women to die? (Douglass 2018, 115)¶ Humans die; meanwhile, black women are hailed into existence by a violence that only permits their perishing. This reality needs to be kept in mind when we are thinking of the phenomenon of police violence. Violence against black women should not be ignored, but an increased media presence does not bring about human recognition; their absence is part and parcel of an anti-black violence that imposes gender differently, though for a similar end, that is, social (and real) death. Wilderson falls in line with much of what Douglass explicates and suggests that the media focus on the carceral violence received by black men only serves the purpose of reifying spectacular violence and offering a false sense of agency through assuming the human categories of gender. Gender for black people is not essential, it is a ‘borrowed institutionality” instrumentalized in strategic ways. In the end, the actions of police brutality, inclusive of all genders, are not simply spontaneous or isolated acts of individual anger; they serve the ends of white civil society inasmuch as its constituents, while recognizing a certain horror in police brutality, feel safe from the fears and dread of its reality in the space where it belongs, namely in the black community. Moreover, there is also pleasure derived in the negrophilic dalliance of a weekend warrior protestor where their confrontation with police actually can be dignifying. These spectacular images show to many that the police are doing their job, which explains the ex post facto justifcations of these black people as criminals even though the criminal records that these victims might possess actually points to the criminalization of their livelihood, that is, the banality of white supremacy. Again, the spectacles obscure all of this and serve to provide a “vital cultural labor” (Sexton and Martinot 2003, 176) Or as Sexton and Martinot state explicitly:¶ White supremacy is not reconstructed simply for its own sake but for the sake of the social paranoia, the ethic of impunity, and the violent spectacles of racialization that it calls the “maintenance of order,” all of which constitute its essential dimensions. The cold, gray institutions of this society – courts, schools, prisons, police, army, law, religion, the two-party system – become the arenas of this brutality, its excess and spectacle, which they then normalize throughout the social field. (Sexton and Martinot 2003, 180)

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.