Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Framework

Change in the debate space can only emerge from collective movements that are centered around intersectionality and relationships. Afro-pess works against movements to change the space – its nihilistic and individualized approach forecloses the possibility for change.

Thuli Gamedze and Asher Gamedze 19, MA in Education, Gender, and International Development from Michaelis, member of iQhiya(art collective); MA in African studies from University of Cape Town, 1-1-2019, "Anxiety, Afropessimism, and the University Shutdown," South Atlantic Quarterly, 118 (1), pp. 215-225, , kav

gamEdze: Just to clarify, “shutdown,” as we refer to it, was (or is) a tactic used by Black students at South African universities that emerged mainly during #feesmustfall in October 2015 and has been used since then in 2016 and 2017. The plan was to stop the university from operating and make it impossible for it to continue with business as usual. Arrest its academic program, hold it ransom, and pressure the management to agree to certain demands that were part of a much larger call for decolonization, which I suppose is what we are dealing with in this collection of texts. The end of outsourced labor and the call for free education have been the main material demands that somewhat unify the national shutdown periods, but the nature of the campaign and the broader demands depended a lot on students’ educational and political processes at the various campuses.

gamedZe: Of course “shutdown” is not a new revolutionary strategy; it has been used all over the world in different ways in different spaces. In our context we might see it as an extension, transplantation, and a micro-referencing of the anti-apartheid strategy of “ungovernability” that proliferated in the townships in 1980s South Africa. After 1994 there have been instances of Black students adopting a similar strategy, but until “mustfall,” the notion of shutdown had not taken on a “national” character.

In recent years, different campuses adopted different strategic approaches to shutting down. Some movements embarked on a live shut-down, moving class by class, rendering lectures and tutorials that were in operation impossible, triggering fire alarms, and mobilizing other students as they went. Others embarked on more preventative shutdowns, attempting to make it impossible for university to even begin, by barricading campus entrances with bins, bodies, and burning tires. These barricades and protest lines, the frontiers of “shutdown,” were met with extreme physical violence from the state police and hired private security forces. This violence— unimaginative masculinist aggression—provoked a response from students, which generally took on the mirrored form of masculinist resistance. Or at least, this was the newsworthy narrative, because, as disturbing as it is, we know that mainstream media has an unending masochistic capacity to absorb images of Black people being brutalized.

The image of the violated black body has strong ties to the politics of the Afropessimist. We feel that through the cycle of protest and violent repression, which continually produces and reproduces black people as “socially dead,” Afropessimism has fed deeply into the ways we think about protest.

gamEdze: I want to get a bit deeper into what you’re saying here, because I think it’s really important to consider the complex and somewhat contradictory role of Afropessimism in student movements. I’m interested in how these politics have been instrumentalized in the service of “shutdown” protests, as well as the ways that the ideology which informs political strategy plays into and is given life in the internal world of the movement. Before I get into the Afropessimism thing, though, let me set it up with an initial statement or belief that I hold.

We are all externally vulnerable to the violence of capital-driven time-space, and so it is the politics through which we live that can potentially offer us healing or, on the other hand, can exacerbate the problem.

A therapist once explained to me that anxiety and anger are place-holder emotions, and what she meant is that in order to explore the causes of our anxiety and anger and potentially soothe them, we must seek a place that is more internal, and perhaps less easy to understand and manage. This internal place is often one of deep sadness, and fear can render us reluctant to explore it. Thus anxiety and anger function to express our incapacity to manage the depth of ourselves in a given situation—they are ways the body defends and manages circumstances that hurt and can possibly damage us. Sadness, on the other hand, is a kind of giving up of the body to its own incapability to be okay—an abandonment of reactive behaviors to violent parameters, and an acceptance of a boundless present of despair. It is raw and difficult, but the experience of pain or sadness is often what allows us to come to terms with pervasive dissonances between our own spirit and the ways we are vulnerable to, and complicit in, the mismanagement of people in the world. My interest is in how our politics can contribute to, hinder, or interact with our emotional life, and how this has played out in the bits and pieces of the shutdown processes we know about.

gamedZe: That’s really interesting, thinking about the notion of a “place-holder politics” and their emotional corollaries. I wonder if it’s useful here to get into Afropessimism, or at least how we saw, understood, and experienced it within student movement spaces?

gamEdze: For sure, go ahead.

gamedZe: As I see it, briefly, Afropessimism is one political lens, set of ideas, or a vocabulary that has found significant traction in certain student movement spaces. This traction has brought with it a particularly nihilistic approach to protest. It could be interesting to think through this tendency toward protest along with some of the ideas you have set up.

gamEdze: Yes, so Afropessimism defines itself through understanding the world’s fundamental structure as “antiblack,” and thus sees black people as perpetually negated or “socially dead” and so absent from any conception of humanity.

gamedZe: Uh huh. And it seems to flatten out and homogenize Black people, reducing and owning the interpretation of Black peoples’ experiences by subordinating them to one supposedly absolute and totalizing logic.

gamEdze: It goes further by articulating that the maintenance of antiblackness is crucial in sustaining the psychic health of white people. In other words, the binary created through the construction of blackness versus whiteness is the logic through which white people are able to recognize themselves as human, and through which black people, too, see white peo¬ple as human, and negate themselves. While Afropessimism can be useful in identifying systems of power—for instance, the mutual relationship of the racist construct of “black people as criminals” with the legal system and the capitalist prison-industrial complex—it falls short itself by asserting that there exists no other state for the black body except perpetual death, so con-sistently caving in on itself.

gamedZe: So, in that, it fails on many levels to make sense of the nuanced ways in which people, despite their supposed nonexistence, exist in and navigate through the world. How does Afropessimism understand its social death in relation to queerness or disability—forms of otherness that also generate gratuitous violence, exclusion, and oppression? But also, this particular transplantation of the American thing (the origin of the school of thought) to the continent is pretty wack. Even as the Black radical tradition has largely been formulated and theorized in and from America, and even as it often falls prey to American exceptionalisms in its quest for forms of Black universalism, I think it holds radical potential for us on the continent. As many theorists and thinkers of the Black radical tradition have shown, African cultural practices have formed the basis of Black revolt across time and space. I see Afropessimism as a departure from that tradition’s dynamic foundations in African culture.

Afropessimism, through its fixation on natal alienation, tends to ignore the living connections to the continent, seeming to take the severance of African people from the continent through the middle passage as utter and complete. It therefore seems to understand Black people not as cultural subjects who brought entire cosmological worlds and practices with them but as hopeless, utterly dislocated beings only existing as the sum total of their position in white supremacy. While I think that this can be challenged even in a diasporic context, this contradiction is even more pronounced here on the continent, because although many of us are alienated from African cultural practices and contexts, those traditions persist and are more or less proximate whether or not one is immersed in them.

gamEdze: In this way, it can be difficult to move with the Afropessimist, whose American-specific engagement with a particular history defines the functioning of antiblackness, seen as a mechanism that forms the foundational reality of every scenario of oppression.

Afropessimism’s refusal to engage its own internal world, to abandon its reactive and defensive nature, leads me to imagine it as a “placeholder politics,” similar to the ways that anxiety and anger hold and protect us from entering the place existing beyond them. This is not to offer a clean critique on Afropessimism but to situate it as a politics that perhaps exists as external to something more effective in exploring and acknowledging the internal— the power and the pain.

Afropessimism finds no way to its own sadness.

gamedZe: The idea of “holding” the “place” is quite a nice one. And interesting to think about how, in relation to the continent, it is perhaps the anxiety or the anger of Afropessimism that holds the place that prevents or protects the descent into the deep sadness. Perhaps this is what Fred Moten (2003: 94), through Amiri Baraka, might refer to as “the tragic,” which “is always in relation to a quite particular and material loss,” in this case being “the impossibility of a return to an African, the impossibility of an arrival at an American, home.” The sadness of the tragic is too great.

gamEdze: Heavy ...

Let’s move back, or forward to the student movement, where we have seen Afropessimism function in a number of different ways. Because of the diverse and chaotic mixture of political ideologies under the “mustfall” umbrella, Afropessimism, like other politics, has been a collaborator, mixing sometimes productively, but often aggressively, with other political schools in the space, such as Black feminism, Marxism, and Charterism.

No one ever decided that “mustfall” would adhere to a single way of navigating, and thus we could find ourselves having to hold a number of contradictions, jumping between politics as we navigated the trauma of the external, and the ways we chose to deal with emotions of the internal. In this way, sometimes the reactive nature, the anxiety and anger of the placeholder politic of Afropessimism, functioned to hold the outsides, as different political ideas played out on the inside of the shutdown. I know that this thought experiment seems far neater than the muddiness of any reality of shutdown and occupation could possibly be. But we are using it because as far as we both critique Afropessimism, the way it has catalyzed in the mix of mustfall politics seems to have opened it up to something beyond its own imagination. On the outside, Afropessimism leads to a style of protest, to a style of retaliation, to a mode of policing, to a steering away of movements from initial strategy, to individualized acts of embodied resistance to the law.

gamedZe: On the barricades, forced into the form of protest that the state and security is prepared and equipped for—violent confrontation—there is no possibility of Afropessimism evolving into anything else because we run into the militarized trap set for us, with no possible escape.

gamEdze: On the inside, in the temporary “safety” offered by a successful shutdown, is the place where we can create.

gamedZe: That kinda comes back to what I think of as a classic revolutionary dialectic, of reaction and creation. It raises the question: was it necessary to react in that way in order to create? Did we have to adopt this nihilistic politics and dangerous bodily mode of protest to shut down the space such that we can then explore other possibilities?

gamEdze: This is such a fundamental question, and I personally don’t necessarily think so. Afropessimism to a large extent really upset the growth of Black feminist thought, at least in the shutdowns I have been involved in. Instead of providing an entry point into various political schools, black feminism—particularly intersectionality—seemed optional, forming just one of several political collaborators within the shutdown space. This approach was often read by Afropessimism and even black consciousness as an aggressor, or a “distracting” force within the movement. But intersectionality makes collective work possible.

Audre Lorde, much in keeping with intersectionality, is insistent on conscientizing difference, so that it escapes its usual trap of exploitation by the status quo. This approach to making activism is a depthy internal process of instrumentalizing and weaponizing one’s pain and power toward collective struggle (Audre Lorde 2012). It is in direct conflict with Afropessimism, which begins and ends through the arrest of blackness in singular form: a circular anxious reasoning that cannot explore its particularities and intersections, and so finds its imagination short-circuited by the binary understanding of power only through white supremacy.

If Afropessimism went to therapy, it might find, beneath its repeated anxious mantra of social death, a network of connected histories that have created layers and layers of power and oppression. This painful conscientization is the beginning of a process of shaping tools that can be used to transcend the defensive limitations of placeholder politics and can, rather, soothe the internal while launching a fiery attack on the oppressor. Lorde’s tool was poetry. And ours right now is this.

gamedZe: I’m thinking now of some of Toni Morrison’s work and how one gets a real sense from her stories, that, despite the horror, violence, and the trauma of racism, Black people have, and have always had, stories outside white terrorism. Not that the terror is ever fully absent, but she makes a political decision in her writing to center Black people rather than white supremacy, opening up different creative and political potentialities. Although one of her starting points might be a critique of racism, it is not her endpoint. And I think what we are interested in thinking about in relation to shutdown is the possibilities that open up when the campus is claimed and the spaces, under new management, have not yet been purposed. When you occupy a house successfully, what do you do in the house? If we are able to arrest the university, what kinds of potentialities emerge?

gamEdze: And further, to extend your question, if a particular mode of protest that is exclusionary is used in “shutting down” or securing the space, does this mean that the inevitable political landscape within that space is limited to this political tendency? Considering that the act of barricading requires a certain kind of bodily intervention which is often masculinist and exclusionary, can an Afropessimistic-led shutdown secure and open the space for an intersectional collectivity and loving place of study?

gamEdze: The connection is that a masculinist, exclusionary, body-based rupturing of space will easily lead to an exclusionary group consciousness that occupies spaces using the same guiding principles it did to secure that space, unless tasks are explicitly divided using an intersectional approach to plan for the people involved. It is well documented, although poorly publicized, that “mustfall” in most instances failed to challenge institutionalized ableism and built-in inaccessibility at South African universities, as much as it did racism, classism, and patriarchy.

gamedZe: Where the work happened well, it seemed to temporarily allow for a reconfiguring of relationships and roles insisted on by the university. For instance, the mobilization, organizing, and study that happened around the “OutsourcingMustFall” opened up new ways of relating between “workers” and “students.” These relationships were shifted, through organizing together and resisting white institutional order, from the rigid and distinct categories of the university, to being resituated within the framework of the Black family. In certain instances Black students spoke about workers as “our mothers and fathers” and workers related to students as “our children.” This was a radical departure from the way that the institution was intentionally curated, where to be a student means to have gained access to a world of more privilege than that rewarded for physical labor (for a further discussion, see Motimele, in this issue).

Following on from the Black family, what I think shutdown allowed for in its most generative expression was the possibility of a different way of being together. And interestingly, it was the possibility of a different way of being together and being at the university. The university was what was being shut down. Its normative mode of functioning was arrested. So in certain senses it was about not being at the university, because the university represents a space of not-being-together, or at least only being together in particular ways that are shaped and governed by notions of difference and hierarchy—ways that operate to preclude or prohibit collectivity.2 In that sense shutdown ruptured the university, using it as a site for anticapitalist experiments with/in time and space.

Some might say that that rupture forms a prefigurative moment—a prophetic enactment of a utopian future that is still, yet, or perhaps to come. Perhaps shutdown forms opposition to the obstacles blocking us from our true social nature?

Shutdown and the space of occupation didn’t, in any definitive or over-bearing way, stop the university being what it is. Even when these spaces were alive, while they might have been able to arrest and repurpose certain functions or buildings, they were only pockets or time-space capsules casting fleeting shadows on the hegemon’s place in the sun. But what we know to be true is that spaces of study and planning have always, at every historical moment, been casting shadow.

gamEdze: Yes, and I think that this is important, too, with our conversation around Afropessimism, which seems to assume that validity only exists in the hegemonic, where the nuances, characters, and textures of everyday social moments are seen to hold no radical value in resistance politics. Can Afropessimism make sense of the reality that no matter how you look at it, we are here, we are working, and we are of value to one another?!

gamedZe: Since its conception of the world seems so thoroughly and hopelessly centered on whiteness, Afropessimism seems unable to value the spaces between us as Black people and what we are able to create together. These collective spaces are only considered important within a “prefigurative frame,” as if they are enactments of the future we imagine in the present. Afropessimism seems to imply that the only possible way for it to value Black life would be following an absolute rupture, the moment of the end of the world, in other words, supposedly the cataclysmic end of whiteness. Afterward, everything is assumed to be different.

gamEdze: Yes. The potential for imagination in Afropessimism is dire. I’m also not very invested in the notion of prefigurative politics, but my main uncomfortability with it is concerned primarily with the “figure” in “prefigurative” because this presence seems to allude to the “endpoint,” or the future as existing in resolved and recognizable form. I find that concept to be itchy because this preoccupation with a figure and with a Western time constraint (implied in pre-) limits imagination to a linearity involved in making a finished thing. What we know is that radical work unapologetically occupies the present, and that “presents” are always in the process of realizing and shifting themselves, reluctant to stay seated or be neatened up as finished figures or symbols attesting to the triumph of an era. This image, or “figure,” sounds oddly like “democracy” and its various symbolic manifestations in post-1994 South Africa—the very era that has led us to these shutdowns in the first place. We should not shut down the possibility that if the “figure” of prefiguration exists, she should operate in motion, without certainty, and always be too present to capture.

gamedZe: I mean, where do you get your bars from? Damn. But beyond your bars, if I think about revolutionary movements on the continent, the historical imagination always suggests that a radical act in the present, even if it is a prefiguration of a desired future, it is also a postfiguration of a sometimes romanticized but nonetheless remembered, recollected past. I recall Cabral’s concept of the “return to the source”—the cultural/political movement of an alienated people away from the values and practices of the colonizer in the search and pursuit of those of their people, historically, the basis of the future society. We see this Cabralian impulse in God’s Bits of Wood, where Ousmane Sembène (1960) talks about what railway workers and their families did when they arrested capitalist time during the great 1947–48 Dakar-Niger railway workers’ strike. Sembène (1960: 75): “Ceremonies that went back to time immemorial were revived, and pageants that had long been forgotten. Men armed with staffs or cudgels performed the saber duels whose ritual dated back from the reign of El Mami Samori Touré. Women dyed their hands and their feet with henna enriched with the black of burnt rubber and coloured their lips with antimony.” There was a return to the source and a reinvigoration of the imperative to be in historically rooted motion, and it was the impossible time-space pocket wrought open by the strike’s initiation that made the cultural movements possible even as they existed in a broader context of colonial domination.

Similarly, if we think about shutdown as a parallel strategy, Black students shut the university down, and then we didn’t have to just be students. In that time-space we could be artists, intellectuals, African people, friends, comedians, musicians, writers, dancers, actresses, and we could be together. People were able to collectively create, learn, tell stories, teach, rap, laugh, cry, and sing in occupation in ways that I had never seen or even imagined in my almost ten years at and on the fringes of the university. It’s as if that arrested space allowed us to return to our true (following Marx to our social)3 nature; it allowed us to return to ourselves, to be with our internal world, and that means singing (being) together as a people.

Rejecting the white society requires agential capacity through the imagining of futures. Impositions of power – like the 1AC – erase agency and political power. Only debate – through discourse – can generate power to challenge the system.

Lewis Gordon 20, Editor of the American Philosophical Association Blog series Black Issues in Philosophy, American philosopher at the University of Connecticut, 2-6-2020, "The Sartrean Mind," Routledge, pp. 510-511, , kav

To belong to the future, however, entails a rejection of an isomorphic relationship between European/white and modern. Where this is so, it means the construction of other forms of temporal belonging. For blacks, this would mean a paradoxical transformation from black to Blacks. The first accepts the impasse; the latter, as transcending it, regards the future as a commitment to be made. In effect, that requires being agents of history, which means, then, that within blacks would become the possibility of Blacks. This argument is thus a demand for Black modernity. As any group who makes such moves effectively constitute its possibility, modernity would be decoupled from Europeanness and whiteness through an appeal to modernities. That would make Euromodernity one among many possibilities for the human condition. It would also mean identifying the extent to which, in making itself isomorphic with modernity, Euromodernity is a theodicy and, ultimately, a historic expression of la mauvaise foi. This understanding of taking on the responsibility for building a future can also be read as practices of liberation. It is an important feature of Black existential philosophy as offered by such philosophers as Biko, Birt, Fanon, Henry, Jones, Manganyi, and More, among others, as well as those in the literary existential traditions, including James Baldwin, Paula Marshall, Toni Morrison, and more. There are many elements of these thinkers’ writings pertaining to existential phenomenology; for example, each offers meditations on embodiment and the social impact on comportment. There are, as well, their detailed interrogations of oppression. What I offer here is just a hint. To close, there is one in particular on which I would like to offer some consideration. None of what I have argued makes sense without power. Unfortunately, the contemporary circumstance is one in which political discussions of power are dominated by two opposing views, both of which are premised on a reductive idea based primarily on the Anglo line of Euromodernity. It comes down to this: the right exercise it, while the left shun, at times even seem allergic to, it. This is because of the focus on coercive power in contemporary political life. The reasons for doing so aren’t entirely misguided. After all, what are colonialism, enslavement, and racism but abuses of power? Enrique Dussel observed that the effort to articulate the underlying grammar of Euromodernity as the Cartesian triumph of epistemology veils its underlying history of conquest. Instead of “I think, therefore I am,” the truth was actually “I conquer, therefore I am.”22 Sartre’s influence in Black existentialism This is patently the triumph of Hobbesianism, where in the hypothesized war of all against all, order is restored through the emergence of peace-establishing might. In this model, power is what is imposed, and its expansion in studies of class, engenderment, race, and sexual orientation includes ideas on interpellation. Naming becomes a sovereign beneath which suffer the named. Yet, as we have seen, what is imposed and what is lived are not identical. As with other phenomena, power could collapse into a theodicy, which reeks of la mauvaise foi. Where ill defined, power becomes a form of closure. It erases options, and in so doing becomes so claustrophobic that choice seems to disappear. We should, however, remember the insight on la mauvaise foi, which is that its intelligibility depends on freedom. Where power is read exclusively as an imposition erases the agency of those upon whom it is imposed. Whether the gods, language, or the sovereign, the point remains that agency somewhere raises the question of how it is to be understood elsewhere. Masking this requires avoiding resources of communication, critique, evidence, and meaning. The communicability of power raises the question of its transcendence of efforts at unilateral meaning. Despite attempts to make reality what one may say it is, what it could be is always more. Power is the ability to make things happen with access to the means of doing so. Where locked in the reach of the physical, it offers no difference from force. Human reality, however, offers resources of transcending physical location through communication, meaning, and the ongoing production of social reality. This could be reformulated as the proliferation of options. A human being need not be where the effects of her or his actions take place. The ability to make things happen with the means of doing so also includes, then, the ability not only to increase access to the means but also the cultivation of other means. We could call this positive power. Coercive power, which we could also call negative power, involves decreasing such access. This amounts to power’s relationality. The error is to think about what power “is” instead of what power is about, which is what at least human beings do. The human world is to some extent what Freud called a prosthetic god.23 Living in a world of limited material options, human beings have managed to produce a world of prosthetic materiality. We could call this form of materiality “options.”24

Having prepared debates where we imagine and compare the advantages of different futures is key to progress in society. Questioning underlying assumptions and conclusions provides skills for activism and furthering society. Empirics prove – black debate caused social change.

Brittney Cooper 16, Ph.D. in American Studies from Emory, B.A. in English and Political Science from Howard University, co-editor of The Crunk Feminist Collection, author,6-19-2016, "Take No Prisoners: The Role of Debate in a Liberatory Education," Using Debate in the Classroom, pp. 11-21, https://doi.org/10.4324/9781315707808, kav

In October 2015, the Black Lives Matter (BLM) movement petitioned the Democratic National Committee (DNC) to sponsor a presidential debate with candidates for the 2016 election, focused solely on the concerns of the BLM. The DNC declined the request for debate but did offer to help the BLM host a presidential candidate forum or townhall. This led to a series of conversations about the structure and format of public debates and townhalls, and about which form of activity would allow Black publics to interact substantively with those politicians seeking to lead the country. The BLM’s request for a presidential debate came just weeks after news of a group of prison inmates in a maximum-security prison in upstate New York defeated a group of Harvard University debaters. The incarcerated debaters were students in the Bard Prison Initiative, a program housed at Bard College, that offers college coursework to inmates.

More than 60 years ago, Malcolm X honed his oratorical talents on a prison debate team. Today communities of color have been ravaged by the far-reaching effects of the prison industrial complex, and its role in the enforcement of tough-on-crime policies that have led to the mass incarceration of Black and Latino/a men and women. Far too many of our youth have a better chance of encountering debate training in prison than in the classroom. This is unacceptable. Bringing debate into prisons offers us a clear picture of the kind of intellectual talents that continue to languish behind bars. And the issue of mass incarceration and over-policing of Black communities is one of the critical issues that the BLM has placed on the agenda as a critical topic for public debate and liberation.

Together these examples demonstrate that participating in and understanding how debates work are a critical part of active participation in a democracy. Moreover, having access to good debating skills is a critical literacy to which all students should have access. The ability to understand and evaluate the relative merits of competing positions is not merely an intellectual exercise. These skills materially impact the quality of life of American citizens and all people. Moreover, when matters of rights and freedoms are involved, these skills become increasingly important. If students do not know how to both ascertain and evaluate the key premises and ideas behind the range of arguments that emerge in American politics, arguments that inevitably shape their own quality of life, then our students have not been well educated and they have not been adequately prepared to be engaged and thoughtful citizens.

In the first few decades immediately following the end of slavery, Black communities placed an extremely high value not only on access to a good-quality public education, but also on access to a robust public sphere in which Black communities, including women, men and children, could come and debate issues that mattered. They wanted access to spaces in which they could litigate qualities of leadership, strategies and plans for racial advancement, and general ideas about what it meant to be Black in the slowly receding shadow of enslavement. For communities deeply invested in the quest for freedom, the right to have opinions and to publicly share and deliberate about those opinions served as a mark of freedom. Similarly, in the contemporary moment, the burgeoning Black Lives Matter movement acknowledges that our movements are made clearer and sharper through robust and vigorous debate, disagreement, and consensus-building. But in order for leaders to use those skills as adults, they must first learn them in the classroom.

This chapter offers a brief history of debate within Black communities in the period between Emancipation and the Civil Rights Movement, with a particular focus on debate activities from the 1920s through the 1960s. Community debate programs and the emergence of collegiate debate in this period fit on the one hand with the importance of debate in the creation and cementation of a Black public sphere, but it also sets the stage for the cultures of debate that emerge during the Civil Rights Movement. The range of questions and issues with which these earlier communities concerned themselves are instructive for how educators might use debate in classrooms today. Therefore, I interrogate the manner in which local communities in the first half of the 20th century thought about the importance of debate as a form of political education for citizens. Then I turn briefly to a few of the iconic debates that took place during the Civil Rights Movement. These stories offer a vital and necessary reminder that the expansion of American democracy always requires a commitment to vigorous and sustained debate. In light of that history, we should consider debate a vital part of a good education.

In May of 1892, Ida B. Wells, a journalist and newspaper owner in Memphis, Tennessee, launched a career as a public intellectual and advocate after three of her friends were lynched. After she wrote a blistering editorial in her paper, the Memphis Free Speech & Headlight, townspeople burned down the newspaper’s office and banished Wells from town. She fled to Brooklyn, New York, where she stayed with the famous African American poet and writer Frances Ellen Watkins Harper. In New York, Wells ensconced herself in a vibrant social scene that included the weekly meetings of many African American literary societies, where participants would perform musical selections, give talks about prepared papers and engage in formal debates.

Copyright 0 2016. Taylor & Francis Group. All rights reserved. One popular outlet for such debates was the Bethel Literary Association in New York. There debates which pitted pairs of debaters against each other covered a wide range of topics including “Resolved, that we need wealth more than we do education”; “Resolved, that we should encourage western emigration”; “Labor is a greater power than capital”; “That we owe no party a debt of gratitude”; and “That we need industrial more than academical education” (Peterson, 2011, pp. 346–347). Carla Peterson (2011) notes that the Bethel Literary Association was remarkable for its inclusion of female debaters: “Not only did women now share a public venue with men, but they argued with them over policy on equal terms” (pp. 347–348).

The leading Black lyceum in the city, the Brooklyn Literary Union, known for its debates, was less welcoming to women. The Union had strict debating guidelines. Four debaters gave ten-minute presentations. Then there was a 45-minute discussion, followed by a vote from the audience (Giddings, 2008, p. 234). Women were rarely among those featured as lecturers or debaters. However, during the late summer or early fall of 1892, Wells participated in a debate at the Brooklyn Literary Union, against, among others, Maritcha Lyons, a well-respected school principal from an old New York family. Though Wells had been gaining a local reputation as a compelling speaker, Lyons bested her in the debate. Wells took defeat in her stride, adopting Lyons as her mentor.

Lyons, together with Victoria Earle Matthews, another active member of the Brooklyn Black literati, put together the event that launched Wells’s formal career as a public lecturer. In their mentor–mentee relationships, Lyons imparted to Wells two main lessons. “‘Be so familiar with your discussion that you are literally saturated with it; think, meditate, and reflect, to develop all the points in a logical sequence.’ Lyons also told Wells to learn how to ‘manage the voice; if thought is prolific, expression of ideas will become automatic’” (Giddings, 2008, p. 235). In the ensuing months and years after her encounter with Lyons, Wells went on to become the most visible and vocal anti-lynching advocate of her generation, helping for the next 30 years to bring visibility to the epidemic of lynchings of African American men, women and children. By the early 1910s, the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (NAACP) made anti-lynching one of its key political issues, largely because of the public foundation laid by Ida B. Wells.

In the mid 1920s, Pauli Murray, a famous Civil Rights attorney, writer, professor, and the first Black woman to be ordained an Episcopal priest, joined the debate team of the Hillside High School, the newly built “colored” high school for students in Durham, North Carolina. “We had a debating team, a glee club, organized baseball, boys’ and girls’ basketball teams, a school newspaper, and a yearbook,” she wrote (Murray, 1987, pp. 59–60). All of these were “innovations utterly new to colored high school students in our town” (Murray, 1987, pp. 59– 60). Moreover, she wrote, “our sports teams and debating team competed with those of other high schools in the state, and it was the first time that colored students in Durham had an opportunity to travel to other cities and expand our horizons. These modest advances were important milestones for us. They sustained our hope and gave us a sense of achievement at a time when the prevailing view that Negroes were inherently inferior remained unchallenged” (Murray, 1987, pp. 59–60). Murray suggests that access to a debate team and other modern forms of extracurricular activity increased the rigor of her educational experience and chipped away at the sense of inferiority that a separate and unequal system of public education had produced in Black children, an argument that would be critical to the overturning of the Plessy decision in 1954. Moreover, debate and other activities marked the modernization of the American high school. Among many firsts, Pauli Murray graduated at the top of her class at Howard University Law School in 1944, producing a senior thesis that formed the basis for the legal strategy in the Brown desegregation decision. In addition to her work on the inclusion of the word “sex” in the 1964 Civil Rights Act, Murray also played a role in the dismantling of the all-white, all-male jury system. The first seeds of her voluminous career as a writer, thinker, academic, and poet undoubtedly had some of their genesis in the years she spent “preparing for inter-high school debates on the debating team.”

This abbreviated history of Black debaters is a critical part of the intellectual and political history of African American people. To trace that history offers us a picture of the intellectual environs in which African American people honed and refined the arguments and strategies that shaped Black political discourse in the period between the end of Reconstruction and the Civil Rights Movement. This history of Blacks in debate also gives us a picture of the kind of training that it took to shape an African American leadership class in the post-slavery period. The robust cultures of debating that Black people created in the antebellum North and then throughout the country after Emancipation were critical in building a Black public or counterpublic sphere, a place where Black people could debate together about the collective fate of African Americans. In these nascent iterations of a Black public sphere, gender politics, and more specifically the participation of women, constituted a site of battle; thus, I began with the women because it is important to make visible the variety of ways that women participated in and helped to fundamentally shape the inter-workings of these spaces.

Several years ago, while I was conducting research for a project on the African American Club Women’s Movement in Shreveport, Louisiana, in the pages of the Shreveport Sun, the state’s oldest Black weekly, I unexpectedly began to see prominent front-page headlines advertising the debates of Black colleges near and far. For instance, the front page of the May 28, 1927 issue of the Sun proudly proclaims “Wiley College Debating Team Defeats Howard Univ, 3 Points.” The famed Wiley College debate team was frequently the focus of the Sun’s coverage, in part because Marshall, Texas, home of Wiley College, is located only 30 miles from Shreveport, just across the Texas state line.

Debate and forensic activities were so popular in Shreveport that Black women who participated in the club movement also staged debates about particular issues. In one such debate, the town’s Mary Church Terrell Club debated the topic “Resolved: That the South offers greater inducements and better advantages to our people than any other part of the country” (“Negative win in Debate”, 1927). Mrs. Z. E. Baker and Mrs. R. E. Brown argued the affirmative; the club’s president Cora M. Allen and Mrs. Alice Davis argued the negative. In 1927, African Americans were exiting the South in droves as part of the Great Migration to the North in search of better jobs and more reasonable racial conditions. As fairly well-to-do club women with stable middle-class existences, women like Cora Allen, wife of the Rev. Luke Allen who pastored the largest Black church in town, were part of cadre of Black people who opted not to migrate. But the team of Allen and Davis prevailed in the debate, effectively defending the advantages of leaving the South. The debate is important, however, because it makes clear that the choice of whether to migrate or not, was in fact a debate, rather than a foregone conclusion.

The Sun covered a range of forensic activities, including those of Black colleges and universities throughout the country, and also debates at local churches and high schools. For instance, in 1928 the paper highlighted a story of a woman who had beaten a man in debate at the Galilee Baptist Church on the topic “Resolved: That woman has done more for humanity than man.” The article noted that “it was fairly proven by Miss Shelton that woman had done more for humanity than man. Mr. Bounds made some strong points but came out ten points. The Sun’s coverage of community forensic activities was commensurate with coverage from other newspapers throughout the country. In the early 1920s, the Chicago Defender also covered college and community debate activities. In 1923, the Grace Lyceum in Chicago had a debate on the topic “Slavery has been more of a help than a hindrance to the American Negro” (“Young Women Win Debate”, 1928). An event sponsored by the “Older Girls and Young Woman’s Conferences” and the young men’s council, the teams were split on the basis of gender. The young men argued the affirmative position and the girls argued the negative position. The young women won. In 1924, another Chicago paper, the Broad Ax, covered the annual Elbridge L. Adams Prize Debates held at Hampton Institute (“Douglass Society Wins Adams Debate”, 1924). That year the Douglass Literary Society beat the Dunbar Literary Society debating the topic, “Resolved: That compulsory military training should be abolished in secondary schools.” The Douglass Society team argued the negative.

In 1932, the Sun reported that there had been “a revival of intercollegiate debating activities among the schools of the South Central Association of Colleges for Negro Youth.” Among those schools were Southern University, Straight College, Alcorn State University, Leland College, and the University of New Orleans. The subject under consideration during the spring 1932 debating season was “Resolved: That Great Britain should give India complete and immediate independence” (“Southern Debaters Win”, 1932). These young Black students were engaged in debates over British imperialism and the ethics and value of anti-colonialism in the 1930s. The broad national coverage of community and college debate activities in the Black Press suggests that locally and nationally Black communities valued vigorous debate and discussion and also that they took great pride in seeing young African Americans engage in these activities. The topics also suggest that conversations in Black public culture attended to more general questions of history and social relationships between the sexes as well as debates about contemporary political issues like mandatory military training and the ethics of colonialism. The debates themselves, audience participation, and coverage in the Black Press all participated in raising community literacies and consciousness around these important political issues that certainly had implications for Black communities living in the thick of Southern Jim Crow regimes.

Interracial debates constituted another major aspect of the Black Press’s coverage of Black participation in debate. In May 1923, Lewis Burrell, a debater and team captain at Pleasantville High School in Pleasantville, New Jersey, led his white teammates to victory debating Haddonfield High School on the question “Resolved: That the Merchant Marine of the United States should be subsidized by the federal government” (“Leads White Team Mates”, 1923). In the 1930s, these interracial exchanges became even more common, particularly among college debaters. In 1932 the Wiley College debaters embarked on a 10,000-mile Goodwill Tour, doing exhibition debates throughout the country. The Sun reported that “As a means of promoting better understanding between the races, Wiley has sought to make contacts with some of the white colleges thru [sic] their debating teams.” The paper reported that their interactions with teams in Oklahoma, Michigan and Chicago were gratifying, pleasant and profitable.

In 1933, teams from Wiley and the University of Kansas debated the topic “Resolved: That Socialism would be preferable to Capitalism in the United States.” Wiley argued the affirmative while Kansas argued the negative. The Sun ran this as the lead story in their March 4th issue, with the headline “Interracial Debate Gets Big Ovation.” Above the masthead, another headline proclaimed, “Inauguration of a New United States President Today” (“Interracial Debate Gets Big Ovation”, 1933). Franklin D. Roosevelt began his first term in office this same day. That an interracial gathering of student competitors from the Midwest and South came together in the early 1930s in the wake of the Great Depression and on the verge of Roosevelt’s New Deal to debate the merits of socialism versus capitalism suggests that debates were ideal spaces for capturing the political zeitgeist. Moreover they created opportunities for students from different racial, geographical and cultural backgrounds to come together in a meeting of minds over big ideas. In 1939, the University of Chicago Debate Union traveled to historically Black Lincoln University in Missouri to debate the topic, “Why go to college: To learn how to live or to learn how to make a living” (“Hold Round-Table Discussions”, 1939). A picture of the interracial group of debaters sitting and dialoguing ran with the article in the Shreveport Sun providing a powerful visual demonstration to the Black readership of the Sun about the importance of debate to the work of racial advancement.

The broad swath of issues covered in these debates and the fact that local audiences flocked to see them suggests that local communities were politically engaged and that this engagement was intergenerational, encompassing the political ideas of both the young people who primarily participated in these debates and those adults and elders who served as judges and audience members for such debates. The editorial board of the Sun believed that space for discussion and debate was critical to the public life of the city. A 1938 editorial argued that “a city with a colored population as large as ours should have” among other things “a Forum where current questions could be discussed and debated” and “a debating society which might engage in forensic contests with neighboring colleges on important questions of the day” (“More Cultural Organizations Needed”, 1938). The clear attention to debate in the press coverage of cities as disparate as Shreveport, Louisiana, and Chicago, Illinois in the 1920s and 1930s suggests that forensic activity was a critical building block not only of African American educational settings but also of African American public culture in the two decades before the formal inauguration of the modern Civil Rights Movement.

As the Civil Rights Movement came to full articulation, beginning with desegregation in 1954 and the Montgomery Bus Boycott of 1955, the importance of formal debate and discussion took on a different meaning. Now Black communities needed to think both ideologically and tactically about what the goals of this latest iteration of the Black freedom struggle were and how to go about achieving them. Many of these debates played out formally among Black male leaders who advocated a liberal integrationist view of the Civil Rights Struggle and those who advocated a radical Black nationalist view. Chief among the Black nationalists was Malcolm X, leader of the Nation of Islam, and a staunch opponent of the philosophy of non-violence that undergirded the public face of the Civil Rights Movement.

As is well documented, Malcolm X honed his oratorical skill as part of the Norfolk Penal Colony Debating Program, during his stint as a prisoner there in the late 1940s and early 1950s. Robert James Branham writes that “Malcolm X was a brilliant debater, adept at dismantling the positions of his opponents, converting their arguments to his own advantage, and most importantly casting the issues of dispute in utter and compelling clarity” (Branham, 1995, p. 117). Malcolm X valued debating as a form of political speech, because, as he famously said in his autobiography:

Standing up there, the faces looking at me, the things in my head coming out of my mouth, while my brain searched for the next best thing to follow what I was saying, and if I could sway them to my side by handling it right, then I had won the debate – once my feet got wet, I was gone on debating.

(As cited in Branham, 1995, p. 121)

Despite the fact that Malcolm X became a debater and formidable political thinker while in prison, the presence of the prison debate program represented a moment where prisons were viewed as social apparatuses that could appropriately redirect and prepare inmates for productive lives as citizens upon their release (Branham, 1995, p. 118). In an earlier era, even prisons recognized that teaching people to debate was nothing less than preparing them for a critical and engaged form of participation in democracy.

When Malcolm X was released from prison in the 1950s, now a convert to Islam, he moved to Harlem where he refined his thinking as a street preacher and minister of the Nation of Islam. As the Civil Rights Movement matured, Malcolm X emerged as the most formidable intraracial adversary of Martin Luther King and those proponents of a liberal Civil Rights Tradition. He engaged in a number of debates both throughout the United States and famously in England at the Oxford Union a few months before his death (see also Ambar, 2014; Tuck, 2014). Within the U.S. on more than one occasion he debated Civil Rights figures like James Farmer and Bayard Rustin. Martin Luther King refused to debate Malcolm X, and most Civil Rights leaders were afraid to take him on in public as well, because of his history of fiercely routing his opponents (Ogbar, 2004).

In October 1961, Malcolm X debated Bayard Rustin, one of the key tacticians of the nonviolent direct action strategy, on the campus of Howard University. The topic was “Integration or Separation.” Each man “spoke for about thirty minutes followed by a ten-minute rebuttal for each.” E. Franklin Frazier, the famous sociologist and author of The Black Bourgeoisie, moderated the event. In the audience on the front row that night sat a young, spellbound Stokely Carmichael. Before this night, Carmichael had been a devotee of Rustin’s non-violent teachings. Freshly back on campus after a summer spent in Nashville organizing with the Student Non-Violent Coordinating Committee (SNCC) and participating in the Freedom Rides organized by James Farmer and the Congress of Racial Equality, Stokely was jubilant when he heard that Malcolm X was planning to visit the campus (Joseph, 2014). Carmichael biographer Peniel Joseph argues that Malcolm’s lecture “galvanized racial pride at Howard. He planted seeds of political conversion that would turn many in the audience, over time, into ardent Black nationalists, committed Pan-Africanists, and lifelong political radicals.” Carmichael, who would go on to be a key architect of the Black Power Movement, was one such figure.

Joseph writes that “Malcolm’s physical swagger and intellectual bravado made a lasting impression on Carmichael” (Joseph, 2014, p. 42; see also Ogbar, 2004, p. 54).

James Farmer, national director of the Congress of Racial Equality, proved that when it came to formal debates, swagger and bravado weren’t everything. From 1934 to 1938 Farmer served as member and eventually captain of the famous Wiley College debate team. Thus, unlike his fellow Civil Rights counterparts, he was unafraid to debate Malcolm. And he proved to be X’s most formidable opponent. On March 7, 1962, the two debated each other at Cornell University also on the topic “Integration or Segregation.” This debate represented a convergence of the intellectual, rhetorical and political traditions that brought African Americans into the realms of formal debate, Farmer emerging through Black collegiate debate channels and X emerging from the environs of the prison debate and street preaching.

By all accounts, Farmer bested Malcolm in the first showdown in 1962. Tactically, because Farmer had the first speech in the debate, he laid the historical groundwork for the evils of Jim Crow and segregation. Because X was known to recite a litany of these evils in order to make the case against segregation, by covering that ground first, Farmer claimed the prerogative to reframe the terms. The evils of segregation that instilled a sense of inferiority in Black children, distorted the perceptions of white people about their own supposed superiority, and hurt American business through boycotts, were all reasons, in Farmer’s estimation, to support a robust program of integration. Where X frequently cast integrationists as passive recipients of white supremacist treatment, Farmer argued that it was prior generations of Black people, people in his father’s generation, who had thought “that the way things always had to be and they always would be, so we put up with it, took part in it, decided to exist and stay alive” (as cited in Bosmajian, 1969). In recounting this story with his father, James Farmer Sr., who on his deathbed gave the younger James his blessing to participate in the 1961 Freedom Rides, Farmer situates those actively involved in the desegregation struggle as those who are committed to racial progress. He casts X’s desire, vis-à-vis the Nation of Islam, for a separate Black nation-state as the politically retrograde position, one that moved Black people from “forced ghettoism” to “voluntary ghettoism” (as cited in Bosmajian, 1969).

Farmer also pre-empted X’s attempts to discredit him as a race man because he had married a white woman. He argued simply that he believed enough in the “virtue of Negroes that I do not even think those virtues are so frail that they will be corrupted by contact with other people” (as cited in Bosmajian, 1969). Finally, and most compellingly, Farmer took on Malcolm’s claim that the desire for integration was a bourgeois desire. He argued that historically members of the Black middle class were often against integration because it would hurt Black businesses through competition with white business owners. By the time Malcolm attempted to refute this argument by saying that Farmer still only spoke for a minority of Blacks rather than the majority, the rhetorical heft of his claim has been sufficiently mitigated.

In a subsequent debate with James Baldwin in September 1963, he and Malcolm X tangled masterfully over which accounts of identity, and which accounts of history, Black people should accept as a guide for moving forward. Baldwin challenged Malcolm’s desire to identify solely with the African or Black part of his heritage and not with the American and white parts of his heritage, particularly the histories of violence, rape and enslavement with which such histories would demand we all grapple. Malcolm simply replied that no other group was asked to give up its cultural and racial identifications in service of identifying with American history. Malcolm challenged the continuing investment of Civil Rights leaders in non-violent strategies, saying to Baldwin, “never do you find white people encouraging other whites to be non¬violent.” In other words, such tactics in Malcolm’s estimation followed a set of rules about non-violence to which white Americans themselves did not even subscribe. In this debate, there were no clear winners and losers. But what emerges is a picture of a robust culture of public debate among African Americans about the proper ends, aims and goals of the Black freedom project. The Civil Rights Movement and the subsequent Black Power Movement were conceived in a culture of rigorous and powerful debates, the most public of which occurred among Black men, about the ways that history, notions of identity, religion and the politics of power should inform the quest for African American freedom.

Whether we are talking about the life of anti-lynching crusader Ida B. Wells in the post-Reconstruction era or Malcolm X during the Civil Rights Movement, it is simply impossible to understand the rich ideological terrain upon which the quest for African American freedom grew without talking about the importance of formal debates and forensic activity. In the nineteenth century, such activities were critical to the formation of a Black public sphere, as Black people were actively involved in imagining and reimagining their relationship to the larger American body politic in the decades leading up to and following Emancipation. After true emancipation, followed by a century of Jim Crow segregation, proved elusive, the necessity of African American oratical skill and rhetorical prowess became even more important to Black communities throughout the country. Parents wanted their children to have debate training, local communities tried to create debating societies, and the Black Press invested in coverage of high school and collegiate debates both to foster pride in African American achievement and to creatively highlight how issues important to Black people were being engaged publicly. The many debates that took place over the course of the Civil Rights Movement then emerge not as tangential but rather as central and fundamental to steering the course of the movement. As the most vocal proponent of a Black nationalist framework, Malcolm X forced the Civil Rights Movement and its leaders to refine its message, even as his status as the more radical foil to King made King’s arguments about inclusion seem imminently more reasonable and attractive to liberal white Americans.

Teaching students to debate means teaching students to invest deeply in the power and possibilities of ideas. Teaching students to debate means teaching them to question more fully and more deeply. Teaching them to debate means that we foster dissatisfaction with easy answers. Debate training emerges as a kind of boot camp for those students who really want to know what it means to grapple with and solve problems that do not have easy or absolute answers. Each of the major leaders profiled here used debate training to push America to be a more inclusive democracy. Ida B. Wells, Pauli Murray, Malcolm X, James Baldwin and James Farmer stood on the frontlines of public discourse, challenging our country to tell ugly truths and to change. Debate helped to teach them how to be the courageous leaders that they were. In a moment when a whole new generation of activists, leaders, thinkers and movers are taking to the street as part of the Black Lives Matter movement, the resonances of these earlier movements insinuate themselves. These earlier movements and the debates on which they stood remind us that the quest for freedom demands our best thinking, and that our best thinking is frequently a product of work in community and contestation with others who are as deeply invested as we are. At the same time, these debates remind us of the importance of civility and respect and a mutual appreciation for the importance of ideas. For no great movement for social justice has ever been achieved without debate.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.