Essentialism DA
Afropess oversimplifies history into a struggle between Humans versus Slaves – that forecloses any possibility for change and ignores all other oppression.
José Sanchez 22, PhD student in history at Duke University, 6-13-2022, "Against Afro-Pessimism," Jacobin, , kav
But the rise of “Afro-pessimism” as a philosophy in academic and intellectual spaces threatens to undermine a politics rooted in such a sense of solidarity, in favor of one that essentializes black identity and exceptionalizes black suffering as intrinsically unanalogous to the oppression of other people. Afro-pessimism argues that “anti-blackness” trumps all other systems of oppression and exploitation, whether the racism that faces nonblack people of color such as Palestinians or indigenous Americans, antisemitism, capitalism, sexism, or transphobia.
At the core of this philosophy is the belief that the world’s basic breakdown of humans is between Humans and Slaves, with the latter being the cross that all black people of every distinction are born to bear to their grave regardless of status or class. The essence of blackness is to be a slave, at every level and in every sense.
By grouping together all blacks today as slaves — from striking black Starbucks baristas to black presidents, millionaires, and landlords — Afro-pessimism’s proponents render a socialist anti-racist politics null and void. After all, if you cannot solve the problem of racism because to be black means to be essentially and eternally enslaved, then you cannot change it. By placing race and blackness outside of history, Afro-pessimism makes white supremacy unsolvable. Furthermore, by dividing the world in all of its mind-boggling complexity into a battle between blacks and nonblacks or between Humans and Slaves renders solidarity amongst blacks and others impossible and the presence of a black ruling-class invisible.
The problems with this approach are many: Afro-pessimists take the flattened definitions of blackness preached by white supremacists — a state of universal and transhistorical abjection — seemingly at their word and warp it into a badge of pride, as black people become a race of eternal victims. But what is particularly troubling about this schema is the fact that Afro-pessimists reserve much of their ire not for the overwhelmingly white bourgeoisie who lord over Western societies, and they remain largely silent around the sexism as well as the homo-/transphobia facing black women and queers, because anti-blackness is believed to be uniquely worse than other forms of identity-based discrimination.
By placing race and blackness outside of history, Afro-pessimism makes white supremacy unsolvable.
The ire of Afro-pessimists is rather reserved for other people of color. Asians, indigenous Americans, and other nonblack people of color, such as even Palestinians, are categorized as the “junior partners” of white supremacy and racial capitalism. The Afro-pessimist argument is that whites and nonblack people of color are so psychologically invested in not being burdened with the enslaving essence of blackness that solidarity with blacks in any sort of political struggle is ultimately a fool’s errand.
Beset on all sides by enemies or false friends, the only logical conclusion to this worldview would be black separatist politics — a tired and exhausted politics, if there ever was one. Afro-pessimism is the old wine of black nationalism and separatism in the new bottle of an alienated black middle-class intelligentsia.
At a certain level, one can understand why Afro-pessimism appears to be on the rise in certain academic quarters: despite the ascendancy of a select few black people into US politics and business, American racism still rages on, most gruesomely sensationalized in police killing after police killing of innocent black people. Racism is everywhere. Yet the racism faced by a black single mother in a housing project in Jamaica, Queens is evidently different from the experiences of tenured black academics and graduate students at predominantly white Ivy League universities.
This is the classic history of ethno-racial nationalist and separatist ideologies. Claiming to speak on behalf of an ideologically constructed “nation” or “race,” the educated, bourgeois sections of an ethnicity or racial group suppress class and other divisions within the group in order to amass power. By propagating the idea of universal injury, an elite within such a community can deflect attention from the enactment of their power either against the social lessers or in brokering power with existing, traditional elites outside of the so-called race or nation.
This dynamic is also the story of another flavor of diasporic ethno-nationalism: Zionism. Afro-pessimism and Zionism rip identity-based oppressions out of their historical contexts, conjure up essential identities in their place, and mock multiracial coexistence and integration as mere fantasies.
For Afro-pessimists, nonblacks will forever leech and feast off of black suffering, all of history reduced to an unrelenting anti-blackness. As for Zionists, antisemitism is everywhere, in every time. Such pessimistic and nationalistic worldviews halt the ability to extend solidarity across different forms of oppression. They are thus the opposite of the socialist project’s goal of building a coalition of the vast majority of the working class across lines of race, ethnicity, and other divisions. By mystifying and flattening black identity, Afro-pessimism robs its followers of the ability to discern class and other divisions among black people themselves — eerily similar to how Zionists cannot recognize the world-historic irony of an oppressed minority, Jews, donning the role of oppressor in another context, the settler-colonial state of Israel.
Essentializing blackness erases intersectional antiblackness– those are key to mitigating antiblackness.
Greg Thomas 18, teaches global Black Studies texts out of the English Department at Tufts University, founding editor of PROUD FLESH, January 2018, "Afro-Blue Notes:The Death of Afro-pessimism (2.0)?" Theory & Event, 21(1), p. 293-295, muse.jhu.edu/article/685979, kav
This tradition is not a tradition in Wilderson who regularly critiques the analogical arrogance of Marxism, feminism, and an academic paradigm of "post-colonialism" with less common reference to "queer" or "gay and lesbian" categories of analysis as well—all in the name of pessimism. For him, none of these political frameworks with their privileged identarian subjects can capture the condition of "Blackness" and "slavery" (or "the Black/Slave"). While that perspective can allow for some insights—ones certainly seen before around the Black world and ones certainly avoided by so much institutional scholarship—it leaves the general categorical grid of established Western political epistemologies intact. The familiar academic terrain of "race, gender, class, and sexuality" frames the critique for "Blackness" of "gender, class, and sexuality" in addition to "post-coloniality" or "post-colonialism." The most conventional US academic categories of identity and analysis are still rendered in full as discrete, monolithic, and monological categories and referents (e.g., workers, women, etc.), like the respective political ideologies based upon them in the traditional ideological history of the white West (e.g., Marxism, feminism, etc.). There are "workers" and then there are "women," generically, and then sometimes there are "gays" by whatever name, not to mention "natives" or the colonized in this culturally specific epistemology of a specific culture of colonialism itself. The upshot is quite conservative, even anachronistically so. This critique is an internal if damning critique embodying and encouraging [End Page 293] pessimism largely from within the established order of knowledge that it analytically engages and categorically replenishes and preserves.
The grid politics of Wilderson's critique of "the ruse of analogy" leaves all manner of "Blackness" in a wasteland. The routine categorical contrast with "Native Americans" reduces all that and any colonial condition to a startlingly oversimplified matter of "land" (or "land restoration"); and it occludes "Afro-Indian" history as well as "Red-Black" maroonage all across the Americas. The constant generic contrast with "feminism" or "non-Black women" eclipses the more mammoth criticism of "gender" writ large in Diop and Amadiume's Black-African studies of Europe or "Western Civilization" as a "racial patriarchy" of pessimism and "anti-Black" imperialism. The contrast with Marxism and its "workers" never resurrects any issues of "class" or economics from any other perspective to recognize or to resist, for example, the white invention of Black elites as vital instruments of racism, anti-Blackness, and white-supremacism. There never appears a trace of any critique of Black "social class' (or political class) elitism in "Afro-pessimism" (2.0), which is a tell-tale sign of petty-bourgeois or "lumpen-bourgeois" articulations. Lastly, Wilderson's occasional categorical contrast of "Blackness" with Palestinians or al-Nakba (which aligns in Arabic with the Swahili substitution for the term "Middle Passage"—Maafa, the "Catastrophe") comprehends no Blackness in Palestine or among Palestinians. His Afro-pessimism can envision no Afro-Palestinianism, unlike a great tradition of Pan-African discourses that also do not dislocate Palestine from an anti-colonialist mapping of the African continent or the Afro-Asian landmass of a Pan-Africanist and "Bandung" imagination, one powerfully shared by Malcolm X and Fayez A. Sayegh. For "Black Power" internationally, Kwame Ture would refer to Palestine as the "tip of Africa" and uphold Fatima Bernawi, the iconic Black woman who's been named the "first Palestinian female political prisoner," as the paragon of "Black and Palestinian Revolutions."30 She is likewise canonized by other Afro-Palestinian icons themselves, such as Ali Jiddeh and Mahmoud Jiddeh of the African community of the Old City of Jerusalem, for example—or, say, Ahmad and Jumaa Takrouri of Occupied Jericho—who are each among the greatest of all icons across Historic Palestine, a country which has produced multiple Black Panther formations in Hebrew as well as Arabic in the 1970s and the 1980s. Again, Wilderson tacitly "nationalizes" his category of "Blackness" although this is scarcely in the interests of Black people in or outside of the US colonized mainland of Americanism; and so none of the above "Blackness" survives the critical grid of a very Anglo-American (and white racist state-bound) critique of "analogy," regardless of the "Afro-pessimist" text at hand.
Do not the vulgar colonial-nativist politics of Incognegro's strangely overlooked comment on "West Indians" go full blown then in Red, White & Black and elsewhere?31 [End Page 294]
There is here a general critical erasure of the massive tradition of Black anti-colonialism—or anti-colonial Black resistance to "anti-Blackness" and anti-Black colonialism, which transcends nationalization. Wilderson's "Afro-pessimist" rejects the anti-colonialist paradigms of supposedly "other" peoples, and yet in a manner that reinstates US or Western coloniality nonetheless—a white colonialism that oppresses "the Black" inside and outside the United States's official geopolitical limits. This position can thus make a virtue out of automatic and absolute anti-alliance postures with no further, actual political action then required for Black people, "the Black critic," or any Black liberation struggle on this view. Such chauvinism without political commitment or engagement beyond critique is logically consistent, for pessimism, where mere resentment or ressentiment can masquerade as resistance or "pro-Black" "radicalism." After all, Afro-pessimism (2.0) begins with a proud suspicion of Black liberation or Black liberation movement, itself, no less than of its potentially "anti-racist" or "anti-Black" political alliances. This provincial "American" pessimism reveals more affinities with Créolite in the Caribbean than Césaire's anti-colonialist eruption of Pan-African Négritude, in reality, its narrowly and negatively delimited rhetoric of the "Blackness" of "the Black" (as "Slave," of course) notwithstanding. As if this too is a virtue, pessimism is not just suspicious of power but possibility—while, upholding dystopia, it is casually dismissive of all historical actuality that does not support a pessimist paradigm, orientation or sensibility. Analytically, moreover, there is somehow no white colonialism for Blacks to fight in Africa or Black countries of Black people anywhere and no terrible landlessness that afflicts the African diasporas of Blackness captive within white settler and/or imperial state formations, for Wilderson and Afro-pessimism (2.0).