Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

AT: Social Death

Social death is disproven by thousands of Black-African revolts – prefer empirics that contest the thesis of the K.

Greg Thomas 18, teaches global Black Studies texts out of the English Department at Tufts University, founding editor of PROUD FLESH, January 2018, "Afro-Blue Notes:The Death of Afro-pessimism (2.0)?" Theory & Event, 21(1), p. 303-306, muse.jhu.edu/article/685979, kav

The Death of "Social Death" and Its Death?

With Wynter nowhere in sight, without any scenario of resistance or revolt ever in the vicinity of slavery's consideration, Wilderson would facilitate a revival of the writing of Orlando Patterson thanks to a cherry-picked reference to Slavery and Social Death (1982). An anonymous introduction to a recent "Afro-pessimism" reader describes the conservative sociologist as "erudite," simple and plain, customarily bracketing a host of controversial issues central to any intellectual analysis of "Blackness" and "humanity."60 Vincent Brown pointed out a decided misreading of the juridical notion of "social death" before the rise of the death cult of Afro-pessimism (2.0), which fetishizes it without understanding evidently or critical interrogation.61 But there is much more to note on this matter. Patterson is a historical sociologist of Occidentalism. His career promotion of a meta-narrative of "Western freedom" is inseparable from his academic narrative of slavery and his sociological promotion of sexual integration via intermarriage of Black women with white men in Rituals of Blood: The Consequences of Slavery in Two American Centuries (1999). How is this not a neo-slavery of concubinage made conjugal and synonymous with "life" itself? His sociology of slavery is one of Western socio-cultural assimilation and US-American political accommodation. What a contrast with the Diop and Amadiume perspective on "racial patriarchy" and European empire. The reincarnation of Afro-pessimism avoids examination of [End Page 303] Patterson's Occidentalism and its resultant investment in Black "social death" as a fetish and a phantasm. But Wynter would not by any means. She ordinarily writes of "master codes" of "symbolic life and death" as the central organizing principles of all human social orders of existence, not merely the "master codes" of plantation so-called "slavemasters" whose antebellum legal statutes could be mistaken for an uncontested reflection of actual historical reality by a subsequent school of scholars. The "death" discourse of Patterson is a vector of white disciplinary power that was so frontally challenged by Black Studies in the 1960s. Regarding history, Sterling Stuckey wrote in Amistad, symbolically: "white historians as a group are about as popular among Black people as white policemen."62 Regarding sociology, Joyce A. Ladner edited The Death of White Sociology (1973) in a sort of homocidal death wish for Western "knowledge production" and "white middle-class values"—not a death cult, a death drive, a death fetish or an acceptance of "social death" propaganda for Black people or Black social history. But these beasts die hard. Decades ago, Wynter could identify a crude Western narrative of unfreedom from Patterson's earliest writings on slavery: "Dr. Patterson purports to discover in Cudjoe [the legendary leader of the Leeward Maroons in Jamaica] an almost cowardly desire to avoid battle and to escape detection. Such criticism suggests a lack of understanding of the now well recognized tactics of successful guerilla warfare, tactics which Cudjoe had brilliantly developed centuries before their use by the Chinese and Cuban revolutionaries of modern times!"63 This was her in Black Metamorphosis: New Natives in a New World, the massive 900-plus page manuscript that she wrote in the 1970s for the Institute of the Black World and which Derrick White describes as a prelude to her … work on humanism or her "Theory of the Human."64

The tacit, presumed history of slavery inked by Wilderson's "Afro-pessimism" cannot break free of the infamous Stanley Elkins school of historiography. Both Elkins and Wilderson share the same geopolitical contours of Anglo-American nationalism—"slavery" is the US settler state of slavery delinked from the rest of the world—if one inscribes "happiness" in supposed "docility" during slavery, the other re-inscribes that "docility" with "suffering." Black or African revolt never rocks Afro-pessimism's slavery, or its whiteness, nor Elkins's "Sambo" national fantasy and related "Sambo" historiography. For him, as for Wilderson, Africans could only emerge from the "Middle Passage" as tabulae rasae—negro, or "black," but "no longer" African of any sort or in any way. This Maafa or "Middle Passage" depiction is a white mythology passed on yet long debunked elsewhere. Okun Edet Uya even showed in "The Middle Passage and Personality Change among Diaspora Africans" (1993) how new African-based modes of kinship were developed on the "slave ships" that supposedly eliminated [End Page 304] Africanity and kinship among the enslaved. Much later, Eric Robert Taylor made a study of hundreds of officially documented and often successful anti-slavery revolts aboard in If We Must Die: Shipboard Insurrections in the Era of the Atlantic Slave Trade (2006), subverting or sabotaging some of the most beloved academic folklore at the base. But white nationalism needs this phantasmagoria; it needs the "negro" rhetorically de-Africanized before it is semantically recoded as "black" or, in Wilderson, "Black." On a smaller scale, this white settler mythology also ignores the falsely framed "Herskovits-Frazier" debate; the essence of the very concept of "diaspora" widely commercialized in academia now; and the once popular if passing historiographical trend focusing on "small" or "day-to-day" resistance to slavery without threatening the fundamental politics of US national history as a professional discipline in the West.65 More stunning still in its demystification of the tabula rasa dogma of Elkins's "Sambo" (and hence Wilderson's "Black/Slave") is the heretical and exhaustive historical work of Gerald Horne: The Counter Revolution of 1776: Slave Resistance and the Origins of the United States of the America (2014) flies infinitely beyond the prior research of Herbert Aptheker's American Negro Slave Revolts (1943) and "Maroons within the Present Limits of the United States" (1939). Horne meticulously chronicles how maroonage determine the outlines of the US state merely assumed by Wilderson. The white power discourse sacralized in critique by Afro-pessimism (2.0) is revealed not to be total or absolute at all but delirious, addicted, and desperate in the face of chronic, raucous, and hemispheric Black-African resistance and revolt. The anti-pessimist James Baldwin's account of white nationalist histories that represent the enslavement of Africans as "nothing more than a record of humiliations gladly endured"66 can help explain Elkins and Wilderson's "histories" as ideological pieces of a sado-masochist historiographical whole. There is little to nothing but "docile" humiliation in either case—with or without the overtly nationalist narrative of "happiness," with or without the covertly white nationalist narrative of "suffering."

In the end, it is also telling that this "Afro-pessimist" embrace of "social death" has never thought to ask what or whose conception of the "social" and whose or what conception of "death" is assumed by the notion, not to mention how African people would respond to it accordingly over time and in various theaters of struggle. This is a Western cosmology of "death" not lived by Black people who do more than just die passively on white Western terms. One might only recall the many African Studies discussions of John Mbiti's African Religion and Philosophy (1969) with its multiplying categories of the long, recently, soon-to-be and living "dead." The entire history of modern slavery is rife with live conflicts in conceptions of life and death between Africa and Europe in or en route to the Americas and [End Page 305] back. This topic is a rich one in Wynter's Black Metamorphosis where many a rebel against slavery mounts the execution platform singing and laughing in communal glee at the prospect of returning home in valor via a spiritual escape from Western conceptions of "life" as well as Western conceptions of "death." Audre Lorde encodes as much in Our Dead Behind Us (1986), its ancestral call animating an ongoing life of revolt in the flesh. Another poet of the Black Arts Movement, Jayne Cortez celebrates Black defiance of death and a Black murder of white life which her Black life sees as no kind of life of at all: "Death, you are ugly. You are white. Death, you are death no more. … Liberation in my head. Liberation in my eye. … I've killed fear and my soul's on fire. I confess I am armed and prepared to reproduce the love that made me live."67 A slate of revolutionary figures of the iconic Black Panther Party also brilliantly re-theorized life, death and existence under colonial slavery and neo-slavery. Huey P. Newton's To Die for the People (1972) and Revolutionary Suicide (1973) cast the ruling oppressor's "life" as a "reactionary suicide" leading to a sorry death without significance. Alprentice "Bunchy" Carter exceeded the Western bourgeois conceit of biological life in "Black Mother," a poem where he achieves his humanity and his mother's freedom in the daring disdain for "natural death" driving his outlaw rebellion: "for a slave of natural death who dies / can't balance out to two dead flies."68 Like a Panther archetype himself, George Jackson found immortal life in revolutionary praxis and maintains in Blood in My Eye (1972) that the "social" in Western "society" is not truly "social" at all since this colonial-fascist formation does not produce "society" in fact but "hierarchy" whose aim is to fabricate the illusion of a "society above society" to rule.69 He could have been speaking of prison or pessimism when he wrote in Soledad Brother (1970): "They've been 'killing all the niggers' for nearly half a millennium now, but I am still alive. I might be the most resilient dead man in the universe. The upsetting thing is that they never take into consideration the fact that I am going to resist."70

African culture disproves the thesis of social death. Afropess is anxiety and anger that covers the sadness at its own core.

Thuli Gamedze and Asher Gamedze 19, MA in Education, Gender, and International Development from Michaelis, member of iQhiya(art collective); MA in African studies from University of Cape Town, 1-1-2019, "Anxiety, Afropessimism, and the University Shutdown," South Atlantic Quarterly, 118 (1), pp. 215-225, , kav

gamedZe: Uh huh. And it seems to flatten out and homogenize Black people, reducing and owning the interpretation of Black peoples’ experiences by subordinating them to one supposedly absolute and totalizing logic.

gamEdze: It goes further by articulating that the maintenance of antiblackness is crucial in sustaining the psychic health of white people. In other words, the binary created through the construction of blackness versus whiteness is the logic through which white people are able to recognize themselves as human, and through which black people, too, see white peo¬ple as human, and negate themselves. While Afropessimism can be useful in identifying systems of power—for instance, the mutual relationship of the racist construct of “black people as criminals” with the legal system and the capitalist prison-industrial complex—it falls short itself by asserting that there exists no other state for the black body except perpetual death, so con-sistently caving in on itself.

gamedZe: So, in that, it fails on many levels to make sense of the nuanced ways in which people, despite their supposed nonexistence, exist in and navigate through the world. How does Afropessimism understand its social death in relation to queerness or disability—forms of otherness that also generate gratuitous violence, exclusion, and oppression? But also, this particular transplantation of the American thing (the origin of the school of thought) to the continent is pretty wack. Even as the Black radical tradition has largely been formulated and theorized in and from America, and even as it often falls prey to American exceptionalisms in its quest for forms of Black universalism, I think it holds radical potential for us on the continent. As many theorists and thinkers of the Black radical tradition have shown, African cultural practices have formed the basis of Black revolt across time and space. I see Afropessimism as a departure from that tradition’s dynamic foundations in African culture.

Afropessimism, through its fixation on natal alienation, tends to ignore the living connections to the continent, seeming to take the severance of African people from the continent through the middle passage as utter and complete. It therefore seems to understand Black people not as cultural subjects who brought entire cosmological worlds and practices with them but as hopeless, utterly dislocated beings only existing as the sum total of their position in white supremacy. While I think that this can be challenged even in a diasporic context, this contradiction is even more pronounced here on the continent, because although many of us are alienated from African cultural practices and contexts, those traditions persist and are more or less proximate whether or not one is immersed in them.

gamEdze: In this way, it can be difficult to move with the Afropessimist, whose American-specific engagement with a particular history defines the functioning of antiblackness, seen as a mechanism that forms the foundational reality of every scenario of oppression.

Afropessimism’s refusal to engage its own internal world, to abandon its reactive and defensive nature, leads me to imagine it as a “placeholder politics,” similar to the ways that anxiety and anger hold and protect us from entering the place existing beyond them. This is not to offer a clean critique on Afropessimism but to situate it as a politics that perhaps exists as external to something more effective in exploring and acknowledging the internal— the power and the pain.

Afropessimism finds no way to its own sadness.

gamedZe: The idea of “holding” the “place” is quite a nice one. And interesting to think about how, in relation to the continent, it is perhaps the anxiety or the anger of Afropessimism that holds the place that prevents or protects the descent into the deep sadness. Perhaps this is what Fred Moten (2003: 94), through Amiri Baraka, might refer to as “the tragic,” which “is always in relation to a quite particular and material loss,” in this case being “the impossibility of a return to an African, the impossibility of an arrival at an American, home.” The sadness of the tragic is too great.

gamEdze: Heavy ...

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.