Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Wilderson Indicts

Wilderson equates everything to antiblackness – homogenizing millions off of personal encounters.

José Sanchez 22, PhD student in history at Duke University, 6-13-2022, "Against Afro-Pessimism," Jacobin, , kav

The exact meaning of Afro-pessimism as a philosophy is still being teased out in academia and on social media. At its center is Frank Wilderson III, especially after the 2020 publication of his half-memoir, half-treatise work of what he calls “auto-theory,” Afropessimism. In it, Wilderson narrates stories from his life, especially episodes between him and his coworkers, partners, friends, and others, in which his blackness is made to be painfully visible and repelled. His conclusion is that “at every scale of abstraction, violence saturates black life,” consigning blacks to perpetual enslavement.

This argument lies at the core of Afro-pessimism as a philosophy: the belief that the world’s basic breakdown of humans is between Humans and Slaves, and all black people are the latter, regardless of status or class. The essence of blackness is to be a slave.

Though beautifully told at times, the psychodrama of this relatively blue-blooded, tenured University of California professor morphs into an ideology that comes to some unsavory conclusions.

Illustrative of the black exceptionalism that characterizes Wilderson’s thinking and Afro-pessimism as a philosophy is an episode in the memory of an interaction between a younger Wilderson and a Palestinian friend. Sameer, Wilderson’s friend, recounts life in the Occupied Territories, lamenting the “shameful and humiliating way the soldiers run their hands up and down your body” at checkpoints — but then slips that “the shame and humiliation runs even deeper if the Israeli soldier is an Ethiopian Jew.”

For Wilderson, this statement made the “earth [give] way,” causing him to spiral to a shocking conclusion: “I was faced with the realization that in the collective unconscious, Palestinian insurgents have more in common with the Israeli state and civil society than they do with Black people.”

The irrationality of assigning an implacable anti-blackness to an entire people of millions based on a singular encounter ought to be clear enough. It also ignores the existence of, say, Fatima Barnawi, a Nigerian Palestianian detained in 1967 who, according to residents of the Afro-Palestinian Jerusalem enclave was called “Little Harlem,” was the first Palestinian woman to be imprisoned for a paramilitary operation against Israel.

Another indicative episode concerns when his father, an official at the University of Minnesota, jointly runs a program with a tribal government on a reservation outside of Minneapolis. Conflict ensues over rules and funding, Native Americans and others gather into a room, and a Native American man near a young Wilderson shouts, “We don’t want you, a nigger man, telling us what to do!” to applause.

Wilderson argues that the central struggle of the world is one of whites and their non-white ‘junior partners’ against all black people, no matter their position. This is an incredibly flattened worldview.

This prompts Wilderson to conclude that the “wealthy White housewives” that his parents, middle-class figures of the ivory tower, knew and worked with “shared the same psychic space as the Indians in the underserved neighborhoods of South Minneapolis.” And that within the “collective unconscious” of indigenous Americans, “the specter of Blackness was a greater threat than the settler institution that had dispatched a Black professor to do its dirty work.”

Over and over, these snapshots of Wilderson’s life scaffold into a bleak assessment rendering the central struggle of the world to be one of whites and their non-white “junior partners” against all black people, no matter their position.

This is an incredibly flattened worldview, allowing Wilderson to mask the actual class differences that splinter the “races.” One chief example is the fact that his parents are middle-class intellectuals who gave him an upbringing of socioeconomic advantages far out of the reach of most working people of all colors, whites included. Wilderson spent his youth hopping from Ann Arbor to Berkeley to Chicago as his parents’ faculty positions changed. In Minneapolis, they lived in the tony neighborhood of Kenwood, with the mansion of local hero and future vice president Walter Mondale nearby — a man who cavorted with Wilderson’s father so much that Mondale tried to convince him to run for Congress. Afro-pessimism, according to Wilderson’s telling, makes the existence of black members of an elite or bourgeoisie illegible, and solidarity among other racially oppressed peoples impossible.

Wilderson has made Afropess Americanized, paradoxical, and further colonized.

Greg Thomas 18, teaches global Black Studies texts out of the English Department at Tufts University, founding editor of PROUD FLESH, January 2018, "Afro-Blue Notes:The Death of Afro-pessimism (2.0)?" Theory & Event, 21(1), p. 289-293, muse.jhu.edu/article/685979, kav

Recently, putative foundations get presented or re-presented: Frank Wilderson publishes "Afro-Pessimism & the End of Redemption" (2016) in The Occupied Times after Incognegro: A Memoir of and Apartheid (2008) and Red, White and Black: Cinema and the Structures of US Antagonism (2010). The history of the vexing concept mocked by countless African scholars and politicos will go either unknown or unrecognized or both somehow in this latest articulation nonetheless. Some incubation period seems to have given this "Afro-pessimism" a very odd new breed of life. Intellectually, it is presented as a "new" brand, still, somehow—in an academic discourse on slavery, but a brand that can't possibly be "new" at all of course. Copyright issues of capitalism notwithstanding, this is a kind of "Afro-pessimism (2.0)"—kind of. It is very much of the old while effecting some great and deliberate ignorance of that which shapes and informs it. The global-conservative racist colonial-imperialist matrix of the "old" is simply disregarded by the "new" in its re-branding for the contemporary academic marketplace. Hence, Wilderson writes, "Afro-pessimism argues that the regime of violence that subsumes Black bodies is different from the regime of violence that subsumes hyper-exploited colonial subalterns, exploited workers and other oppressed peoples."21 He reprises, "Let me state the proposition differently: Human Life is dependent on Black death for its existence and for its conceptual coherence. There is no World without Blacks, yet there are no Blacks who are in the World. The Black is indeed a sentient being, but the constriction of Humanist thought is a constitutive disavowal of Blackness as social death; a disavowal that theorises [sic] the Black as degraded human entity: i.e., as an oppressed worker, a vanquished postcolonial subaltern, or a non-Black woman suffering under the disciplinary regime of patiarchy."22 What can be said of these "foundations," as it were, conventionally or unconventionally speaking?

First of all, how is it that "Afro-pessimism argues," in point of fact? How does it become such a personified abstraction bestowed with such a rhetorical aura of authority, begging so many questions as to the perverse circumstances of its hypothetical birth, or rebirth? Furthermore, how does this arguing "Afro-pessimism" get to have such authoritative "life"—as a "field"; to be a living, speaking thing, not a theory even but an oracular "Theorist"—when Black people as a people (or "sentient beings") are rendered as nothing but "dead" by this Afropessimism's absolute commitment to the concept of "social death" for Black people on the white plantations of African enslavement and after the formal demise of those plantations still?

It's imperative to analyze this specific discourse (or notion) of "slavery" embedded here along with the conception of history or the geopolitics [End Page 289] of history inscribed by a "Black" discourse that could so casually dub itself "Afro-pessimism." The entire discourse operates in the flow of an exceptionally provincial time and place. The "First Worldism" noted in Afro-pessimism (1.0) by Emeagwali is matched here by what Malcolm X marvelously defied as "Americanism." A "new," "pessimist" critique of "anti-Black racism" is made in the age and academic context of liberal identity conflicts and competitions—"after the revolution has failed," to recall George L. Jackson, after counter-revolution has receded an array of revolutionary movements of praxis from hegemonic and certainly academic view. Wilderson adds in his writing against redemption: "We need to apprehend the profound and irreconcilable difference between White supremacy (the colonial utility of the Sand Creek massacre) and anti-Blackness (the human race's necessity for violence against Black people). The antagonism between the post-colonial subject and the settler (the Sand Creek massacre, or the Palestinian Nakba) cannot—and should not be—analogized with the violence of social death: that is the violence of slavery, which did not end in 1865, for the simple reason that slavery did not end in 1865."23 The chronological marker of "1865" is not insignificant or inconsequential. It indexes a specific white settler nationalist project; the USA construct of "Americanism" (or "amerikanism") and slaveocracy; an official, white settler-slave state nationalist history and historiography. Yet Blackness and slavery are supposedly being thought at the most global or worldly level of humanity and humanism. Yet species automatically becomes nation, or the settler nation-state ideal, "American" meaning US settler imperialism in North America—both the species of humanity and the species of Blackness, which is cut up, constricted, and undercut from the start by Wilderson's paradigm.

How should 1865 function for the London site of The Occupied Times?24 The powder-keg Haitian Revolution does not pivot around 1865, of course, but 1791–1804. Britain declared a "gradual" abolition of slavery in 1833–34 with a typical "compensation" mandated for the slavers. So, what of the official if spurious "emancipation" dates for the rest of the Black world of Africa's enslaved diaspora? Spain is said to officially abolish slavery in 1811, for instance, while making exceptions for colonies in Cuba, Santo Domingo, and Puerto Rico. Denmark proclaims abolition in its "West Indies" in 1846–1848, like Sweden for Barthélemy in 1847. France is forced to follow suit, once more, in 1848; and Gabon is "founded" accordingly in Africa as the US would Liberia, etc. "Upper Canada" was said to end slavery with the British and "Lower Canada" (now Québec) with the French, an interesting fact for narrations of the Underground Railroad that often kept moving beyond Canada in the north back to the African continent (often Sierra Leone). The Netherlands is said to do so in 1861 or 1863. The modern slavery founded in the "Hispano-Portuguese slave trade" would thrive [End Page 290] in the Western Hemisphere both before and after formal independence from Spain and Portugal. This is key to debunk the "Afro-pessimism" that thinks it can delink slavery and colonialism as two separate, even competing entities or issues. The criollo settler-colonial slave-states of Cuba and Brazil do not officially abolish slavery for Africans until two decades after 1865 in 1886 and 1888, respectively. Slavery was purportedly abolished in Ecuador in 1851, but it is quite possible to move that pretentious date to 1894, which is well beyond the official "closing" dates widely touted for Brazil after Puerto Rico and Cuba in the Americas. To think of slavery's pseudo-abolition in terms of 1865 alone or any one date is not to think on the level of "Blackness" and "Human Life" at all; it is to reinscribe the most imperial white "American" perspective on slavery and Blackness instead.

The conceptual-geopolitical trappings of "1865" fundamentally define the discourse of "Afro-Pessimism and the Ends of Redemption," like assorted neo-pessimist texts: "The expanding field of Afro-pessimism theorises [sic] the structural relation between Blackness and Humanity as an irreconcilable encounter, an antagonism. One cannot know Blackness as distinct from slavery, for there is no Black temporality which is antecedent to the temporality of the Black slave."25 Critically, Wole Soyinka details "pre-colonial" African languages of "black" self-identification from the Yoruba to the Ga to the Hausa peoples on continent, for starters, in "The African World and the Ethnocultural Debate" (1989). But these details do not enter modern Eurocentric discussions in the main, be they Marxist or anti-Marxist, etc.26 There is in Wilderson only the slaver's history of slavery—one slaver's official "national" or state history and discourse. The "expanding field" of "Afro-pessimism" (2.0) further expands anti-Black, anti-African conceptions of historical agency. There is nothing outside of, or before, or countering Wilderson's "slavery" for the African enslaved. There is only Wilderson's "Blackness," which is curious. For what he casts as "Black" rather than "black" is more accurately cast as "negro" (in this specifically English usage, moreover, with no memory of the Spanish or Portuguese etymology) and not even "Negro," quiet as it's kept—since all of Africa is flatly foreclosed by this acutely paradoxical "Afro-pessimism." Both Africa and diasporas eclipsed, his "Blackness" and "Human Life" turn out to be the blackness and humanism of white Americanism, specifically and restrictively, an isolationist or exceptionalist Americanism despite the past and present hegemony of white Western humanism and its "anti-Black racism" worldwide. What is the "Afro" in "Afro-pessimism," therefore, when this Afro-pessimism (2.0) revivifies in disguise the "negro" concept of white settler-slave state history and historiography? It ironically does so in the name of some "Blackness" itself or, rather, the "blackness" of whiteness, of white postulation—not the Blackness of Blackness or the transvaluations [End Page 291] of manifold Black liberation movements themselves, even as it blithely misappropriates the ongoing if now naturalized cultural-political labor of that historic Blackness in the upper case. A dominant Anglo-American discourse of slavery is all that there is and ever was now when it comes to the Black and African, all anti-slavery discourses and counter-discourses of slavery as well as Blackness somehow vanished.

A glaring absence of Black radical and revolutionary intellectual history should be expected from any expression of "Afro-pessimism." Indeed, could Afro-pessimism 2.0 take hold as another trend in mainstream academia except in the political void produced after the 1960s and '70s by local as well as global counter-revolution and counter-insurgency? This absence affects the shape and agenda of the critical analysis of "anti-Black racism" in essential ways. Wilderson's critique of the "ruse of analogy" in Red, White & Black becomes a refrain that naturalizes academic approaches to politics now institutionalized with the continued reign of Western bourgeois liberalism. For older and enduring Black radical perspectives, the existence of "anti-Black racism" among non-Black peoples, organizations, and movements is neither a new nor shocking phenomenon. For many Black revolutionary movement logics of the '60s and '70s, for instance, this did not preclude alliance (or the exhaustion of alliances made) or lead to a doctrinaire rejection of "solidarity" work and its international (or "intercommunal") possibilities.27 "Contradictions" were expected, so to speak, in theory and practice, which might be resolved or not, depending on material interest, circumstance, etc. For them, this work was not about gauging identity, or the perfection of a projected analogy, but mobilization for the political accomplishments of revolution—a revolutionism that could or may not work toward the development of a new humanism not white or racist or anti-Black after all. The reach for potential solidarities was not construed as a gift or an act of good-willed benevolence, wise or unwise given the risks. Even solidarity work with obviously problematic, openly enemy forces could be a strategic or tactical mode of advancing Black collective self-interests that might dispense with any alliance at any given moment in time without seeing the relationship as a statement of some total identity or non-identity of condition and interests. The notion of solidarity has nowadays been superficialized, remaining riveted on mere rhetorical proclamation and aesthetic or representational identification in neo-colonial culture industries here and there. An older, praxical approach to alliance, perhaps "analogy," and solidarity is not taken up by current analyses of identity conflicts that prevail with the resurgence of a more academic political-intellectualism and a now much less contested liberalism. This is imperial "multiculturalism" and its malcontents. As much as Afro-pessimism (2.0) may object to certain instances of liberalism, or [End Page 292] regulation white racist liberalism at least, it assumes these Western epistemic frameworks of white academic liberalism all the same, thereby ensconcing the colonialism and neo-colonialism it constantly and symptomatically denegates in text after text.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.