Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Solvency

Afropess drains historical perspectives; forecloses alternatives of liberation; and fails without political resistance.

R.L. Stephens 17, organizer in Chicago, founding editor of Orchestrated Pulse, A. Philip Randolph Fellow at Jacobin, 5/17/2017, "The Birthmark of Damnation: Ta-Nehisi Coates and the Black Body," Viewpoint Magazine, , kav

One of Liza’s daughters, Ella Townsend, was born after emancipation, but remained in the bondage of sharecropping in rural Mississippi. As an adult, she carried a pistol with her in the fields, determined to protect herself and the surrounding children. One day, a white man on horseback rode into the fields. He had come to abduct a young black girl.

Ella, carrying her pistol in a lunch pail, intervened. “You don’t have no black children and you’re not going to beat no black children,” she told the intruder. “If you step down off that horse, I’ll go to Hell and back with you before Hell can scorch a feather.”

“I do not believe that we can stop them … because they must ultimately stop themselves,” Ta-Nehisi Coates says of white racists in the final paragraph of his bestseller Between the World and Me, written as an open letter to his son. Coates describes racism as galactic, a physical law of the universe, “a tenacious gravity” and a “cosmic injustice.”

When a cop kills a black man, the police officer is “a force of nature, the helpless agent of our world’s physical laws.” Society is equally helpless against the natural order. “The earthquake cannot be subpoenaed,” says Coates.

In a widely replicated gesture, Coates locates the experience of racism in the body, in a racism that “dislodges brains, blocks airways, rips muscle, extracts organs, cracks bones, breaks teeth.” In the slim volume, fewer than two hundred pages, the word “body” or “bodies” appears more than three hundred times. “In America,” he writes, “it is traditional to destroy the black body.” Another brooding passage dwells on the inevitability of this violence.

Yet Coates’s descriptive language and haunting narrative are not mere metaphors. They act as a kind of ontological pivot, mystifying racism even as it is anchored in its physical effects.

Metaphor has long been used to capture racism’s almost unimaginable brutality. Lynching became “strange fruit” in Abel Meerpool’s song, made famous by Billie Holiday. In a wry, tragic innuendo, rape was referred to in Black communities as “nighttime integration.” The use of metaphor is not in itself an obfuscation. But Coates wields metaphor to obscure rather than illuminate the reality of racism.

What we find all too often in Coates’s narrative universe are bodies without life and a racism without people. To give race an ontological meaning, to make it a reality all its own, is to drain it of its place in history and its roots in discrete human action. To deny the role of life and people — of politics — as Coates does is to also foreclose the possibility of liberation.

No Helpless Agent

Ella knew her mother Liza’s unimaginable suffering, but her memory was not a yoke on her shoulders. It provoked something in Ella.

As an adult, she did not see the white predator stalking the fields as some helpless agent. She took matters into her own hands. There was no gravity strong enough to break her will or loosen her grip on her pistol. Her efforts rippled beyond those cotton fields.

Ella taught her own daughter, Fannie Lou Hamer, not only to struggle, but to resist.

Fannie Lou was born into a sharecropping family in rural Mississippi but would go on to become a beacon of the Civil Rights movement. She is best known for her work registering black voters in Mississippi, most famously during 1964’s Freedom Summer, at great personal risk.

Police arrested and beat her. White racists shot at her. Lyndon Johnson dismissed her as an illiterate. In 1973, an interviewer asked her, “Do you have faith that the system will ever work properly?” By then, Fannie Lou had seen a decade of setbacks and false dawns since first walking off her plantation in 1962 to fight for Civil Rights. She responded,

We have to make it work. Ain’t nothing going to be handed to you on a silver platter. That’s not just black people, that’s people in general, masses. See, I’m with the masses… You’ve got to fight. Every step of the way you’ve got to fight.

She marched. She sang freedom songs. She testified. She co-founded the Mississippi Freedom Democratic Party. For her, the logical solution was political: uniting a powerless many against a powerful few. White racists could be stopped. Black people could resist, and Fannie Lou and so many others did just that.

Fannie Lou knew that the wages of racism were measured on the body. “A black woman’s body was never hers alone,” she once remarked. White doctors sterilized her without her consent during a minor surgery, a barbaric intrusion so common she called it a “Mississippi appendectomy.” However, though she knew racism’s physical toll, she drew inspiration from stories of black resistance passed down orally across the generations. Hamer recalled her grandmother’s will to survive and her mother’s weapon of protection.

These intergenerational resistance narratives, according to Charles Cobb in his book This Nonviolent Stuff’ll Get You Killed, “underlay a deep and powerful collective memory that was invisible to whites but greatly affected the shape and course of the modern Freedom Movement.” As a result, Fannie Lou and so many others possessed an intimate knowledge not only of their own human dignity, despite the racist brutality they endured, but also of the human frailty of their racial oppressors.

In the years before Fannie Lou’s political struggle began, whole communities, black women and men, rose up against the violence that was forced on black women’s bodies. Feminist historian Danielle McGuire argues this anti-rape community organizing in Alabama laid the foundation for what eventually became the Montgomery Bus Boycott. She observes, “The majority of leaders active in the Montgomery Improvement Association in 1955 cut their political teeth demanding justice for black women who were raped in the 1940s and early 1950s.”

Despite being a poor, black sharecropper drowning in the poverty and racial terror endemic to rural Mississippi, Fannie Lou held fast to her forbearers’ stories of resistance. She did not resign herself to fatalism, as Coates does.

Afro-pess ignores how its pessimistic approach originated from colonization and slavery – only embracing afro-optimism solves.

Greg Thomas 18, teaches global Black Studies texts out of the English Department at Tufts University, founding editor of PROUD FLESH, January 2018, "Afro-Blue Notes:The Death of Afro-pessimism (2.0)?" Theory & Event, 21(1), p. 284-286, muse.jhu.edu/article/685979, kav

Africa and the Pessimism without History

Reading what some are today calling "Afro-pessimism" invites no small amount of amnesia, myopia, as well as illiteracy. There is little if any Africa to this discourse at all, its nominal Afro-hyphenation notwithstanding. Armah sits atop the lengthy bibliography on the "Afro-Pessimism" page at Incognegro.org for alphabetical reasons alone. The selection of The Beautyful Ones Are Not Yet Born is as symptomatic as this list's addition of an Achille Mbembe book in due course. There is Frantz Fanon but only his Black Skin, White Masks (1952) is included to the exclusion of A Dying Colonialism (1959), The Wretched of the Earth (1961), and Toward the African Revolution (1964). The rest of the bibliography tends to dovetail with "race" and "critical theory" canons of US-centered academic classrooms, graduate if not undergraduate, across North America—with key duty-free imports from Western [End Page 284] Europe. In any case, what is the significance of this term as a term, its rather bizarre adoption by Black academic advocates who have come to promote it today without any apparent sense of the history of its ravaging the African continent and without any reference whatsoever to the history of insistent Black political-intellectual resistance to its application to Africans on the continent and in the diaspora?

Crucially, neither pessimism nor optimism is just a word in a dictionary. Fred Moten made a certain call for "optimism" in an earlier, and terribly "friendly," response to this "Afro-pessimism" which could be deflected by Jared Sexton as if optimism and pessimism were now virtually transposable conceptual terminology or as if pessimism could suddenly be posed as a strange mode of optimism itself—something like a philosophical detour to it, after all, when all is said and done.11 That's a specious revision to be sure. Yet what goes ignored here is how this lexical couplet makes its meaning in context, politically, in time and space, particularly in European languages and colonial-imperial lexicons, most notably perhaps in English as well as French, just for example. It carries baggage too big to check in current games of academic branding. What's more, optimism and pessimism do not ever confront each other on equal ground here, any façade of even-handed as opposed to hierarchical dichotomy aside. The pessimist intellectual empire of the West has systematically crowded optimism out of serious contemplation and come to pin pessimist condemnation to all "things" Black-African in the interests of white racist imperialism, for various and sundry periods of this empire. Who would overlook this issue rather than address it frontally—in and beyond books of all kinds?

A history or genealogy of optimism and pessimism as "ideologies" is hardly unavailable to us. The old Black radicalism of Cheikh Anta Diop wrote famously and at length about this subject. The Cultural Unity of Black Africa (1959) concluded in the late 1950s, no less: "the Meridional Cradle, confined to the African continent in particular, is characterized by the matriarchal family, the creation of the territorial state, in contrast to the Aryan city-state, the emancipation of woman in domestic life, xenophilia, cosmopolitanism, a sort of social collectivism having as a corollary a tranquility going as far as unconcern for tomorrow, a material solidarity of right for each individual…." "In the moral domain," he continues, "it shows an ideal of peace, of justice, of goodness and an optimism which eliminates all notion of guilt or original sin in religious and metaphysical institutions."12 Looking at literature in a long world history, Diop analyzed novels, tales, fables, and comedies to advance this core proposition, along with the material and economic structures of human social development. His Pan-African critique of European imperialism indicted not only its culture of "war, violence, crime, and conquests," but also its signature "metaphysical systems" of pessimism.13 One could thus combat "anti-Black" racism, "anti-Black" colonialism, and "anti-Black" imperialism, so to speak, [End Page 285] by confronting or challenging the pessimism of Occidentalism—or one could reproduce this "anti-Black" empire of slavery and colonialism by adopting, reifying, and endorsing it. The final words of The Cultural Unity of Black Africa would proclaim in the spirit of revolutionary decolonization and bona fide independence: "The universe of tomorrow will in all probability be imbued with African optimism."14

How then does a current trend in academia proceed to dub itself "Afro-pessimism," simultaneously deeming itself a school of Black radical thinking, with no awareness of a critique of this stature; no engagement with it at all; and no critical explanation of how "Afro-pessimism" could not as a consequence signify an elemental contradiction in terms? The late Diop remains the most monumental historian of the Black world. His intellectual biography is as a legendary as his academic and extra-academic scholarship. It is almost cliché now to recall that he was named the most influential thinker of the 20th century—with W.E.B. DuBois—at the First World Festival of Black Arts convened in Dakar of the 1960s. Even if Anglophone political and intellectual circles show little awareness of his radical political practice and related political imprisonment as opposition under Leopold Senghor in neo-colonial Senegal—thinking too exclusively of his counter to Egyptology or his anti-Hellenomania—Diop was and is no less a giant for the historic Black Studies movement of the African diaspora across the Americas.15

Drawing arbitrary lines to determine if actions are anti-black individualizes afropess. That oversimplifies afropess and creates a theory that doesn’t have any basis.

George Weddington 19, PhD candidate with research interests in social movement studies, Black studies, and organizational sociology, 7-20-2018, “Political Ontology and Race Research: A Response to ‘Critical Race Theory, Afro-Pessimism, and Racial Progress Narratives.’” Sociology of Race and Ethnicity, 5(2), pp. 278–288, doi:10.1177/2332649218785921, kav

My objection is that the authors’ call for sociologists to test whether diversity practices reproduce antiblackness reduces antiblackness to individual attitudes and preferences toward African Americans, though the authors stated that the evidence of the afterlife of slavery is the ongoing production of gratuitous violence and natal alienation specifically on black populations. Wacquant’s work has earned Sexton’s praise and a central place in the approach of Afro-pessimism specifically because it allows a guideline to how scholars across disciplines can understand the connections between blackness and slavery across time and social institutions. The works of Stephen Dillon (2012), Michael Dumas (2016), and Connie Wun (2016), though beyond the discipline of sociology, point out a potentially distinct path for the way that the afterlife of slavery implicates sociological research. The importance of the concept should not lead Ray et al.’s readers to a distinction of how individuals might personally relate to African Americans in organizations but instead to ask how the dynamics of slavery structure institutions such as schools, prisons, or even the market.

The four authors falter in their prescription of how sociologists can incorporate Afro-pessimism specifically because of their limited incorporation of political ontology. Essentially, if black populations exist on an ontological plane Moten describes as “nothingness,” what is the role of institutions such as the prison that very materially and immediately shape the experiences of African Americans?3Moten (2013b) and RAlessandra aengo (2016) provide a way forward. Raengo observes, via Igor Kopytoff’s (1986) chapter in The Social Life of Things, that the political life of black populations is distinctly a result of “the ontological violence of slavery.” Reading Hartman and Raengo, along with help from Sexton and Wacquant, shows how institutions can differentially produce black life across the black diaspora, while also being understood as instances of a longer history that is characterized by the reformulation, as well as lasting effects, of slavery. The afterlife of slavery is not an issue of “testing” how diversity reproduces antiblackness or asking how many black people need to be incarcerated for prison to be considered an antiblack institution. Such approaches reduce the Afro-pessimist mode of reading histories of race to the conditions of black individuals. Instead, Afro-pessimism’s commitment to the afterlife of slavery means seeking the threads from slavery through the past, to the present and the future using black captivity, racial terror and reformulations of slavery as terrifying signposts.

Climate turns racial violence — it is the most extreme form of structural oppression. Developing responses to it is key.

Williams ‘21 — Jeremy Williams, writer, The Earthbound Report, writer and activist for Environmental Justice, author of the upcoming books, Climate Change is Racist; (July 21st 2021; “The Racial Violence of Climate Change”; Foreign Policy; ; //LFS—JCM) [***NOTE*** — This article is an excerpt from the authors upcoming book, Climate Change is Racist, and paragraphs have been condensed for readability, no text changed, omitted, or altered]

Only the top strata requires intent. Direct violence is a deliberate act whereas structural violence results from “numerous acts of omission.” Structural violence is better understood as a process than an event. The suffering it causes can be many times greater than direct violence, but it goes unnoticed because it is depersonified and diffused across many people and different acts. It is the grinding inequality that holds minorities back year after year. Environmental inequalities are an example of structural violence. They too flow from deep cultural ideas about who is entitled to clean air and water and who is less “deserving.” Who must be kept safe and who is, to quote a Robert D. Bullard book title, the “”? Consider Archona and Priambandhu, who were farmers in Kaya Benia, a village in Bangladesh. In previous years, they had been able to produce two metric tons of rice from their 11 acres of land. After repeated cyclones and floods, their land has shrunk to two acres, and what remains is polluted with salt. It is underwater for four months of the year. “We don’t know the future, but we can assume that we will lose it all,” Archona said. “We are losing our home. We have lost our livelihood, and we are fighting to have enough food and water for each day. If we just had the land beneath our feet, then we could adapt to climate change.” Archona and Priambandhu have suffered an act of violence. Their home and their livelihood have been destroyed. Their land has been taken from them. They have contributed almost nothing to the crisis; this is something that has been done to them.

The cause and the effect are so far apart from each other that it might not be recognized as violence. There was no malicious intent, yet their experience is all too common. As greenhouse gases pollute the atmosphere from the world’s most developed countries, the waters rise or the rains fall in faraway places. Heat waves claim the weakest. Crops are lost. Places and the memories they hold are erased. Cultural heritage is eroded. The individual events—the storms and cyclones—are sometimes described as “violent.” Why not the wider issue? If the cause and effect could be connected, perhaps it would be more obvious that expanding an airport, opening a new coal mine, or pulling out of an international treaty are acts of violence. They are acts of violence perpetrated against nature and biodiversity—and against people of color. One reason climate change is not seen as violence is it happens so gradually. This is a problem identified by Rob Dixon, a professor at Princeton University’s High Meadows Environmental Institute. He described how environmental harm progresses as “slow violence”: “a violence that occurs gradually and out of sight, a violence of delayed destruction that is dispersed across time and space, an attritional violence that is typically not viewed as violence at all.” Climate change is nobody’s fault. Nobody intended it. It has not been designed. It has been “created by generations of decisions from privileged people who seek to make themselves safe and comfortable, who contribute disproportionately to the problem of climate change while tending to avoid its worst effects,” wrote Kevin J. O’Brien in his striking book The Violence of Climate Change: Lessons of Resistance From Nonviolent Activists. “It has no single architect and no direct cause, but it is nevertheless violence—a selfish expression of power that harms others.”

There is a through line from George Floyd in Minneapolis to Archona and Priambandhu in Bangladesh. They have all suffered from acts of violence that spring from underlying patterns of inequality, where some people’s lives have greater value than others’ lives. The convenience of white consumers—the right to drive or fly or eat beef—takes precedence over the rights of people of color around the world. As demonstrators took to the streets of Minneapolis in May 2020, climate activists from the local branch of served food and provided first aid to protesters. Sam Grant, executive director and environmental justice campaigner, made the connection very clearly: “Police violence is an aspect of a broader pattern of structural violence, which the climate crisis is a manifestation of.” It is all part of the same struggle, the defiant cry that Black lives matter. The British media may have been wrong-footed by the actions of Black Lives Matter U.K. and their assertion that climate change is racist. African activists would have been less surprised. Maangamizi is a Swahili word that means havoc or annihilation. It has become a shorthand term for an “African holocaust” that stretches from slavery, through colonialism, and into current oppression and the threat of climate change. It is used by pan-African activists and academics, including a group that runs a called “Stop the Maangamizi: We charge genocide/ ecocide.” “We have our own understanding … of the problem of climate change, within the context of Pan-Afrikan Internationalism,” Kofi Mawuli Klu and Esther Stanford-Xosei from the Pan-Afrikan Reparations Coalition in Europe. The group “sees climate change as one of the results of the criminal imposition—by the ruling classes of Europe—of a rapacious system expropriating the resources of the globe, not only at the expense of the majority of Humanity, but also to the detriment of our Mother Earth.”

The term genocide is not an exaggeration. The first genocide of the 20th century was in German-controlled West Africa, a campaign called the Vernichtung that drove out the Herero and Nama tribespeople. The described it as a “template for the Holocaust.” Similar atrocities occurred in the Congo under Belgium, in Libya under Italian rule, and in the French colonies like Algeria. Other crimes may not fit the specific definition of genocide, but what is the right word for systematically obliterating an entire culture, as British imperialist forces did in the sacking of Benin? Although colonialism may have formally ended, pan-Africans argue justice is yet to be done and the damage is ongoing. As rapper put it: “They changed that much? Are you so sure? The world’s darker people still the most poor?”

This history of genocide and extraction of value from Africa is now being compounded by the climate crisis. It has taken different forms over the centuries, but the same pattern of cultural violence underlies slavery, colonization, unfair trade rules, and the climate crisis. First, it was the people and their labor. Then, it was the land and its resources. Now, it is the atmosphere. The nature of the plunder has changed, but the logic remains the same: White people are entitled to take what they need from Black people.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.