AT: African Nation Link
Racism and colonialism were recreated by black settlers in Liberia – they carried over violent structures with them. That disproves any link to African nations.
José Sanchez 22, PhD student in history at Duke University, 6-13-2022, "Against Afro-Pessimism," Jacobin, , kav
The histories of Liberia and Israel, like the histories of African and Jewish Americans, are not perfectly analogous. But key similarities are there. Liberia and Israel were founded by the descendants of oppressed peoples whose self-conceptions were strongly tied to being an oppressed and dehumanized people. These are nation-states conceived as refuges from ancient and lethal hatreds in faraway lands.
Ironically, the respective settlers of both countries became a dominating group themselves, building up states and societies that served their interests as a group, particularly a clique of ruling elites among them. Yet in Israel, Jews were able to achieve a demographic majority and maintain it today through an apartheid system; rhetoric and action against Palestinians in everyday Israeli politics smacks of ethnic cleansing or even genocide. Palestinian birth rates are described in apocalyptic terms of “demographic time bombs.”’ In Liberia, the manumitted slaves, free blacks, and “mulattoes” who made up the Americo-Liberian and West Indian–Liberian dominant groups were consistently outnumbered by the masses of indigenous Africans that they quarreled and traded with.
In 1816, the slaveholder-dominated Virginian statehouse asked the US Congress to find a territory on the African coast to become a refuge for free blacks and emancipated slaves. Both slaveholders and abolitionists gathered at a Washington, DC hotel in December of that year and founded the American Colonization Society (ACS). Colonizationists came to believe that only by exporting blacks to a separate country could their plight find resolution because of the impossibility of racial harmony in the United States.
As Eric Burin writes in Slavery and the Peculiar Solution: A History of the American Colonization Society, the ACS “hoped to rid the United States of both slavery and black people.” Exporting America’s “Negro problem” was initially a political outgrowth of early black nationalists such as Paul Cuffe to address the plight of African Americans in the antebellum republic. Cuffe, a sailor of mixed-race heritage, visited Sierra Leone in 1811 to think through how the United States could establish a similar project.
Sierra Leone was established in the late eighteenth century by black and white British abolitionists as a “homeland,” drawing black Britons, Nova Scotians, and West Indians. Soon enough, British squadrons were intercepting illegal, mostly Havana- and Rio de Janeiro–bound slave ships, “liberating” the enslaved Africans on board and bringing them to Sierra Leone, creating a polyglot and multireligious community. As the nineteenth century progressed, Liberian colonization grew more and more popular, with proponents growing to include US presidents James Monroe and Andrew Jackson. Even Abraham Lincoln would flirt with the idea as president.
Historians have concluded that paternalism and racism motivated the ACS’s actions. For example, many of its Southern slaveholding members believed that free blacks posed a problem to their interests and dreamed of shipping them all off to Liberia. Yet in his earlier years, the abolitionist William Lloyd Garrison promoted the colonization of and the sending off of free blacks to Liberia as the most strategic pathway to furthering slavery’s demise. It was only when Garrison was shown by black allies that the masses of African Americans were not pro-colonization that he became an opponent of the Liberian settler-colonial project.
Against assimilationists like Frederick Douglass, black nationalists such as Martin Delany also looked to Liberia to solve the problems of black America. Delany declared that “only through wielding the national helm could Africans in the Americas achieve their quest for representation and preserve their distinctiveness.” Douglass and the overwhelming majority of African Americans, now generations removed from the Middle Passage and made into a new people born through that rupture, believed that only struggling for their liberation in their new homeland was the path forward.
Yet in Liberia, slaveholders, black nationalists, and do-good white abolitionists pushed on. There, their thinking converged — none of them thinking for a second that the United States could actually be a multiracial democracy.
Like the Afro-pessimists today who fatalistically believe in a timeless and intractable anti-black racism, proponents of Liberian colonization could not imagine that racism could be consciously eliminated by the same human beings that actually gave birth to it. Racial animosity between blacks and whites was imagined to be ingrained and unstoppable. And even if emancipation could be won, peaceful, multiracial coexistence and equality would be an impossible dream. Afro-pessimists today are like the recalcitrant ACS members who kept promoting the fantasies of Liberian colonization and back-to-Africa efforts, even as strong majorities of black folks looked to more practical solutions within their own environments, oftentimes allying with whites themselves.
However, with Reconstruction’s defeat in the last quarter of the nineteenth century, it is understandable why a minority of African Americans looked to emigration and Liberia as a solution to their plight in the United States as the century drew to a close. The Jim Crow counterrevolution began to solidify, pushed by a frightened Northern and Southern ruling class anxious to snuff out the democratic and interracial popular energies unleashed by Reconstruction. This only bolstered the claims of the ACS, in the ears of some. As Burin wrote, “Insisting that African-Americans were unfit for citizenship in the United States and that white people would inevitably crush black aspirations, Society officials eagerly anticipated a postwar upsurge in emigration.”
Any upsurge in post–Civil War back-to-Africa efforts, however broadly unpopular, grew in times wherein racism became so intense that exasperated African Americans could not help but seriously doubt that they had a future in the United States. As Kenneth C. Barnes concludes in Journey to Hope: The Back-to-Africa Movement in Arkansas in the Late 1800s, “Interest in African emigration peaked among black southerners in the 1890s, a time when cotton prices hit rock bottom and white racism reached its zenith.”
In this rightward lurch in US national politics, black emigration and racial pessimism becomes tragically sensible — paralleling the context of Afro-pessimism’s growing popularity in our own bleak times of primetime-televised police killings and growing inequality.
In the beginning, the Liberian settlements were collaboratively run by black settlers as well as white philanthropists and governors who sincerely wanted to solve the United States’ “Negro problem” through exporting it. With independence in 1847, state affairs were fully in black settler hands, in an effort driven by “well-heeled” elites, in James Ciment’s observations. Through colonization efforts across the United States and even the West Indies, blacks developed a diasporic identity, mythologizing Africa as their “homeland” in spite of the cultural differences and distance from the continent through the abortive rupture of the Middle Passage.
Yet almost from the very start of this unique and black settler-colonial experiment, tensions emerged between the black settlers and the indigenous Africans that unraveled meanings of blackness as well as exposed the limits of black nationalism and separatism.
In an essay titled, “Black Imperialism: Americo-Liberian Rule over the African Peoples of Liberia, 1841–1964”, M. B. Akpan observes that due to a variety of cultural differences between African American settlers and indigenous Africans in Liberia that, “in spite of their color, they were, as a rule, as foreign, and lacking in sentimental attachment to Africa as were European colonialists elsewhere in Africa like the British, the French, the Portuguese, and the Spaniards.” Americo-Liberian families carved up the tropical land amongst themselves, dressed in the woolens of their respectable white counterparts back in New York and Baltimore despite the oppressive heat and scorning local fare like cassava for familiar tastes like pickled beef.
Americo-Liberians had become, as indigenous Africans would call them, the “black white people.” As Caree A. Banton argues in her book More Auspicious Shores: Barbadian Migration to Liberia, Blackness, and the Making of an African Republic, “When black migrants believed they had gotten away from the dread and terror of white supremacy and colonialism, different aspects of the ideologies traveled to Liberia through black migrants’ own internalization of them.”
Though indigenous Liberians outnumbered settlers a hundred to one, Liberia’s 1847 constitution didn’t afford natives any rights or privileges. Supported by US funds and arms, the settlers forcibly put Africans into a “protectorate” relationship, requiring subjected peoples to acknowledge the supremacy of the settler state over their own governments in exchange for civilizing goods such as an assimilation policy.
African youths, particularly illegitimate children, would be sired in settler households to work as servants and be educated. Hinterland villages were subjected to an onerous “hut tax” starting in 1916, and such revenue was siphoned into the pockets of corrupt village and settler elites. With later, twentieth-century pushes to centralize settler governance, indigenous rebellions broke out among the ethnic Grebos in 1910, the Krus in 1915, among others — all defeated with the help of US arms, personnel, and training.
Perhaps the most sensational example of Americo-Liberian abuse against indigenous Africans was the scandal and League of Nations investigation into forced labor recruitment and shipping of indigenous Liberians by Americo-Liberian elites to work the plantations on the Spanish island colony of Fernando Po, the northernmost part of Equatorial Guinea. Americo-Liberians would turn a profit for this traffic in a scheme eerily reminiscent of the crimes done to their ancestors. I. K. Sundiata writes in “Prelude to Scandal: Liberia and Fernando Po, 1880-1930” in the Journal of African History, “Thus, the laborer found himself working for the period of the advance, three months, as unpaid labor.” Americo-Liberian settlers ironically recreated the centuries-old tradition of African rulers selling their own subjects to European merchants in exchange for power and wealth over their remaining charges.
When the Jamaican Marcus Garvey’s exploding back-to-Africa movement and his Universal Negro Improvement Association made links with Monrovia envoys, eyeing Liberia as a place to settle masses of followers in the Americas, Americo-Liberian elites eventually responded with coldness because they looked at Garvey as a contender for the power they had over the country. Instead, Americo-Liberian elites looked to a white man named Harvey Firestone, Sr who led the world’s largest tire company and who offered that the government pay off all of their debts in exchange for more control over state affairs. In sidelining Garveyism while putting the Liberian state once again under effective tutelage to white capitalists in exchange for maintaining power over indigenous Africans and others, Liberian settler elites once again found, in blackness, a useful cover for justifying an abusive ruling class.