Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Strengthening partnerships with non-Turkey members effectively sidelines Turkey

Saidel 18, JD @ Georgetown, Center for Ethics and the Rule of Law at the University of Pennsylvania Law School (Nicolas, “Turkey's Eastern Pivot: A Challenge for NATO and a Threat to US National Security,” Center for Ethics and the Rule of Law, https://www.law.upenn.edu/live/files/7539-turkey-nato-1192018)//BB

The recent guilty plea by Former National Security Advisor Michael Flynn, and the indictment of Trump campaign officials Paul Manafort and Rick Gates, should highlight the fact that violators of the Foreign Agents Registration Act have reached the highest levels of government. 1 Flynn’s long delay in registering as a foreign agent is particularly problematic in view of his lobbying efforts on behalf of the Turkish government. 2 As detailed below, Turkey is no longer reliably aligned with US and NATO interests, despite being a military partner of the US as well as a member of NATO. Indeed, Turkey now appears to be more firmly aligned with Russia than with the US or NATO. Turkey’s penetration into our political system is therefore of significant concern from the standpoint of national security. This paper will argue that Turkey has become a threat to US and NATO security, and that this fact has not resulted in the policy shift it merits. Notably, US strategy regarding Turkey is nowhere to be found within the White House National Security Strategy document, suggesting that the current Administration is insufficiently attuned to the risks of our present alliance with Turkey. 3 This paper will propose several policy adjustments warranted by Turkey’s shifting orientation towards Russian interests. I. Introduction On December 2, 2017, US Secretary of Defense James Mattis told reporters that as the war against ISIS enters its final stages, US strategy would move towards holding territory instead of arming Syrian Kurdish fighters.4 This statement came a week after US President Donald Trump informed Turkish President Recep Erdoğan in a phone call of “pending adjustments to the military support provided to our partners on the ground in Syria,” a reference to Kurdish fighters that have been working in tandem with the US military in Syria.5 This abrupt about-face in American policy, which includes the recouping of weapons and vehicles from Kurdish militias, is an imprudent attempt at détente by the Trump administration towards the Turkish government.6 Erdoğan is a vociferous critic of American support for the Kurds in Syria. This issue, among others, has strained US-Turkish relations. For the US, the diplomatic crisis with Turkey is a matter of critical national security, given our intelligence and military collaboration with Turkish forces. In July 2017, the Turkish state-run news organization, Anadolu, revealed the location of 10 US bases and outposts in northern Syria.7 In late August 2017, US troops stationed in northern Syria came under direct fire from Turkish- backed forces.8 In December 2017, Turkey finalized the purchase of the S-400 surface-to-air missile defense system from Russia, the North Atlantic Treaty Organization’s (hereinafter “NATO” or the “Alliance”) historical adversary.9 These are but a few recent examples of increasingly overtly hostile acts taken by Turkey against NATO and the United States, actions that suggest a growing alliance between Turkey and the Kremlin, and a lack of commitment to democratic ideals. Erdoğan once revealed his attitude towards democracy by remarking, “Democracy is like a bus, when you arrive at your destination, you step off.”10 Turkey possesses a formidable military and a robust economy. NATO’s only Muslim-majority state, Turkey serves as NATO’s bridge to the Middle East, sharing as it does a border with Syria, Iraq, and Iran. Turkey also helps to stem the tide of migration into Europe. It is in Russia’s interest to drive a wedge between NATO and Turkey, both to diminish NATO and to bring Turkey increasingly within Russia’s sphere of influence. Turkish recalcitrance towards contributing forces and capacities to NATO operations may reflect an enhanced Turkish-Russian relationship. Strengthening bilateral relationships with other NATO nations as well as pursuing a multilateral NATO approach towards Turkey, in a judicious combination of “carrots and sticks,” appears to be the optimal path moving forward for the US.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.