No Arctic war---their ev is all hype.
Øystein Tunsjø 20, professor and head of the Asia programme at the Norwegian Institute for Defence Studies, Norwegian Defence University College, “The Great Hype: False Visions of Conflict and Opportunity in the Arctic,” Survival, Vol. 62, No. 5, 09-23-2020, https://doi.org/10.1080/00396338.2020.1819649
In recent years there has been an abundance of studies, reports, articles and statements presenting the Arctic as a new frontier for resource extraction and sea lanes of communication.1 These studies claim that the receding Arctic ice provides not just commercial opportunities, but also security challenges that could fuel great-power rivalry and conflict.2 Yet, despite the hype, there is little likelihood of a shipping bonanza or a natural-resource boom in the Arctic.3 This does not mean that climate change is unimportant for the region – we can expect more shipping activity, investment and competition as the ice cap recedes. But it is important to maintain a balanced view of the opportunities and challenges presented by the ‘new Arctic’.4
Equally important, the stakes in a changing Arctic are not high enough to warrant a great-power conflict. As in the past, it remains unlikely that military force will be used to resolve a conflict originating in the Arctic. It is more likely that any potential great-power competition in the High North between Russia and NATO will reflect the more consequential sources of competition and conflict in Eastern or Southern Europe – in other words, that conflict might spill over into the High North from somewhere else.5 Developments in the Arctic appear to have caused some observers to forget that Russia’s recent naval build-up is primarily focused on safeguarding traditional Russian security interests, such as maintaining its sea-based nuclear deterrent and contesting sea lanes of communication in the North Atlantic. Thus, it is a familiar security challenge – Russia’s rivalry with the United States and NATO over the European security order – that has the highest potential for creating conflict in the Arctic.
Similarly, the recent focus on China’s Arctic ambitions minimises the importance of the changing balance of power in East Asia as the primary source of US–China competition. Beijing’s foremost security concern is the US response to China’s activities in its own maritime periphery, but Chinese behaviour will also determine the United States’ global strategic priorities. Sino-American competition will compel the US to prioritise the Asia-Pacific, and thus to draw down its commitments to other regions. This will constrain its options in the High North.
Since European states are unprepared to substitute for American power, Russian advancements in Europe and the Arctic will primarily reflect US retrenchment and European inertia, rather than improved Russian capabilities. Moreover, heightened US–China competition in the Arctic, much like heightened competition with Russia, will be a spillover effect of US–China rivalry in East Asia.
The new Arctic: land of opportunity?
One of the leading champions of the new Arctic has been the Norwegian government. It defined the region as a national priority in 2005 and launched an international diplomatic offensive to increase international awareness of its supposedly vast potential. In a speech in 2006 at the Center for Strategic and International Studies in Washington, Norway’s then-minister for foreign affairs Jonas Gahr Støre declared that ‘in the years to come … the High North will be one of the most important strategic areas in the world’.6 In 2014 Oslo released ‘Norway’s Arctic Policy’, which stated that ‘the Arctic is the Norwegian Government’s most important foreign policy priority’, adding that ‘access to energy resources and other natural resources is becoming easier, and new trade routes are opening up in the north. All this is creating new opportunities.’7 Such claims have been echoed in other countries too. US Secretary of State Michael Pompeo, for example, emphasised in a speech to the Arctic Council in May 2019 that
the Arctic is at the forefront of opportunity and abundance. It houses 13 percent of the world’s undiscovered oil, 30 percent of its undiscovered gas, and an abundance of uranium, rare earth minerals, gold, diamonds, and millions of square miles of untapped resources … Steady reductions in sea ice are opening new passageways and new opportunities for trade.8
This kind of public diplomacy, along with exaggerated media reporting, appears to have contributed to the circulation of imprudent claims and unfounded assumptions about the opportunities presented by the new Arctic – and about the likelihood of conflict in the region.9