Previous shifts are not enough, we need a full transition to overcome the mistakes of the past
Anne Ruyan, 2018 (Ruyan, professor in the School of Public and International Affairs, faculty affiliate of Women’s, Gender and Sexuality Studies at the University of Cincinnati and has a PhD in International Relations. “Global Power Politics” Gender and Global Governance, pg 53/// MF)
These points suggest how this shift in analysis, in turn, shifted strategies: from “adding women” to formal power structures to valorizing feminine traits in order to redefi ne politics from “power-over” to “power-to” (also known as “power-with” or enabling power) and change the standards of political behavior in favor of interdependence and cooperation. Still, this left intact a lingering and limiting referent to “women” that did not de-homogenize the category to recognize power diff erentials among women and the power some women hold over some men. It also left intact the association of embodied women with feminine values, which, on the one hand, led to essentialist assumptions about women as cure-alls for social (and global) ills and, on the other hand, positioned certain embodied men (largely non-Western, non-white, and/or lower class) as the villains of the piece. In the process, attention is defl ected from the complicity of both women and men—particularly those with the most power and privilege—in contributing to global ills. It also misrepresents feminist politics as exclusively about women rather than about resisting gender and gendered hierarchies and the ills they cause globally. This is not to say that raising the status of women and other subjugated people—in politics and other facets of life—is not necessary to increase formal representation and better equalize voice, but to note that it is insuffi cient if there is no attendant ideological shift away from politics as power-over to politics that enables resistance to and transformation of global politics-as-usual, which the power of gender sustains.