A gendered lens avoids essentialism and universalism
Anne Ruyan, 2018 (Ruyan, professor in the School of Public and International Affairs, faculty affiliate of Women’s, Gender and Sexuality Studies at the University of Cincinnati and has a PhD in International Relations. “Global Power Politics” Introduction, pgs 8-9 /// MF)
Contemporary feminist scholars engage in intersectional analysis to avoid the practice of “essentialism,” or the assumption that, for example, all women or all men or all those within a given race or class share the same experiences and interests. Only by recognizing how, for example, some women have benefi ted by the racial, class, sexual, and national origin oppres-sion of other women, whereas many men subordinated by these very characteristics still exercise gender oppression, can we advance a more comprehensive notion of gender equality that sees it as indivisible from racial, class, and sexual equality and equality among nations. Thus, a sole focus on gender equality can fail to address other sources of inequality (such as race and class discrimination) that disadvantage certain groups of women. At the same time, when such eff orts blame only men, and mostly non-elite men, for gender inequality and fail to address forms of discrimination that subordinated men experience (based on class, race, and/or sexuality), then subordinated men may withhold support for gender equality. A narrow focus on gender equality also maintains the power of gender, even as the socio-economic positionings of some women and men may be somewhat altered, as is addressed more in this chapter.
Another reason to avoid essentialism is also to avoid “universalism,” or universal prescriptions for how to achieve comprehensive gender equality. Not only do women not share the same experiences or interests as a result of their multiple identities derive from their differing social locations in the world, but also the sociopolitical, cultural, and historical con-texts in which women live vary significantly, requiring varying strategies for social change. These complex realities have made many feminists skeptical of resorting to “global” solutions just as they have recognized that “global” problems take many and differing “local” forms to which agents of social change must be attentive to create context-specific and context-sensitive solutions that do not backfire (Grewal and Kaplan 1994).