Addressing the structural issues, specifically the language used in IR is key to progress
Anne Ruyan, 2018 (Ruyan, professor in the School of Public and International Affairs, faculty affiliate of Women’s, Gender and Sexuality Studies at the University of Cincinnati and has a PhD in International Relations. “Global Power Politics” Gender(ed) Lenses on Global Politics, pgs 42-43/// MF)
Asking initially “Where are the women?” and subsequently “adding women”—and com-paring their positions to those of men—were and remain productive orientations. They make embodied women (and men) visible in our picture of world politics, illuminate how women and men are diff erently engaged with and aff ected by international politics, and reveal women as agents and activists, as well as victims of sociocultural, economic, and political oppres-sions. But adding women to existing paradigms also raised deeper questions by exposing how the conceptual structures themselves presuppose masculine experience and perspective. For example, women/femininity cannot simply be added to constructions that are constituted as masculine: the public sphere, rationality, political identity, objectivity, “economic man.” Either women as feminine cannot be added (e.g., women must become like men) or the con-structions themselves are transformed (e.g., adding women as feminine alters the masculine premise of the constructions and changes their meaning). In this sense, the exclusions of fem-ininity are not accidental or coincidental but rather are required for the analytical consistency of reigning explanatory frameworks.
The lesson that emerges from these studies is that we cannot systemically add women without rethinking gender—recognizing it not only as an empirical category or variable but also as an analytical category and governing code. Doing so requires acknowledging the constitutive power of language, which is most eff ectively addressed through a feminist poststructuralist (sometimes referred to as postmodern) lens. This redirects our attention from adding women and deploying sex as a variable to analyzing gender as a category of mental ordering that produces masculinity and femininity as hierarchical power relations. In eff ect, examining “the woman question” leads us to examine “the man question,” which, as argued in this text, leads us to examine questions of “race,” “class,” “sexuality,” and “nationality” as well. Doing so requires acknowledging intersectionality, derived from anti-racist and postcolonial feminist thought, as a necessary analytic, which is also further illuminated through poststructuralist lenses. As used in this text, poststructuralist lenses in general reject essentialized categories, unitary meanings, sovereign claims, universalizing solutions, and presumptions of (foundational) objectivity associated with positivist and modernist commit-ments. Moreover, feminist poststructuralists criticize the residual essentialism that haunts references to “women” and other “identity-based” groups, rendering them homogeneous, undiff erentiated wholes and erasing hierarchies within as well as across all groups.