Adding women reinforces essentialism and doesn’t result in change
Anne Ruyan, 2018 (Ruyan, professor in the School of Public and International Affairs, faculty affiliate of Women’s, Gender and Sexuality Studies at the University of Cincinnati and has a PhD in International Relations. “Global Power Politics” Gender and Global Security, pgs. 105-106 /// MF)
On the other side of the coin, as Whitworth (2004) argues based on her study of Canadian peacekeeping operations, the UN’s new interest in “adding women and stirring” simply grafts on (essentialist) gender analysis, which assumes women will just ease and assist the already predetermined business of peacekeeping and peace negotiations by bringing information on women and “women’s issues” into these activities. This predetermined business disregards any considerations of militarized masculinity as a major source of prolonged confl ict or such sources of structural violence as neocolonial economic and political relationships and neolib-eral economic restructuring that may lie at the heart of the confl ict (Whitworth 2004: 133, 137). Instead, this business focuses on “when the fi ghting broke out” and how to control, if not cease, it (Whitworth 2004: 133). Thus, rather than causing a rethinking of peacekeeping and peace negotiations, “analyses of women and of gender thus become part of the ‘programmatic solutions’ that form the UN repertoire of responding to confl ict and insecurity around the world, and, in this way, confi rm the appropriateness of the repertoire” (Whitworth 2004: 137). In this sense, like gender equality that is subsumed under neoliberal governmentality, gender perspectives on international peace and security are subsumed under a kind of security governmentality. Nine out of 11 peace agreements by 2005 had involved some focus on including women and providing for their security (mostly with respect to sexual violence), although that dropped to six out of nine agreements by 2010 (Ellerby 2017: 36–37). But the tenuous and minimalist nature of treating women as add-ons to an overall approach to simply managing confl icts underscores Whitworth’s conclusion that the issue is not so much adding more women to peacekeeping and peacemaking operations as it is questioning the sole reli-ance on militaries to do the job of peacekeeping and, by extension, on military leaders and civilian defense elites to do the job of peacemaking (2004: 183).