Intersectionality takes into account more marginalized perspectives and considers the idea of hegemonic masculinity and hierarchies within hierarchies
Anne Ruyan, 2018 (Ruyan, professor in the School of Public and International Affairs, faculty affiliate of Women’s, Gender and Sexuality Studies at the University of Cincinnati and has a PhD in International Relations. “Global Power Politics” Introduction, pgs 5-6 /// MF)
Contemporary gender studies that partake of intersectional analysis, which holds that gender cannot be understood in isolation from other identity categories and relations of inequality, recognize that there are multiple genders, as well as sexes, in part because race/ethnicity, class, sexuality, and other cultural variations shape gender identities and performances. The concept of intersectional analysis emerged from the work of black US feminist theorists in the 1980s and beyond (Crenshaw 1991; Collins 1991) who recognized that the lives and experiences of women of color were underrepresented in dominant Western feminist theories about women’s subordination that were based on the experiences of largely white, Western, middle-class, and/or working-class women.
Because the particular characteristics associated with femininity and masculinity vary signifi cantly across cultures, races, classes, and age groups, there are no generic women and men, cis or trans. Our gender identities, loyalties, interests, and opportunities are intersected and crosscut by countless dimensions of “diff erence,” especially those associated with ethnicity/race, class, national, and sexual identities. “Acting like a man” (or a “woman”) means diff er-ent things to diff erent groups of people (e.g., trans people, heterosexual Catholics, Native Americans, British colonials, agriculturists versus corporate managers, athletes versus orchestra conductors, combat soldiers versus military strategists) and to the same group of people at diff erent points in time (e.g., nineteenth- versus twentieth-century Europeans, col-onized versus postcolonial Africans, pre-puberty versus elderly age sets, women during war versus women after war). Men may be characterized as feminine (e.g., Mahatma Gandhi, “fl amboyant” gay men) and women as “masculine” (e.g., Margaret Thatcher, “butch” lesbians). Gender is shaped by race (models of masculinity and femininity vary among Africans, Indians, Asians, Europeans), and race is gendered (gender stereotypes shape racial stereo-types of Africans, Indians, Asians, whites). Moreover, because masculinities and femininities vary (by class, race/ethnicity, sexuality, age), some expressions of gender (Hispanic in the US, Muslim in India, Turkana in Kenya) are subordinated to dominant constructions of ender (Anglo, Hindu, Kikuyu). There are thus multiple masculinities that not only vary across cultures but also confer diff erent levels of power. What is referred to as “hegemonic masculinity” (Connell 1987, 1995) is the ideal form of masculinity performed by men with the most power attributes, who not incidentally populate most global power positions. These are typically white, Western, upper-class, straight cismen who have conferred on them the complete range of gender, race, class, national, and sexuality privileges. “Subordinated masculinities” (Connell 1987, 1995) are embodied by those who lack one, some, or all these privileges and are consequently rendered feminized and thus devalorized (a process explored more in this chapter) on these scores. Although all femininities are subordinated to all mascu-linities, it is also the case that some femininities are subordinated more than or diff erently from others. The idealized image of Western femininity remains associated with Victorian notions of womanhood that celebrated the gentility, passivity, decorativeness, and asexuality imposed on white, middle- to upper-class women, who were the only ones who could enact such standards. Working-class women, women of color, and/or lesbians or trans women are either denied the (dubious) status of feminine because they cannot meet these standards or are feminized in other ways through processes of racialization and/or sexualization . For example, since the times of slavery and colonization, women of color have been labeled as naturally oversexual, thereby not only being unworthy of (white) male protection but also particularly open to (white) male sexual exploitation.
[Anne Sisson Runyan.Global Gender Politics]