Only looking at the relations between different things can solve for structural violence and war – current lens creates violence
Anne Ruyan, 2018 (Ruyan, professor in the School of Public and International Affairs, faculty affiliate of Women’s, Gender and Sexuality Studies at the University of Cincinnati and has a PhD in International Relations. “Global Power Politics” Gender and Global Security, pgs. 86-87 /// MF)
Hence, feminists argue that to understand violence and insecurities, we must look not only within particular “levels” but also at the linkages among them. According to Ann Tickner,
Feminist perspectives on security would assume that violence, whether it be in the inter-national, national, or family realm, is interconnected. Family violence must be seen in the context of wider power relations; it occurs within a gendered society in which male power dominates at all levels . . .. Any feminist defi nition of security must therefore include the elimination of all types of violence, including violence produced by gender relations of domination and subordination.
(Tickner 1993: 58)
But as argued here, gender violence must also be seen in combination with racialized, sexual-ized, and class violence to reveal the interconnections between relations of domination and subordination that are present across all levels and constitute the conditions (structural violence) and goads for war (direct violence) as well as the eff ects of war or militarized confl ict. Unless these are taken seriously, even rival notions of (non-disaggregated) human security to state security will fail to recognize all the sources of insecurity (bred of the injustices of structural violence) and their diff erential eff ects.
At the same time, a more poststructural feminist view of security is that it is always “elusive and partial” because the quest for absolute security is in itself productive of violence: it relies on the eradication of all threats, real or imagined, and thus sets up a never-ending defensive and off ensive posture (Tickner 2001: 62). Such a posture is emblematic of the “sovereign man” (Ashley 1989), who, like the sovereign state that is fashioned upon this construct of hegemonic masculinity, thwarts connection and interdependence in fear of engagement with diff erence that might break down walls between the sovereign “self ” and the “other” on whom is projected all that one denies in oneself (Eisenstein 2007: 13).