The current system of a gender lens reinforces gender binaries and the idea of essentialism – only a gendered lens solves and overcomes these ideas
Anne Ruyan, 2018 (Ruyan, professor in the School of Public and International Affairs, faculty affiliate of Women’s, Gender and Sexuality Studies at the University of Cincinnati and has a PhD in International Relations. “Global Power Politics” Gender(ed) Lenses on Global Politics, pgs 38-40/// MF)
On the other hand, feminists, queer, and trans critics of heteronormativity and gender normativity have exposed the assumption of binary sex diff erence as stunted (reducing “sex” to paired opposites, precluding alternatives and commonalities), static (neglecting historical shifts in how “sex” is “seen” and responded to), simplistic (obscuring the complexity of “sex” and its relationship to gender), and politically problematic (unrefl ectively essentializing what is historically situated and socially constructed). Feminist research has additionally docu-mented the deeply sedimented normalization of dichotomized gender (generated by essen-tializing sex as a binary) as a governing code valorizing what is privileged as masculine at the expense of what is stigmatized as feminine. Gendered socialization and social control mechanisms amplify individual and collective internalization of, and investments in, repro-ducing gendered orderings. Here it is argued that more adequate analyses of power require attending to and integrating the critical insights particularly of poststructuralist, postcolonial, feminist, queer, and trans lenses. In particular, to comprehend the resilience of hierarchical thinking and its reproduction of divisions and inequalities requires making sense of the power of gender as a hegemonic and pernicious but typically unacknowledged worldview.
Stated simply and based on the discussion of the power of gender in Chapter 1 , the “naturalness” of sex difference becomes indistinguishable from the “naturalness” of dichotomized and hierarchical gender differentiation that we reproduce, consciously and unconsciously, as we act out gender in all areas of social life. Because of this interaction, gendered stereotypes have political significance far beyond their role in male–female relations. First, gender normalizes dichotomized thought as a deeply embedded practice reproduced throughout social orders. Second, the gender dichotomy is so taken as given that it lends authority to the binary logic that “naturally” divides terms and identity groups into polarized opposites. The naturalness of dichotomized gender then becomes indistinguishable from—and lends credibility and authority to—the naturalness of dichotomized thinking. Third, the normaliza-tion of dichotomized thinking reproduces not only gender hierarchy but also other relations of inequality as dichotomies are taken for granted and eff ectively legitimate hierarchical ordering.
At the same time and as argued earlier, the binary logic of positivist orientations normal-izes and privileges thinking in dichotomies. The elevated status of this logic lends credibility and authority to the practice of essentializing categories as paired opposites, valuing one over the “other” term, and normalizing domination of whatever and whoever is “othered.” In this sense, the normalization of dichotomies in modernist thought lends credibility and authority to the binary of sex and dichotomy of gender. Insofar as other familiar dichotomies have gen-dered connotations (culture–nature, reason–emotion, autonomy–dependency, public–private), when they are deployed in modernist thought, they buttress the stereotypes of masculine and feminine.
This is what is meant by mutually reinforcing: the dichotomy of gender gains its natural-ness by being grounded in the assumption of essentialized sex diff erence; gendered orderings are normalized by being reproduced throughout social life; dichotomies gain their taken-for-granted and even desirable status by being privileged in modernist thought and acquiring credibility through the “reality” of pervasive gendered diff erentiation. The mutually reinforcing interplay of essentializing sex, dichotomizing gender, and the binary logic of positivism generates the constellation of dimensions of the meta-lens of the power of gender. Recog-nizing the power of these coding and fi ltering devices is crucial for improving our ability to see beyond essentialized identities and oppositional “wholes.” Thus, feminists argue that dichotomized thinking cannot be adequately understood, critiqued, or eff ectively transformed without addressing how sex-diff erentiated gender grounds, naturalizes, and reproduces binary thinking.
These points are crucial to the arguments of this text because the perpetuation of dichotomized thinking and its gendered normalizations reproduces hierarchical divisions and, hence, antagonistic relations between groups. But the power of gender also operates to obscure intersectionality, and, thus, the gendered power relations and divisions discussed in Chapter 1 . When the power of gender focuses attention on essentialized notions of gender—masculinity and femininity—we fail to see these as constructed and crosscutting dimensions operating within any particular group and across groups. This is among the problems with the way in which gender has been taken up by international policymakers, not as a matter of equality and social justice, but rather instrumentalizing women’s empowerment to try to “fi x” serial crises without addressing deeper ones that arise from not only gender but also gendered divisions. Similarly, when essentialized notions of group identities erase the diff erentiations within them, we fail to see the complexity of social orders and how inequalities are often sustained by pitting subordinated groups against each other. We are seeing this now in the rise of illiberal democracies resulting from the cultivation of ethno-nationalist and masculin-ist political backlash, associated with some (typically white, global North, working-class, and heterosexual) men falling down the economic ladder and “strong man” political rhetoric that places the blame for this on groups also in increasing and often greater precarity. Such blaming defl ects attention from the global crises that are producing and are the result of vast and intersecting inequalities, while undermining the equality struggles of all subordinated groups. This militates against the potential for coalitions and more comprehensive resistances to unjust social and global political orders. Deploying intersectional analysis facilitates a more comprehensive notion of gender equality that is indivisible from racial, class, and sex-ual equality and equality among nations. It encourages contemporary feminist IR scholars to ask not just “Where are the women?” but also “Which women?” and “Where are the men and which men?”