The idea of power within traditional IR is based on historical ideas of “men” and colonization – feminist perspectives are key to taking all aspects into consideration
Anne Ruyan, 2018 (Ruyan, professor in the School of Public and International Affairs, faculty affiliate of Women’s, Gender and Sexuality Studies at the University of Cincinnati and has a PhD in International Relations. “Global Power Politics” Introduction, pgs 11-12 /// MF)
In IR, as in political science generally, power is usually defi ned as “power over,” specifi -cally, the ability to get someone to do what you want. It is usually measured by control of resources, especially those supporting physical coercion. The appropriate analogy might be power understood as tools: if you have them, you can use them to get certain things done if and when you choose, and some have more of these tools than others. This defi nition assumes measurable capacities, privileges instrumental rationality, and emphasizes separation and competition: those who have power use it (or its threat) to keep others from securing enough to threaten them. The emphasis on material resources and coercive ability defl ects attention from the fact that power reckoning is embedded in dominant conceptual orders, value systems, disciplinary practices, and institutional dynamics.
In IR, the concept of “political actor”—the legitimate wielder of society’s power—is derived from classical political theory. Common to constructions of “political man”—from Plato and Aristotle to Hobbes, Locke, and Rousseau—is the privileging of “man’s” capacity for reason. Rationality ostensibly distinguishes man from other animals and explains his pursuit of freedom—from nature and “necessity” as well as from tyranny. Feminist scholarship has exposed how models of human nature presupposed in constructions of political man are not in fact gender-neutral but are androcentric , based on exclusively male (especially elite male) experience and perspective. With reference to gender divisions of power, “woman” is excluded conceptually from political power by denying her the rationality that marks “man” as the highest animal. Substantively, women have historically been excluded from political power by states’ limiting citizenship to those who perform military duty and/or are property owners. Under these conditions, most women are structurally excluded from formal politics, even though individual women in exceptional circumstances have wielded considerable political power. Women worldwide have largely won the battle for the vote, though defi ni-tions of citizenship continue to limit women’s access to public power and women’s political power is circumscribed by a variety of indirect means (discussed more in Chapter 3 ). Most obvious are the continued eff ects of the dichotomy of public–private that privileges men’s productive and “political” activities over women’s reproductive and “personal/familial” activities. For example, sovereign man and sovereign states are defi ned not by connection or relationships but by (masculinist) autonomy in decision-making and putative freedom from interdependence and collective responsibilities. Although Aristotle acknowledged that the public sphere depends upon the (re)production of life’s necessities in the private sphere, he denied the interdependence that this implies in articulating political theory.
With reference to gender ed divisions of power, “political man” also presupposed “civiliza-tional” status: early Greek texts excluded “barbarians” and Persians; premodern European texts excluded “primitives” and racialized “others” within Europe and outside it as coloniza-tion proceeded. Indeed, racialization is historically inextricable from the expansionary and colonizing practices of European elites who deployed Enlightenment ideas (“reason,” “science”) and new technologies (gunpowder, steam engine) to enhance their power over foreign populations, thus enabling the extraction of resources and labor to fuel European “modernization” and geopolitical dominance. “Eurocentrism” is an ideology of European superiority that arose from this conquest and is often used interchangeably with “Western-centrism” in more recent times. “Orientalism” (Said 1979) is one eff ect of Eurocentrism (or “Occidentalism”), consigning the “non-West” to the status of cultural, political, economic, and technological backwardness. Such backwardness is assumed, in Eurocentric and Orien-talist thinking, to need stimulation from the West to “develop” or “modernize” or “progress.” Thus, men and women of various colonized, racialized, and classed groups have been excluded over time from political power by various means: barred on the basis of property claims, denied leadership in their own lands by colonial domination, displaced to other lands and denied power through slavery and debt bondage, and more generally excluded from citizenship rights based on criteria related to birth location, “appropriate” documentation, or “economic” status. Although after World War II resistance to direct colonial rule was largely successful, more indirect “neocolonial” or “neoimperial” rule (sometimes referred to as “recolonization”), in which former colonial or newer superpowers control or seek to control the polities and economies of formerly colonized nations, has continued. Such labels as “developed” versus “developing” countries or the terms “First” and “Third” Worlds attest to the maintenance colonial logics that construct the West (or the North more broadly) as more advanced politically and economically than the rest. Colonial logics also continue through sexualized as well as racialized divisions of power, justifying the invasion or control of “others” by coding the West as uniquely moral and “respectable,” as well as racially superior.
Today, most people have a “right” to political participation, but the most powerful decision-makers in global politics are those occupying positions of power in national and international governmental institutions and transnational corporations. Occupants of these positions now include elites from both the global North and the global South, terms used in this text to avoid such problematic and inaccurate references as developed vs. developing countries or First vs. Third Worlds. Such elites, regardless of their geographic origin, continue to refl ect privileged statuses, especially of national and economic power, which are derived from being members of the dominant ethnicity/race, class, gender, and sexuality.
[Anne Sisson Runyan.Global Gender Politics]