Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Fem ir accounts for power in a more broad sense thus challenging the assumptions that traditional IR was built upon

Anne Ruyan, 2018 (Ruyan, professor in the School of Public and International Affairs, faculty affiliate of Women’s, Gender and Sexuality Studies at the University of Cincinnati and has a PhD in International Relations. “Global Power Politics” Gender(ed) Lenses on Global Politics, pgs 27-28 /// MF)

Feminist IR scholars, emerging in the discipline by the 1980s, generally do not subscribe to the conventional defi nition of IR as being the power struggles between sovereign states in an anarchic world in which there is no supranational government to control state behaviors through the rule of law. Rather, these scholars favor an alternative defi nition of IR: “the iden-tifi cation and explanation of social stratifi cations and of inequality as structured at the level of global relations” (Brown 1988: 461). In this sense, feminist perspectives on IR understand power in broader and more complex terms than more conventional IR scholars do, and have sought to put the relations of people, as agents and within social structures, back into IR. To do so, these IR scholars have relied on feminist sociopolitical theorizing in other disciplines, including the now well-developed (inter)discipline of women’s, gender, and sexuality studies.

They have also relied on, and contributed to, an array of other IR lenses, arising prior to and after the emergence of feminist IR, that critique conventional IR for such things as assuming reality is given rather than socially constructed, centering the state and state elites as the main actors in world aff airs to the exclusion of actors above and below the state, and failing to see or center how global power structures and relations immiserate the majority of the world’s people and the planet. What connects what are broadly referred to here as critical lenses or perspectives on IR is the view that conventional IR, as a result of its focus on political and economic elites and state power, and its relative blindness to the deleterious eff ects of dominant political, economic, and social arrangements upheld by elites and states, is oriented to serving elites to maintain global power structures. Thus, conventional IR is not value-free. Critical perspectives, which maintain no knowledge is value-free and that scholars should acknowledge their always present values or normative commitments that invariably shape the questions they ask, are, in contrast, oriented to producing more “emancipatory” knowledge, which confronts global power structures and relations and their eff ects on peoples and the planet. Critical perspectives, however, do diff er in terms of which global power struc-tures and relations they highlight, how those structures and relations are understood, and what to do about them. Feminist IR perspectives center gender as a global power relation and structure. But as presented in Chapter 1 and expanded upon in this chapter, feminist intersec-tional analysis in IR goes beyond a gender lens to encompass a gendered lens that highlights the interconnections among global power relations and structures.

This chapter begins with an account of how lenses work and why they matter in a general sense. It then moves to a discussion of IR lenses. Despite the proliferation of such lenses, certain conventional ones still hold sway and take us down very narrow and problematic paths. Why this is the case is particularly explored through a discussion of more privileged positivist knowledge production in conventional IR versus more marginalized postpositivist knowledge production in critical approaches to IR of which feminist IR is a part. Feminist IR, and the multiple perspectives in and approaches to it, is the subject of the rest of the chapter. This discussion includes how feminist IR in particular challenges the power of gender that especially infuses conventional IR lenses and makes them hegemonic or dominant in unques-tioned ways, and produces research that is dedicated to revealing and countering gender and gendered divisions of power, violence, labor, and resources in global politics. Such research informs the empirical fi ndings and analysis presented in Chapters 3 , 4 , and 5 , which examine gender and gendered divisions and their contributions to global crises in the contexts of global governance, security, and political economy.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.