Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Contemporary fem IR reveals and overcomes the mistakes – like exclusion - made by traditional IR

Anne Ruyan, 2018 (Ruyan, professor in the School of Public and International Affairs, faculty affiliate of Women’s, Gender and Sexuality Studies at the University of Cincinnati and has a PhD in International Relations. “Global Power Politics” Gender(ed) Lenses on Global Politics, pgs 45-46/// MF)

In the contemporary period, feminist IR is characterized as consisting of two major and interactive areas of inquiry—feminist security studies (FSS) 4 and feminist international (or global) political economy (F(I or G)PE) studies. 5 FSS scholars engage with and critique conventional, state-centric understandings of war, peace, and security that remain at the center of the discipline of IR and challenge the everyday as well as international violence they leave in place. They re-theorize such concepts as states, just war, the democratic peace, and human security through a gender(ed) lens while emphasizing the role of “subjectivities,” human “agency,” and “discourses” (or narratives) as well as bodies and emotions in the production and experience of direct violence, from the intimate to the global (Hudson 2018: 129). F(I or G)PE scholars focus most on “economic insecurities” produced by neo(colonial-ism), (capitalist) economic development, and globalization and the gendered nature of these processes (Hudson 2018: 129). They apply more materialist analyses to reveal how conven-tional accounts of the global political economy and its global governance structures fail to understand how the political economy of gender—from the sex, domestic labor, and beauty trades to the reliance on women’s unpaid reproductive labor to make up for declining wages, public services, and environmental protection standards under global (and fi nancial) capitalism—underpins unjust global economic relations. As a result, they are more focused on structural violence. However, FSS and F(I or G)PE scholarship often intersect, such as in studies on the political economy of peacekeeping in rural societies that disregards women’s economic roles in the gathering of food and fuel far away from homes and refugee camps, making them most vulnerable to attacks, or in studies on the privatization of security forces, either as subcontracted or mercenary labor, which is implicated in greater direct (including sexual) violence being perpetrated on local populations (particularly women) with less accountability than state militaries (Hudson 2018: 135). Although FSS inquiry is highlighted in Chapter 4 and F(I or G)PE inquiry is highlighted in Chapter 5 of this text, as is argued throughout the book, there are strong connections made between direct and structural violence and discursive and material forms of violence in much current feminist IR scholarship. 6

As interrelated FSS and F(I or G)PE research has burgeoned, scholars working in these areas have multiplied the methodologies used in IR inquiry in order to get at the multiple ways in which global politics is gendered. In contrast to conventional positivist IR research, feminist IR scholars (and other transnational feminist scholars who engage with and contribute to feminist IR thought) have often utilized such qualitative approaches as ethnographic fi eldwork to learn about the lives of the non-elite, social action research through participant observation of social movements, and discourse analysis of classic IR texts, world leaders’ pronouncements, (inter)governmental policies and documents, NGO campaigns, and local group articulations of social problems. In doing so, they consider the role of emotion and bodily experience in the production and reproduction of global political actions and reactions. They thus participate in what is referred to as the “aff ective” turn in IR inquiry, which destabilizes rational actor claims in IR and takes seriously how global politics thought and practice are embodied phenomenon. They also plumb cultural sources, such as popular culture images on the airwaves and the Internet and even literature, art, and poetry, to fi nd expressions over time and space of resistance to global politics-as-usual in unusual places (Ackerly, Stern, and True 2006). As a result, feminist scholarship, as well as, increasingly, other critical scholarship, also engages in what has been referred to as the “visual” or “aesthetic” turn in IR inquiry, which examines such things as images, mediascapes, places, and cartographies to better understand how global politics is embedded in, shaped by, productive, and reproductive of cultural construction and processes.

Such practices seek to reveal the underside of global politics, simultaneously exposing the gendered dynamics that underlie and infect the thought, language, structures, and practices of it and privileging dissident and alternative voices about how it might be rethought, reartic-ulated, and rearranged. These practices also require refl exivity about the power relations between the researcher and the researched. In cases of “studying down”—such as working with non-elite actors—feminist IR scholars aim to be cognizant of their privilege and, thus, their responsibility to allow such actors to represent themselves in their own ways so as not to impose Eurocentric/Orientalist, heteronormative, gender normative, or classist interpreta-tions on the motivations, nature, and outcomes of their struggles. When “studying up”—or dealing with elite or more privileged actors—feminist IR scholars aim to be cognizant of how such actors limit access to researchers engaged in critical scholarship and mystify their power through bureaucratic language. Discourse analysis is thus especially productive when studying up because it enables reading between the lines and catching how the powerful con-sistently represent themselves and how they consistently represent “others” to justify their policies and actions. In these ways, feminist IR scholarship itself seeks to counter the crisis of representation both in the fi eld of IR, in which the study of people and especially non-elite people has historically been absent, and in global politics, which has historically operated as if people and especially non-elite people did not matter. Moreover, it has ignored how bodies, embodied experiences, and embodied thought are integral to producing and understanding global political phenomenon

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.