Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Trying to be the “savior” especially if they believe they are vulnerable – history proves and it ends up foreclosing the possibility of change within the system

Anne Ruyan, 2018 (Ruyan, professor in the School of Public and International Affairs, faculty affiliate of Women’s, Gender and Sexuality Studies at the University of Cincinnati and has a PhD in International Relations. “Global Power Politics” Gender and Global Security, pg. 87-88 /// MF)

On this point, Susan Faludi’s The Terror Dream (2007) continues to be quite instructive. Not only does this work document the resurgence in the US of a state security discourse proff ered across the airwaves, almost exclusively by military men (to the almost absolute exclusion of female and particularly feminist voices representing alternative views), in the fi rst few years of the post-9/11 period, but it also analyzes the resurgence of older sexist and racist mythologies from America’s past called up to cover up the chink in the sovereign man’s armor. Faludi asks us to consider the lionizing of male rescue workers at “ground zero” (and the attendant silencing of female rescue workers long discriminated against, as well as widows who questioned the US military response, because neither conformed with adulating male protection and security at any cost), the ersatz “rescue” of US soldier Jessica Lynch supposedly from rapacious Iraqi captors (who turned out to be caring medical personnel), or overblown (and in most cases untrue) claims about women opting out of the workplace to return home to raise babies and become “security moms” in support of war. She argues that these convenient “fi ctions” have roots in earlier frontier stories, captivity narratives, and Cold War hysterias. These get trotted out whenever there are fears of “masculine insuffi ciency” because hegemonic masculinity cannot countenance “vulnerability” (Faludi 2007: 280).

When we look more closely at the events behind these earlier narratives, we fi nd that white male frontiersmen (such as Daniel Boone) were, in fact, undistinguished as providers or protectors and more often relied on the provisioning and protective skills of their wives, children, and indigenous peoples to survive, and the majority of white women taken captive by indigenous peoples either preferred to stay with their newfound families into which they were adopted or won their release from their captors on their own (Faludi 2007: 212, 256–262). Nevertheless, Faludi argues, insecure times in patriarchal cultures ratchet up the need for elaborate mythologies that “measure national male strength by female peril,” requiring that “women be saved from more and more gruesome violation to prove their saviors’ valor” (2007: 262). In the US white patriarchal cultural imagination, that peril is limited to con-cerns for white women and symbolized most by racialized men, whether they be indigenous “captors” of old and newer Iraqi ones, the “yellow” and “Hun” hordes of World War II, or the “red” communist threat of the Cold War. In each case, fears of “alien” invasion required the “securing of American domesticity,” which conjured images of (white) women (re)confi ned to the home front, obsessions with “women’s sexual purity” supposedly at risk from racial-ized men, and a summoning of “John Wayne and his avenging brethren” (Faludi 2007: 282–283, 286).

Thus, in each case, we also see a “remasculinization of America” (Jeff ords 1989). A number of periods of this have occurred since the 1980s. Seeking to put behind them the defeat in Vietnam that led to a more chastened view about the value of military confl ict to solve problems and secure geopolitical objectives, Reagan-era neoconservatives—through public discourse and policy and even popular culture—rehabilitated the Rambo-esque masculinist and militarist values of might makes right, unfettered by “feminine” considerations about the costs and usefulness of war. The post-9/11 remasculinization of America under yet another neoconservative government was justifi ed with resort to the necessity of war arising from some inevitable “clash of civilizations” in which one ethnic and religious fundamentalism must combat another (the West/Christianity against the East/Islam), but also with resort, at least for a short time, to the claim that the war in Afghanistan was about civilized men (in the West) saving women from barbaric men (the Taliban). Today, under a far-right regime that claimed the previous more liberal one was “weak” on security (despite a record of massive deportations and drone warfare in the midst of troop drawdowns in Iraq and Afghanistan), has reignited obsessions with “homeland security” now entwined with discourses of “America fi rst” that justify, for example, wall-building on the basis of such specious arguments as keeping Mexican “rapists” out.

In such times, Faludi reminds us that the constant replaying of this “security myth” and the remasculinization of leadership and civil society it entails disables an alternative response. Such a response “involves learning to live with insecurity, fi nding accommodation with—even drawing strength from—an awareness of vulnerability” (2007: 286) in order not to create sacrifi cial altars, but instead to create space for multiple and less vitriolic voices and ways of acting and being.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.