Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Diplomats are more likely to follow through on commitments

Casler 21, Ph.D. Candidate, Political Science Department, Columbia University (Don, “Credible To Whom? The Organizational Politics of Credibility in International Relations,” Mershon Center Working Papers, https://mershoncenter.osu.edu/sites/default/files/2021-04/Casler_NWR_Draft.pdf)//BB

Diplomats’ conception of credibility derives from their wide range of duties: translating between the home government and the world; providing early warning of troubles and opportunities; building and fixing relationships; and integrating the military, economic, and intelligence tools of statecraft.53 Diplomats are socialized to be experts in communication, relationship management, and negotiation — whether because they are career civil servants steeped in the art of diplomacy or because they enter government from business or law, where such skills also receive special emphasis. As a result, their self-image is as the first line of defense against international strife,54 or the process-oriented analyst and reporter who keeps the home government informed, represents its interests, and cajoles others into doing what the home government wants. Securing others’ trust is essential for each of these objectives, making diplomats highly focused on the personal and behavioral dimensions of cultivating relationships.55 This means that diplomats constantly and keenly observe how the home government is perceived across a broad range of issues, events, and commitments, which they see as tightly interconnected. The wide scope of diplomats’ core mission inculcates a broad definition of national interests and a capacious understanding of what the home government’s actions can indicate to international audiences.56 Since their chief objective is to cultivate strong, durable impressions and relationships that will persist over anticipated future interactions, I argue that diplomats conceive of credibility primarily in terms of national interests and signaling reputation — in other words, as the willingness to keep commitments and bear costs. Military officers’ conception of credibility stems from their military education, which limits the proper role of military force in foreign policy to traditional security goals such as protecting territory, geostrategic positions, and allies.57 This experience socializes military officials to be experts in managing violence through specialized training in military operations, tactics, and logistics.58 As a result, their self-image is as the goal-oriented technician, taking sober stock of a given task’s hard capability requirements.59 Because they are attentive to the nuts and bolts of military interventions as well as all that can go wrong in war, military officials hold a pessimistic professional viewpoint that typically demands maximum capabilities to address any contingency.60 This manifests in the military ethic of “conservative realism,” stressing the possession of ready forces to meet potential challenges and opposing the extension of commitments or issuance of threats unless the capacity to follow through exists.61

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.