Redlines embolden aggression more than clarity AND jeopardize NATO’s credibility
Z’hra M. Ghavam 16—Lieutenant Commander, United States Navy, B.S., United States Naval Academy. ("NATO’s Preparedness for Cyberwar," September 2016, https://calhoun.nps.edu/handle/10945/50552)
NATO’s publicly declared policy on cyber threats is consciously and purposefully vague.207 Why? Strategic ambiguity has its benefits. According to the Atlantic Council panel, there is no “redline” or “determined threshold” that would automatically define a cyber act as an act of war.208 Leaving the rules undefined affords NATO ample room in which to operate. For a 28-member multinational organization that operates on the principle of consensus, time and latitude for solidifying strategic-level decisions are critical. If NATO publicized a cyber redline, it would box the Alliance into a corner. This kind of policy could embolden cyber offenders and provoke massive intrusions that target NATO’s networks at just below this threshold. Having a defined redline could also invite nefarious cyber actors to cross it to test NATO’s resolve, damage its reputation as a leader in Euro-Atlantic security, and undermine the credibility of its Article 5 commitments.
Following the Wales Summit in 2014, NATO affirmed its stance on law and cyberspace while refusing to address cyber redlines:
Our policy also recognizes that international law, including international humanitarian law and the UN Charter, applies in cyberspace. Cyber attacks can reach a threshold that threatens national and Euro-Atlantic prosperity, security, and stability. Their impact could be as harmful to modern societies as a conventional attack. We affirm, therefore, that cyber defense is part of NATO’s core task of collective defense. A decision as to when a cyber attack would lead to the invocation of Article 5 would be taken by the North Atlantic Council on a case-by-case basis.209
However, an invocation of Article 5 does not necessarily mean that a NATO response would include force. Article 5 of the Washington Treaty states the following:
The Parties agree that an armed attack against one or more of them in Europe or North America shall be considered an attack against them all and consequently they agree that, if such an armed attack occurs, each of them, in exercise of the right of individual or collective self-defense recognized by Article 51 of the Charter of the United Nations, will assist the Party or Parties so attacked by taking forthwith, individually and in concert with the other Parties, such action as it deems necessary, including the use of armed force, to restore and maintain the security of the North Atlantic area.210
Thus, as long as each Alliance member takes “such action as it deems necessary,” it cannot be found in violation of the collective defense principle.211 In the case of a major act of cyberwar against one of its members, NATO could invoke Article 5 as a show of solidarity but opt to refrain from employing kinetic military force; instead, the Alliance could use purely cybernetic means or a hybrid alternative that combined cybernetic tools with military force to fulfill its objectives.
In all, NATO’s establishment, organization, and employment of its sophisticated cyber response agencies and IT resources like the NCIRC, NCIO, NCIA, and RRT are indicative of how seriously the Alliance has implemented its cyber defense policies at the operational level. NATO’s cyber policy, standard operating procedures, and ambiguous thresholds for the use of military force make the Alliance highly prepared to respond effectively to major acts of cyber aggression against one or more of its members. If an act of cyberwar met the threshold of an armed attack, NATO would probably be prepared to manage, counter, and resolve the issue in cyberspace; still, one cannot exclude the possible need to take kinetic measures. Out of a numerical ranking of 1–3, the Alliance earned a preparedness score of 3 in cyber strategy.