Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Ambiguity entangles the US and allies with offensive action—increasing cyber cooperation and defining proportional response solves

Arts 18—Program coordinator supporting The German Marshall Fund of the United States’ (GMF) security and defense policy work in Washington DC, strengthens transatlantic cooperation on regional, national, and global challenges and opportunities in the spirit of the Marshall Plan (Sophie, December 2018, “Offense as the New Defense: New Life for NATO’s Cyber Policy,” GMF Policy Brief, No. 039, https://nato-engages.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/Offense-as-the-New-Defense-New-Life-for-NATO%E2%80%99s-Cyber-Policy.pdf)

Perhaps most importantly, as NATO stands ready to integrate defensive and offensive cyber operations, it should further clarify how these relate to its collective defense provision. Although NATO holds that Article 5 could be invoked following a “significant” cyberattack against one or more of the allies,46 officials have remained deliberately ambiguous when it comes to defining the parameters of a qualifying attack so as to discourage hostile operations that would fall just below such a specific threshold.47 Without a clear line, allies have more room to maneuver in a cyber crisis short of invoking Article 5. However, recent experience across the alliance has yielded little proof that the strategic ambiguity in this domain is effective in preventing hostile operations.

As NATO seeks to address this challenge, it will need to assess how to develop an effective cyber policy that balances deterrence with the potential risk for escalation. With this in mind, it should establish more precise thresholds for cyber-attacks and define proportional response scenarios.48 Without these, it will likely remain very challenging to mobilize allies to invoke Article 5 in a cyber crisis. This could be particularly difficult if a crisis were to be triggered or exacerbated by offensive cyber operations under the command of a NATO ally or if such operation on the part of NATO were used as a pretext for crisis. Considering the potential escalatory nature of a more forward-leaning posture – within NATO and driven by its largest member, the United States – these questions should be urgently addressed.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.