Commitment to proportional response restores deterrence credibility and prevents escalation spirals
Schulze 19 (Dr Matthias Schulze is Associate in the International Security Division at SWP; “Cyber Deterrence is Overrated” SWP, August 2019; https://www.swp-berlin.org/10.18449/2019C34/)
Deterrence fails if the threat of punishment is not considered credible. Deterrence failure often leads to the use of capabilities and thus escalation. This raises questions about the proportionality, effectiveness and accuracy of cyber retaliation capabilities. How much objective damage must be inflicted so that A considers the costs of further offensive action to be too high? How does D know whether A considers threats against certain assets to be particularly painful or not? A and D most likely have different perceptions about what assets are considered especially sensitive. These different perceptions make proportional reactions difficult. There is no international consensus on how proportional cyber retaliation might be conceived. Thus there is an increased risk of escalation. The damage caused by cyber retaliation must be appropriate. If the damage threatened by D is too great, the probability of a renewed retaliation by A increases. It is well researched in political science, that escalation spirals are often a consequence if a retaliation is perceived as inappropriate or too painful. In these cases, deterrence fails. If the threat of punishment is considered not costly enough and thus not credible, deterrence does not work either. Determining the correct measure is highly complex and also a function of the attribution problem: the lower the chance of being caught, the greater the threat of punishment by D must be