Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Russian cyber operations blur the line between wartime and peace—they’ll utilize cyber and AI in tandem to escalate

Aaltola 21—Director of the Finnish Institute of International Affairs, Finland, and Professor of International Relations at Tallinn University, Estonia (Mika Aaltola, 2021, Democratic Vulnerability and Autocratic Meddling, Chapter 4: Russian Cyber-Enabled Diversions in the West, Springer)

The challenge to the existing regional order inevitably blurs the line between normal and unconventional. What is considered legal, established, and conventional becomes an obstacle as the challenger tries to reset the rules and expectations. This logic increases the possibility of unexpected events in the region. The distinction between peacetime and wartime practices can become more blurred. However, there is no evidence of using cyberattacks to cause widespread physical damage in the region; infrastructure has been outside of the targets.

So far, the attacks have been unlikely to attract clear retaliatory actions. Risks have clearly been taken by Russia, but in a calculated way that maximizes the psychological and political effects and minimizes the chances of punishment. On the other hand, the harm scale that focuses on physical damage misses the real significance of politically motivated cyberattacks. For example, the damage caused by rigging an election process far surpasses some of the physical harm scenarios.

It is important to realize that even when uncovered, the attacks showcase the perpetrators’ capabilities. This can even be useful for the attacker, as its image as a powerful modern actor is highlighted in public discussions. When an operation becomes public, the perpetrators can always point to attribution issues and deny their role in the operations to delegitimize any retaliation. Perhaps paradoxically, public revelations about ongoing and active cyber operations can even be part of the overall strategic goal of demonstrating power and impunity. This is a possibility that target states and institutions have to consider.

Although many lessons have been learnt by now, the main response to cyberattacks has been to strengthen deterrence by bolstering cybersecurity. The systems are now in a much higher reactive mode. Vigilance has been increased against different types of shocks, disruptions, and attacks. It is likely that the West will continue to be a target of low- to mediumintensity cyber operations. One may argue about whether high resilience can be achieved without more active deterrent measures. On the other hand, it takes two to tango online. The higher the active deterrence, the stronger the counterreaction is likely to be. The fear is that this may culminate in a destabilizing cyber arms race.

Ever higher awareness is needed to recognize that cyber operations have strategic aims that go beyond mere snooping and spying and, especially those, that can be sowing the seeds for or be parts of much more serious societal destabilization and democracy meddling operations. Clearly, cyber tools and operations can be effective in spreading mistrust, blackmail, and bullying, and in displaying capabilities and deterrence. They are useful in combination with other politically pressurizing tools. The spectrum of these combinatorial tools is still being experimented and the tools are likely to evolve considerably. The clear concern is that the situation may escalate, in which case the level of harm caused by cyber operations in combination with other influence tools will become higher and more intense for the highly digitalized democracies. One should also note that the level of harm is always realized in hindsight. The Dukes and Red October/Turla were identified only a long time after the infections. This suggests that in the present moment, there might already be ongoing attack campaigns with a higher level of harm which are yet to be detected. The analysis cannot exclude the possibility of a further escalation in malicious cyber and AI activities and their use in tandem with destabilizing cognitive operations and hybrid tool. If such a scenario materializes, then the intensifying cyber operations of today can be seen as a preparatory phase for a far more aggressive challenge directed mainly at the key functions and stability of the Western political systems.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.