Single Payer contains costs through administrative savings AND moderate bargaining. Our evidence cites the best studies.
John Geyman 18. John Geyman, M.D. is professor emeritus of family medicine at the University of Washington School of Medicine in Seattle. 01/01/2018. “Crisis in U.S. Health Care: Corporate Power Still Blocks Reform.” International Journal of Health Services, vol. 48, no. 1, pp. 5–27.
Single-Payer Expanded and Improved Medicare for All Act This proposal, as national health insurance, is the only way that all Americans will ever achieve universal coverage of health care, wherever they live and regardless of their health status or income. Under national health insurance (NHI) and its current bill (H.R. 676) in the House, they will have free choice of physicians and hospitals without copayments or other out-of-pocket costs at the point of service. Benefits include physician and hospital care, outpatient care, dental and vision services, rehabilitation, long-term care, home care, mental health care, and prescription drugs. Private insurers will be banned from providing duplicative coverage to the public program. The public financing system will be coupled with a private delivery system, whereby budgets with hospitals and other facilities will be negotiated annually, physicians will be paid on a negotiated fee system, and prices of prescription drugs will be negotiated (as the Veterans Administration has done for years, getting discounts of more than 40% based on bulk purchasing). NHI will be funded through an equitable system of progressive taxes, with 95% of taxpayers paying less than they do now for insurance and care. Much of today’s bureaucracy in health care will be eliminated, saving $503 billion a year on reduced administrative overhead; an additional $113 billion will be saved [[TABLE OMITTED]] annually by negotiating drug prices.22 Table 1 compares these three reform alternatives. Today’s Crisis in U.S. Health Care Despite significant progress under the ACA, these markers show that the nation’s health care system is still in a crisis mode. . Access to care is still a barrier for 28 million uninsured as well as at least 30 million people who are underinsured. . Annual deductibles over $5,000 have become common, together with rising copayments, coinsurance, surprise bills, and other out of-pocket expenses. . Churning of coverage is endemic in the ACA’s marketplace, with 43% of returning consumers switching plans in the federal exchange in 2015, often forcing a change of physicians and available hospitals.23 . In a system without significant price controls, the ACA has provided no significant cost containment, as health care stocks on Wall Street have soared. . The combined annual cost of insurance and care now exceeds $25,000 for typical families of four, way beyond their budgets in view of the ranmedian annual family income of $53,800. . According to a 2014 report from the Commonwealth Fund, almost 30% of privately insured, working-age Americans with deductibles at least 5% of their annual income did not go to a doctor for a medical problem because of costs.24 . Medical bankruptcies still affect more than one million people each year, despite most having had insurance before their illness or accident. . A one-year cost of cancer drugs often exceeds $200,000, and many patients have to choose between forgoing treatment and bankruptcy.25 . With no physician workforce plan in force, the nation’s primary care shortage continues to get worse, as is also the case with psychiatry; less than 10% of U.S. medical school graduates enter family medicine today, while a majority of internists and pediatricians reject primary care in favor of subspecialty practice. . As a result of the decline of primary care physicians, fragmentation and depersonalization of care are now the norm, with continuity of care difficult to attain. . Since many psychiatric hospital beds have been closed in recent decades, jails now house 10 times more mentally ill people than state mental hospitals26; only 4 in 10 jails offer them psychiatric medications.27 . Quality of care is mediocre for much of the population; medical errors account for about 250,000 deaths each year,28 while a recent study of 22 million hospital admissions found that patients are three times more likely to die in the worst hospitals and have 13 times as many medical complications compared to the best hospitals.29 . Cross-national studies by the Commonwealth Fund have shown for years that the United States performs at or near the bottom among 11 advanced countries in access, efficiency, equity, and quality of health care.30 . Faced with uncertainty in the health insurance markets, many insurers are exiting the market for 2018, leaving more than 1,370 counties in the United States with only one available insurer on the ACA exchanges.31
How Corporate Stakeholders Continue to Thrive and Block Reform Corporatization and growth of for-profit health care has been an increasing trend dating back to the 1970s. Corporate hospital chains were established within a few years after Medicare and Medicaid were enacted in 1965. Wall Street soon became enamored with the profits to be made as investor-owned facilities and services grew rapidly. Their corporate profits after taxes increased by more than 100 times between 1965 and 1990, at a pace almost 20 times greater than profits for all U.S. corporations.32 As freewheeling markets dominated the health care system, Robert Kuttner, cofounder of The American Prospect, observed the failures of these markets at the turn of the century in this way: In America, the over-reliance on market logic and market institutions is ruining the health care system. Market enthusiasts fail to tabulate all the costs of relying on market forces to allocate health care—the fragmentation, opportunism, asset rearranging, overhead, under-investment in public health, and the assault on norms of service and altruism. They assume either a degree of self-regulation that the health markets cannot generate, or far-sighted public supervision that contradicts the rest of their world view ... There is no realm of our mixed economy where markets yield more perverse results.33 Geyman 9 Figure 1 shows the extent of private for-profit ownership of parts of the U.S. health care system today. Consolidation and mergers have become increasingly common in the last two decades. Despite the theory that increased market power can bring down prices and costs through economies of scale, we see just the opposite—costs go up as value of services go down. These examples make the point that each industry gives higher priority to its shareholders and CEOs than the public it is supposed to be serving. Insurers Giant insurers have been extending their reach into the health care system by purchasing companies in health information technology, physician management, and other areas that give them more clout and market share in their favor. As one example, United HealthGroup, the largest insurer by revenue, sells technology to hospitals, distributes prescription drugs, offers continuing medical education to physicians, and manages clinical trials.34 A 2015 report by the Commonwealth Fund found that 97% of markets for private Medicare Advantage plans in U.S. counties were ‘‘highly concentrated’’ with little competition.35 Hospitals As hospital systems expand, they typically buy up physician group practices in order to control large parts of medical practice in their areas; almost two-thirds Figure 1. Extent of for-profit ownership, 2016 Source: Commerce Department, Service Annual Survey 2016 or most recent available data for share of establishments. 10 International Journal of Health Services 0(0) of U.S. physicians are now employed by these systems, in some cases even by insurers. Physicians are typically hired under productivity-based contracts that reward them for providing a higher volume of services and ordering more expensive tests.36 A 2014 study documented how hospital ownership of physician practices drives up prices and costs.37 Nursing Homes About two-thirds of the nation’s 16,000 nursing homes are for profit. More than half are controlled by corporate chains, which have been found to provide worse quality of care than their not-for-profit counterparts, typically by cutting nursing staffing to increase profits.38 Home Care Three-fourths of the country’s home health agencies are for profit, which have been demonstrated to have higher costs and lower quality of care.39 Drug and Medical Device Mergers The year 2015 set a record for mergers and acquisitions in the drug and biotech industries. As one example, Walgreens Boots Alliance purchased Rite Aid, creating a chain of more than 12,000 U.S. pharmacies.40 In 2016, Abbott Laboratories acquired St. Jude, combining Abbott’s stent business with St. Jude’s pacemakers and implanted defibrillators.41 Dialysis Centers Mortality rates for the two largest for-profit dialysis centers in the country are 19 to 24% higher than their not-for-profit counterparts,42 while patients at forprofit dialysis centers are 20% less likely to be informed about kidney transplant options and 53% less likely to be put on a transplant waiting list.43 Hospice End-of-life care through hospice has become a $17 billion industry, with most hospices for profit; they spend less on nursing per patient, resulting in worse quality of care and more patients dropping out compared to their not-for-profit counterparts.44 The ACA enabled and accelerated these trends toward consolidation, mergers, and profiteering in several respects. Without any price controls or signifi- cant approaches to cost containment, it was seen as a bonanza for corporate Geyman 11 stakeholders in our market-based system. Its emphasis on wide adoption of electronic health records, rather than improving coordination and quality of care, instead became a billing instrument, with all kinds of ways for providers to game the system by up-coding the severity of illness. For insured patients, overutilization of health care became the norm. One such example: physician owners of CT and other imaging centers order two to eight times as many imaging procedures compared to those who do not own such equipment, amounting to an estimated $40 billion worth of unnecessary imaging each year. As a keynote speaker at a 2013 meeting of the Potomac Research Group, Tom Scully, former administrator of the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services in the George W. Bush administration, observed: Obamacare is not a government takeover of medicine. It is the privatization of health care ...It is going to make some people very rich.45 With all their economic and political clout, corporate interests lobby both sides of the aisle in Congress to continue this bonanza, further deregulate health care, and promote increased privatization of Medicare and Medicaid. They are aided by the current political climate, with Republican control of Congress and the White House as well as of 32 state houses around the country. The Citizens United decision of the U.S. Supreme Court and the lack of campaign financing reform also facilitate corporate agendas. Moreover, conflicts of interest are endemic through a revolving door between government, industry, and the lobbying agencies. As just one of many examples, Marilyn Tavenner, former Obamacare administrator in charge of the rollout of the ACA’s HealthCare.gov, now heads America’s Health Insurance Plans (AHIP), the industry’s main lobbying organization. Her highest priority is preserving and expanding private Medicare Advantage plans and maintaining large overpayments from the government compared with traditional Medicare.46 Lessons still unlearned After so many years of failed attempts to reform U.S. health care, it is remarkable that policymakers and politicians still haven’t learned what seems obvious from health policy science, evidence, and experience. These nine lessons, unlearned by many to this day, stand out as barriers to reform. Competitive Free Markets Don’t Work in Health Care The U.S. experiment with market-based medicine over the last four decades has failed the public interest. Instead, it has enriched corporate stakeholders in the medical-industrial complex at the expense of patients and their families. Nonetheless, many economists still believe that health care markets work like other markets, where competition can rein in prices and patients can shop for their best deal. This belief, however, has been fully discredited over the years for many reasons, including that patients don’t really know their needs, urgency of time is often a controlling factor, information is unavailable, asymmetry exists between physicians’ and patients’ knowledge, and consolidation of corporate providers tends to increase costs. Some economists saw this problem coming. Dr. Friedrich A. Hayek, leading economist from the last century and professor of social and moral sciences at the University of Chicago, made this prediction as early as 1946: Market capitalism will have the same inefficient, exploitive outcome as Soviet Communism if the ownership of resources becomes concentrated in the hands of fewer and fewer large corporations, and if economic business decisions come to be made by those relatively few individuals who own and/or operate large concentrated corporations.47 Consumer-directed Health Care Fails to Control Costs Many conservatives have harbored a long-held belief that ‘‘empowered patients in an ownership society’’—a common view even today—will contain health care costs by making more prudent decisions about seeking care. That boils down to policies that force patients to have ‘‘more skin in the game’’ through larger deductibles, copayments, and other restrictions. But recent decades have shown that more cost-sharing with patients leads many to forgo or delay necessary care, resulting in worse outcomes. As a society, we have yet to learn that the main purpose of higher deductibles is not to help patients but to reduce spending by insurers, employers, and government plans.48 The Private Health Insurance Industry Has Failed the Public Interest The private health insurance industry in the United States has had a long run and remains antithetical to reform. Its priority is to maximize revenue for CEOs and shareholders. After seven years with the ACA, the insurance industry still has many ways to game the system at patients’ expense, ranging from higher cost-sharing, restrictive networks, limited drug formularies, and deceptive marketing practices. Its products have become unaffordable to millions of people while its benefits continue to decrease in an increasingly segmented market. Insurers were bailed out by the ACA with expanded markets and subsidies and are again asking for further government bailouts under the guise of ‘‘reform’’ as they threaten to exit unprofitable markets. We have to come to realize that the industry has itself become a barrier to reform, that it is obsolete and should be abandoned. Geyman 13 Risk Must Be Shared Across the Largest Possible Population As long as we rely on a multi-payer system, including some 1,300 private insurers to finance our health care, we will fail to share risk across a large enough population to make health care affordable for everyone. The mathematics of risk pools have been known for years. Studies by the National Institute for Health Care Management have shown that just 5% of the population accounts for almost onehalf of all health care spending. In its 2012 report, 15% of the population used no care in the last year studied. We have a 20-80 rule that states that 20% of the population accounts for 80% of all health care spending.49 Based on this fact, the most efficient way to gain insurance coverage is to spread the risk across the largest number of people. The basic policy alternatives boil down to our present multi-payer system, with its expensive segmented risk pools that try to shift sicker patients to public programs, versus a single-payer public financing system that spreads risk across all 320 million Americans. Measures Intended to Improve Quality of Care Have Failed In an effort to improve the quality of care, the ACA introduced new ‘‘value-based’’ initiatives, such as pay-for-performance (P4P) report cards for physicians and accountable care organizations (ACOs). More than 150 quality metrics are now in use for outpatient services, such as rates for screening mammography. But there is still no evidence that any of these measures actually improve quality of care. Physicians and staff find reporting on these measures both burdensome and expensive in overhead (e.g., physician practices spend more than $15 billion annually on this task).50A majority of physicians believe that these ‘‘quality’’ measures are neither accurate nor useful, and fail to account for socioeconomic factors that harm safety net providers and hospitals caring for poorer and disadvantaged populations.51 The ACA’s accountable care organizations have failed to contain costs or improve care. Architects of this experimental program at Dartmouth College recently dropped out of their program amid increasing financial costs.52 A recent study of the ACO at Massachusetts General Hospital in Boston found that churning was common for both patients and physicians and that ACO benefi- ciaries accounted for less than 5% of a physician’s patients. It was easy to game the system, and about 90% of physicians felt that the ACO model is ineffective in containing costs or improving care.53 A Larger Role of Government and Regulations Are Needed to Assure Americans of a Reliable Health Care System That Meets Their Needs The recent and current political landscape reflects a divisive issue over the proper role of government in the economy, health care, and society. On the left and for many moderates, a larger role is strongly supported, even based on earlier American traditions, while conservatives on the right today argue for a limited role federally and more governance on state and local levels. Our present market-based system lacks enough regulation to assure access to affordable health care of acceptable quality. We have seen how privatization of Medicare and Medicaid leads to many abuses, including restricted access, higher costs, and worse care than better regulated public programs.54 Table 2 compares important differences between privatized Medicare and traditional, public Medicare. Here are just two examples that illustrate how unaccountable the current system is: . Federal audits of 37 private Medicare Advantage programs have found overspending due to inflated risk scores by overstating the severity of such conditions as diabetes and depression for a majority of elderly patients treated.55 . Medical billing fraud, ironically enabled by electronic medical records, is estimated to account for 10% of all health care costs, or about $270 billion a year.56 This perspective more than two centuries ago by John Adams, second U.S. president and one of our founding fathers, is more relevant today than ever: Government is instituted for the common good: for the protection, safety, prosperity, and happiness for the people; and not for the profit, honor, or private interest of any one man, family, or class of men.57 Table 2. Comparative Features of Privatized and Public Medicare [[TABLE OMITTED]] Source: Geyman.54 Shredding the social contract: the privatization of Medicare. Monroe ME. Common Courage Press, Monroe, ME, 2006, p. 206. Geyman 15 Health Care Should Be an Essential Human Right, Not Just Another Commodity Whether we acknowledge it or not, all of us are in the same boat—we will need health care at various points in our lives when we experience unanticipated accidents or illness. In a fair system, access to affordable health care should not be a privilege based on ability to pay (especially in a deregulated, profitdriven system with exorbitant costs) but a human right, as virtually all advanced countries around the world adopted many years ago. These words by Drs. Steffie Woolhandler and David Himmelstein, general internists and professors of public health at the City University of New York, make a persuasive case that health care is not just another commodity: In our society, some aspects of life are off-limits to commerce. We prohibit the selling of children and the buying of wives, juries, and kidneys. Tainted blood is an inevitable consequence of paying blood donors; even sophisticated laboratory tests cannot compensate for blood that is sold rather than given as a gift. Like blood, health care is too precious, intimate, and corruptible to entrust to the market.58 The ‘‘Business Ethic’’ of U.S. Health Care Should Be Replaced by a Service Ethic In 2014, Stephen Pearlstein described how corporations in the 1960s were ‘‘broadly viewed as owing something in return to the community that provided them with special legal protection and the economic ecosystem in which they could grow and thrive.’’ All that has changed since then. Today, the prevailing norm of corporate behavior is to maximize revenues for shareholder values and returns while squeezing employees, avoiding taxes, leaving communities in the lurch, and incentivizing CEOs with stock options. National polls have recorded a long, slow descent in the public’s trust and respect for corporations, with only Congress and HMOs lower.59 According to a Harris poll in early 2017, just 9% of U.S. consumers believe that pharmaceutical and biotechnology companies put patients over profits, and only 16% believe that health insurers do this.60 Since almost two-thirds of U.S. physicians are now employed by one or another corporate body, they frequently become entangled in ethical conflicts of interest, whether helping companies to market their products, participating in flawed studies that result in unwarranted FDA approval, or through physician-owned facilities. As one example, specialty hospitals allow their physician owners to ‘‘triple dip’’ by receiving income from performing a procedure, sharing in the facility’s profit, and increasing the value of their investment in the business.61 All this is a far cry from the teachings of Dr. William Osler, the best-known physician and medical educator in the 16 International Journal of Health Services 0(0) English-speaking world at the turn of the 20th century, who had this to say on the subject: As the practice of medicine is not a business and can never be one, the education of the heart—the moral side of the man—must keep pace with the education of the head ...The profession of medicine is distinguished from all others by its singular beneficence.62 The Meme of American ‘‘Exceptionalism’’ in Health Care Must Be Put to Rest The foregoing makes a compelling case that U.S. health care is in crisis. In by far the most expensive system in the world, tens of millions of Americans remain uninsured or underinsured, costs of insurance and care are increasingly unaffordable for much of the population, and outcomes of care are far worse than in virtually all advanced industrialized countries. The system is built by and for corporate interests and enabled by conservative policymakers and legislators. Despite this, a meme lives on among many Americans, fueled by conservatives and advocates of the free market, that we have the best health care in the world. The other advanced countries with which we are compared consider health care a human right and have developed systems of universal coverage to health care. It is therefore no surprise that we fare so poorly in this country by cross-national ratings, as the following markers illustrate: . Compared to 10 other advanced countries in the world, by a measure of mortality amenable to health care, the United States has the highest number of deaths per 100,000 population, nearly double that of France.63 . The United States has the worst record for preventable deaths among 19 Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) countries.64 . The United States has one of the highest mortality rates in the world for dialysis patients.65 . The United States has a wide variation between top and bottom states, with up to an 8-fold difference by such measures as access and affordability, prevention and treatment, avoidable hospital use and costs, healthy lives, and equity.66 . Up to one-third of all health care services provided in the United States are unnecessary or inappropriate, and some are actually harmful.67 . Despite the lack of evidence of benefit or approval by the FDA and the American College of Radiology, more than 30 million full-body CT scans are performed every year as an ineffective screening procedure, leading to potentially harmful radiation exposure.68 Geyman 17 . Given the shortage of primary care physicians in the United States, polypharmacy among multiple physicians not communicating with each other leads to excessive prescribing, accounting for drug-related complications among more than one-half of hospitalized elderly patients.69 Whither the Future? Despite the post-election control by the Republicans of the White House and both chambers of Congress, their recent failure to repeal and replace the ACA was a political event of monumental proportions. The battle exposed wide divisions within the Republican Party. They may proceed to another attempt to unify the party enough to pass a repeal-and-replace bill. In that case, however, support in the Senate may not be forthcoming. The GOP’s defeat changed the political dynamic in a number of important ways. Organizations representing insurers and hospitals defended the ACA, fearing reduction of markets, cuts in government funding, and loss of government subsidies. Organized medicine joined the opposition to repeal, including the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG), which strongly objected to charging women higher premiums than men and restrictions in the AHCA for women’s health care. Even the AMA came out in support of the ACA. It is a wide-open political question where, and when, U.S. health care will go now. Were a Republican bill to finally pass, which seems very unlikely, it would set our health care system back many years to the early 1960s before Medicare and Medicaid were passed as part of the Great Society in President Lyndon Johnson’s time. It would allow insurers to offer barebones, worthless policies under the guise of ‘‘insurance.’’ It would expand the rolls of the uninsured, make prices and costs higher, restrict access to care, and decimate safety net programs. It would likely lead to further privatization of Medicare and Medicaid, leaving policies of eligibility and benefits more up to the states. In effect, it would be cruel health policy inciting mass backlash from the public. As we have seen above, however, the ACA has not made health care more affordable for much of the population, has not contained prices or costs, will never bring universal access to care, and is unsustainable in the long run. The private insurance industry cannot tolerate uncertainty, and we can expect many insurers to hike premiums and exit markets in 2018. Many parts of the country are in jeopardy of having no choice of insurers next year.70 So health care remains a front-burner issue. Aetna’s CEO, Mark Bertolini, has already acknowledged that the ACA is in a ‘‘death spiral’’ for insurers.71 Although the economic and political power of corporate stakeholders in the current market-based system are formidable obstacles to reform, especially in this new period of Republican control at the federal level and in at least 32 states, there is a rising wave of broad support for universal coverage through single-payer NHI. Rep. John Conyers (D-MI) has introduced such a bill in the House (H.R. 676) every year since 2003; it has 113 cosponsors already in the House, with more to come. Here is what he just said about prospects for real reform at this point in time: I’m as happy as anyone with the way the Republicans’ plan to wreck our health care system crashed and burned last week. And President Donald Trump is right: Republicans lost because Democrats beat them. We beat them because we were organized, we were unified, and we were backed by unprecedented grassroots energy. Members of the U.S. Congress hosted dozens of rallies, advocacy organizations hosted hundreds more, and constituents showed up in overwhelming numbers at town halls across this country to make their voices heard. Given the record high support for publicly funded healthcare, economists, policy experts, and commentators everywhere have called on the Democratic party to build on our momentum by supporting a single-payer system.72 Even if they fail to repeal and replace the ACA, the GOP will own the chaos of health care markets. They can also expect to get the blame for trying to sabotage the ACA through administrative actions by Dr. Tom Price, the new head of the Department of Health and Human Services. In the monthly tracking poll by the Kaiser Family Foundation, 61% of Americans now say so.73 Meanwhile, Senator Senator Bernie Sanders, presidential candidate in 2016, plans to introduce a single-payer bill in the Senate, and Medicare for All may well become a litmus test for Democrats in the 2018 and 2020 election cycles, when we hopefully will see the Democratic party adopt single-payer NHI as part of its party platform.74 So the battle is on. On the one end of the political teeter-totter are support by the public and physicians, evidence and experience over the years with a failing system, and restoration of a service ethic in health care. On the other end are corporate money and political influence, profits of corporate stakeholders, and the so-called business ‘‘ethic’’ to make as much money as possible for CEOs and shareholders on the backs of sick people. Let’s hope that the United States will finally come in from out of the cold as an outlier among advanced and civilized countries.