Replacing premiums with taxes is net beneficial for economic growth and brings taxes to standard rates with the rest of the world
Seidman 15 – Laurence Seidman, Professor of Economics, University of Delaware, Ph.D. in economics, University of California, Berkeley (“The Affordable Care Act versus Medicare for All,” Journal of Health Politics, Policy & Law, Vol. 40, No. 4, August 2015, Available through Ebsco)
What is the effect of replacing premiums with taxes? Taxes vary with ability to pay, while premiums do not (Seidman 2009). It would be better for the economy and fairer to use a set of earmarked taxes that have moderate rates (Seidman 2013b). The set of taxes earmarked for Medicare for All might consist of the following: the Medicare payroll tax, a VAT, and a Medicare for All income tax surcharge on the 1040 income tax return. The Medicare payroll tax is currently 1.45 percent on the employer and 1.45 percent on the employee— a combined rate of 2.90 percent on all wage income. The VAT is used successfully by virtually every economically advanced country except the United States. Many US economists have recommended a US VAT (Seidman 2004, 2013b; Hines 2007). Several analysts have recommended that a VAT be enacted and earmarked for universal health (Morone 2002; Burman 2009). The VAT burden on low-income households would be offset by giving these households a refundable tax credit on their 1040 income tax return to compensate roughly for most of the burden they bear from the VAT (Seidman 2013b).
Today US medical costs are 18 percent of gross domestic product (GDP), while no other country exceeds 12 percent. Suppose Medicare for All aims to cut the huge 6 percentage point gap in half to 3 percent so that US medical costs are 15 percent of GDP. If Medicare for All succeeds in using its single-payer bargaining power (as explained below) to achieve its medical cost target of 15 percent of GDP, then Medicare for All taxes would need to be 15 percent of GDP. Government (federal and state) spending on Medicare, Medicaid, and other government health programs is currently about 7 percent of GDP (CBO 2012: 49, 55-57), so new earmarked taxes would need to be roughly 8 percent of GDP.
To put this 8 percent of GDP number in perspective, in 2007 (before the Great Recession caused a plunge in tax revenue) US taxes (federal, state, and local) were about 30 percent of GDP. Thus taxes would rise from 30 percent of GDP to 38 percent (federal taxes would rise by 9.5 percent of GDP, while state taxes would fall by 1.5 percent of GDP due to the reduction in state Medicaid expenses), which would still leave US taxes as a percentage of GDP slightly lower than the average of the economically advanced member countries of the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) (roughly 40 percent) and far below the Scandinavian countries (roughly 50 percent).