Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← SearchNorthwestern2023Affirmative
Opening Word document…

Progressive income tax hikes won’t collapse the economy

Seidman 13 [Laurence Seidman Professor of Economics University of Delaware November 2013 http://lerner.udel.edu/sites/default/files/ECON/PDFs/RePEc/dlw/WorkingPapers/2014/UDWP2014-02.pdf]

Here is a rough estimate of how much the new earmarked taxes would need to be as a percent of GDP. Today U.S. medical costs are 18% of GDP while no other country exceeds 12%. Suppose Medicare for All aims to cut the huge 6 percentage point gap in half to 3%, so that U.S. medical costs are 15% of GDP. If Medicare for All succeeds in using its single-payer bargaining power (as explained below) to achieve its medical cost target of 15% of GDP, then Medicare for All taxes would need to be 15% of GDP. Government (federal and state) spending on Medicare, Medicaid, and other government health programs is currently about 7% of GDP (U.S. Congressional Budget Office 2012), so new earmarked taxes would need to be roughly 8% of GDP. To put this 8% of GDP number in perspective, in 2007 (before the Great Recession caused a plunge in tax revenue), U.S. taxes (federal, state, and local) were about 30% of GDP. Thus, taxes would rise by 8% of GDP from 30% to 38% (federal taxes would rise by 9.5% of GDP while state taxes would fall by 1.5% of GDP due to the reduction in state Medicaid expenses), which would still leave U.S. taxes as a percent of GDP slightly lower than the average of the economically advanced OECD countries (roughly 40%) and far below the Scandinavian countries (roughly 50%). At the same time, U.S. medical costs would be 3% of GDP lower every year (15% instead of 18% of GDP) so goods and services other than medical care would be 3% of GDP higher every year (85% instead of 82% of GDP). Each year Americans would enjoy 3% of GDP more goods and services other than medical care while still having the highest medical care spending in the world (15% of GDP when all other countries spend 12% of GDP or less). Medicare for All would have to bargain over prices and budget caps with medical providers in order to keep Medicare for All spending from exceeding the earmarked revenues it collects. If a gap occurs, Congress would have to bridge the gap by either raising earmarked taxes or reducing medical prices and budget caps. Once Medicare for All taxes are in place, political resistance to raising the rates of these earmarked taxes would help contain the rise in medical costs under Medicare for All. Would the efficiency cost imposed by increasing the tax burden from 30 to 38 percent of GDP be large or small? A huge literature by economists addresses this question, and I make no attempt to review that literature here. I will cite just one economist’s empirical work here that has influenced my own thinking, while acknowledging that not all economists agree with his empirical results. In his monograph on social spending and economic growth in economically advanced countries over the past three centuries, Peter Lindert (2004, p16-17) wrote: “Knowing that higher tax rates and higher subsidies to people who don’t produce could discourage productivity, many of us naturally suspect that taxes and transfers should reduce the productivity of the whole economy…Yet the history of economic growth is unkind to this natural suspicion…Nine decades of historical experience fail to show that transferring a larger share of GDP from taxpayers to transfer recipients has a negative correlation with either the level or rate of growth of GDP per person. The average correlation is essentially zero.” Lindert then gave his explanation (p31): “In general, high-budget welfare states have a more pro-growth and regressive mix of taxes…They rely more heavily on labor income taxes and flat consumption (or value-added) taxes…Granted, the rates of overall taxation are still higher in the high-budget countries, yet their attention to the side-effects on economic growth seems to have led them to choose types of taxes that minimize or eliminate any damage to growth.”

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.