Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← SearchNorthwestern2023Affirmative
Opening Word document…

Empirics prove strike down

Avik Roy 17, President, The Foundation for Research on Equal Opportunity (@FREOPP). Editor @ForbesOpinion. Author of “Transcending Obamacare,” “How Medicaid Fails the Poor.”, 3-2-2017, "How State-Based Single-Payer Initiatives Crush Economic Opportunity," FREOPP.org, https://freopp.org/how-state-based-single-payer-initiatives-crush-economic-opportunity-604ac9ac17c9

Core elements of the New York Health Act violate federal law The New York Health Act envisions abolishing private health insurance and replacing it with a single, state-run insurance program. However, the Act ignores the fact that federal law prohibits states from doing so. ERISA protects self-insured plans from state regulation. The Employee Retirement Income Security Act, enacted by Congress in 1974, provides employers with the ability to preempt state health insurance laws if they choose to provide health insurance directly, instead of through a third-party insurer. In third-party, or group insurance, the insurance company takes on the financial risks of paying health care claims, even if those claims exceed the revenues that the insurer has received in premiums. If a company decides to self-insure, it takes on those financial risks directly. Most large companies self-insure because there are economies of scale in doing so; in New York state in 2015, 83.2 percent of workers covered at firms with more than 1,000 employees were enrolled in self-insured plans, according to the U.S. Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality. All in all, in 2015, 53.5 percent of New York state residents with employer-sponsored health insurance were enrolled in self-insured plans protected from state interference by the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA). With 10.2 million New Yorkers covered by employer-sponsored plans — 52 percent of the population — self-insured plans cover 5.1 million New Yorkers, or 26 percent of the state population. In other words, ERISA prevents New York State from abolishing private health coverage sponsored by companies that self-insure their workers. This principle of preemption was upheld by the U.S. Supreme Court on March 1, 2016 in Gobeille v. Liberty Mutual. The State of Vermont had sought to require self-insured employer plans in that state to report data on health care utilization, pricing, and quality to the state government. The Supreme Court ruled that ERISA prohibited states from regulating self-insured employer plans, even with something as minor as data disclosure. Indeed, the text of the New York Health Act partially anticipates this problem, declaring that a provision related to out-of-state residents working in New York “shall be null and void” if it is found “to violate federal ERISA.” Hence, an analytically accurate assessment of the New York Health Act must take into account that it cannot apply to the one-third of New Yorkers who receive their coverage from self-insured employers.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.