Numerous aspects of the counterplan violate ERISA
Marea Tumber 15 [Candidate for Juris Doctor, December 2015, University of Massachusetts School of Law; MPH, Brown University; B.A., St. Lawrence University, "The ACA's 2017 State Innovation Waiver: Is ERISA a Roadblock to Meaningful Healthcare Reform? 10 U. MASS. L. REV. 388, accessed 1-14-2018]
In order to create a single-payer system, states would need to institute a payroll or income tax to pay for it. The Vermont plan incorporated a payroll tax as the preferred means to raise revenue to pay for a single-payer system. 193 A payroll tax can raise ERISA preemption problems because such taxes create incentives for employers who are sponsoring health coverage plans to terminate or modify their plans.194
The amount of payroll tax that would be required to fund a single payer system is not known, but the Hsiao report estimated it would be approximately 12.8 to 18.2 percent. 195 The Court in Travelers recognized that a state law might impose cost burdens so “exorbitant” that they removed any real choice and therefore could be preempted.196 A 12.8 to 18.2 percent tax is significant and a court would likely find this “exorbitant” 197 under Travelers. Under RILA, the Court found that the eight percent payroll tax in that case left employers with a lack of “meaningful alternatives by which an employer can increase its healthcare spending to comply with the [law] without affecting its ERISA plan.” 198 A law that compels plan administrators to structure their benefits in a particular way, especially by forgoing their ERISA plans, would be preempted under Travelers. 199 This restructuring of employee plans also directly conflicts with ERISA’s goal of permitting uniform nationwide administration of these plans.” 200
States could defend this approach with several credible arguments. For example, both taxation and healthcare financing are exercises of traditional state authority that a court should not presume Congress intended to preempt under § 514(b).201 It could be argued that such a state law would not be directed at employer health plan administration, since employers would be free to provide coverage to employees even if they also were paying the tax. A payroll tax would involve no employer role other than remitting the funds. 202 Furthermore, the incidence of a payroll tax on employers actually falls on employees so its economic impacts are similar to those of an individual income tax.203 Despite these arguments, a payroll tax high enough to fund a single-payer system would likely be so “exorbitant” 204 that a court would find the state law preempted by ERISA.
3. Changes In Plan Administration, e.g. “Single Pipe,” Rate Setting
State innovations under the § 1332 waiver will likely impact plan administration. For example, creating a single payment pipe is an essential feature of a single-payer plan since it reduces administrative waste. 205 There are also healthcare reform models that propose a private-public system that leaves much of the health insurance system intact, but aim to save money through a uniform claims administration process.206 Requiring an ERISA plan to be administered in a specific way or through a single processor would likely violate ERISA. 207 Under Mackey, a state law “references” an ERISA plan if it had an immediate effect on such plans by changing how the plan is administered. 208 Any state law that prescribes a new payment methodology would necessarily “refer” 209 to an ERISA plan. Under the expansive Shaw reading of § 514(a) and its “relate to” clause, this type of statutory mandate is preempted by ERISA because the mandate both “refers to” and has a “connection with” employers’ ERISA regulated plans for providing medical care.210 A state could argue that this is a traditional state regulation under 514(b), but again, as in Part V(A)(1) above, under Travelers, it is unlikely that a benefit mandate law could survive judicial scrutiny as either a quality control measure or workplace regulation.211
Another change to plan administration would be through rate setting. Having a uniform set of mechanisms and rates is typical of a single-payer system, and one of the greatest areas for cost savings.212 The rate-setting aspect of a single-payer system is likely to pass legal muster. Under Travelers, ERISA would not preempt a state ratesetting program that established rates for all providers, including hospitals, physicians and other providers, as long as it dictates what providers must charge rather than what payers must pay. 213 Both insured and self-insured ERISA plans would pay those rates under the reasoning in Travelers. 214
In sum, a state law that enacts a single-payer system under a § 1332 waiver will likely be preempted in at least three ways by ERISA. The law(s) would be preempted through (1) mandated benefits via minimum coverage requirements, (2) coercion (“pay or play”) through payroll taxes, and (3) changes in benefit plan administration.215