Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← SearchNorthwestern2023Affirmative
Opening Word document…

State action is key even if federal reforms are preferable---key to solve geographic coverage gaps and leads to federal follow on

Henry Aaron 8, Bruce and Virginia MacLaury Senior Fellow at the Brookings Institution, Economic Studies, written with Stuart Butler, vice president, Domestic and Economic Policy Studies, at the Heritage Foundation, May 2008, "A Federalist Approach To Health Reform: The Worst Way, Except For All The Others," Health Affairs, Volume 27, Number 3, May 2008, pp. 725-735

Support for state action should be part of any strategy to expand health insurance coverage. Decades-long political deadlock in Washington has frustrated national efforts to expand coverage. Some states have already undertaken to do this; others show a determination to do so. Regulatory and legislative flexibility would trigger widespread state action. Whether one thinks that ensuring coverage requires a unified national approach or that diverse conditions require different methods in different states, the likelihood of progress will be advanced if states test out various ways to expand coverage. We describe a practical way by which the federal government can promote state action to expand health insurance coverage.

Federal encouragement of state health reform will advance both the state and national reform agendas.

HISTORIAN SHELBY FOOTE REMARKED THAT before the Civil War, people commonly wrote, “the United States are…” but that after the war they wrote, “the United States is….” As far as health care delivery is concerned, the United States remains very much in the “are” phase. Whether and when it will move to the “is” phase remains highly uncertain. County and state differences in the organization, financing, and use of health care are vast. The proportion of uninsured people varies across states by nearly three to one. Expenditures per person in the highest-spending state exceed those in the lowest by 70 percent. Use of various services differs among Hospital Referral Regions (HRRs) by five or ten to one and sometimes more.1 Some of the differences arise from explicit state policies or income differentials. Some result from historical accident. The simple fact is that for whatever reason, quality of and access to care are better on average in some states than in others.

These differences should not be ignored as the nation strives to reform its health care system. Some people argue that national legislation is imperative to achieve consistent, comprehensive coverage throughout the country. Others hold that separate action by individual states is the wiser course, given the U.S. political system and disagreements on the best way forward, even among experts of the same philosophical persuasion. This disagreement is important, but adherents of both positions should recognize that encouraging state action to expand coverage at this time will advance both agendas. We argued some time ago in Health Affairs that measures to energize state experimentation within a federal-state framework based on clear national goals will achieve two objectives: it will extend coverage in the near term, and it will advance the date at which coordinated national action is possible.2 Our view has not changed, and it is unlikely to do so, no matter who wins the next presidential election.

State Reform: The Best Way To Trigger National Action

Each of us continues to favor national action. We both feel that Americans have come to a consensus that access to adequate basic health care is part of what it means to be a resident of the United States. That consensus involves important values and goals, and it requires key legislative actions at the federal level to set the nation on course to realize those goals. But for three reasons we believe that a strategy based on state initiatives is likely to be the best way to trigger national action.

Breaks political deadlocks.

First, there are deep disagreements among reasonable and committed people—including between us—about what the best practical approach is. That makes it very difficult to get political support for coherent, workable action even among those who broadly agree on goals. Our strategy is designed as a political device to break that deadlock by making it possible to launch a variety of bold approaches quickly, with the more successful initiatives helping to build consensus for more sweeping action.

Allows for glitches in a limited arena.

Second, given the complexity of current U.S. health care financing, it is likely that well-intentioned reformers will make mistakes. Eventual national action will emerge with fewer glitches if those mistakes are made on the limited stage of individual states than if a full-blown national plan must be designed in advance.XT

Can accommodate states’ variations.

And third, we believe that any national system would have to accommodate considerable state-to-state variation, at least for many years. If that is so, then why not begin with a system that incorporates state variation as an instrument to spur continuous improvement amid uncertainty and disagreement about the ideal solution?

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.