The counterplan causes learning and national adoption
Henry Aaron 8, Bruce and Virginia MacLaury Senior Fellow at the Brookings Institution, Economic Studies, written with Stuart Butler, vice president, Domestic and Economic Policy Studies, at the Heritage Foundation, May 2008, "A Federalist Approach To Health Reform: The Worst Way, Except For All The Others," Health Affairs, Volume 27, Number 3, May 2008, pp. 725-735
The second reason is that the U.S. health care sector is remarkably complex, and knowledge about what will work best in the diverse political and health system environments of the fifty states is remarkably incomplete. So whether one believes that the ideal reform would be national or federalist, the ability to move ahead in the near future will be advanced by learning from state initiatives now—and from initiatives that are not marginal refinements, where the results are minor and the lessons open to dispute, but bold initiatives that test very different approaches. Moreover, any national reform will be enhanced by allowing states to improve it at the margin, both to adjust the reform to local circumstances and to adapt it to new knowledge. It should also be kept in mind that other federalist nations—notably Canada and Switzerland—extended health insurance to all while allowing provinces and cantons some flexibility in how to do it.
The third reason for encouraging state action is the abundant evidence that states are eager and poised to take the lead in health system reform.3 The Massachusetts plan is the most widely known. It mandates that every person have insurance or pay a tax penalty, and it subsidizes low- and moderate-income families to help them buy health insurance. It also creates a state-operated insurance exchange, known as the “Connector,” that enables individuals and employees of small businesses—indeed, anyone—to buy insurance at regulated rates and take it from job to job.