Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← SearchNorthwestern2023Affirmative
Opening Word document…

States can successfully manage single payer systems---previous examples failed because they were added onto the existing federal structure

PPG 8/5, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette editorial board, 8/5/17, "Healthy devolution: For the next round of health care reform, look to states," www.post-gazette.com/opinion/editorials/2017/08/06/Healthy-devolution-For-the-next-round-of-health-care-reform-look-to-states/stories/201708310015

The conservative principle of federalism and the liberal cause of a single-payer option could, for example, be combined.

Both sides understand that the source of ballooning health care costs lies in the system’s vast complexity, which makes government and insurance companies alike unaccountable in keeping costs under control. Liberals recognize that simplifying the health insurance market on free enterprise principles would make insurance utterly unaffordable or simply inaccessible for millions of Americans. But conservatives fear that a health care service based in Washington would be too far removed from patient needs. They also bridle against the rationing and wait times such a system would require to control costs and equalize access. Canadians in need of a hip or knee replacement wait an average of six months for the procedure. With a much larger population than Canada — or any of the other countries with single-payer health care and comparable governments — America under an equivalent system could see substantially worse waiting periods.

But such a system need not be administered from Washington — a state could do it.

This is where conservatives and liberals could find common cause: having states create their own systems. The reason Massachusetts’ and Vermont’s experiments in state-provided health care failed is that they were basically state-sized Medicaid programs added on top of the existing Byzantine structure.

Conservatives have good reason to believe the health care systems of Europe and the Pacific Rim would translate poorly to our much larger democracy and its history of individualism. But they are wrong to deny the relative success of the universal model in those countries. Rather than simply copying and pasting that model, consider an adaptation. Government health care administration could be steered toward the states, building on the American traditions of federalism and choice. With Congress often paralyzed by partisan conflict, states and cities are taking more matters into their own hands, in any event.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.