Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← SearchNorthwestern2023Affirmative
Opening Word document…

Migration isn’t significant enough to cause a race to the bottom

Nicholas Bagley 17, Professor Nicholas Bagley teaches and writes in the areas of administrative law, regulatory theory, and health law, former attorney with the appellate staff in the Civil Division at the U.S. Department of Justice where he argued before the U.S. Courts of Appeals and acted as lead counsel, 4/24/17, "Federalism and the End of Obamacare," University of Michigan Law School, repository.law.umich.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi? article=2847&context=articles

To the extent that the states cannot be excluded from the enjoyment of collective goods, they will be tempted to contribute little or nothing to the production of those goods. They will prefer, instead, to free ride on the contributions of other states. Since every state has the same incentives, contributions toward that collective good will fall short of what the states, acting in concert, would prefer. Federal action may be necessary to avoid a race to the bottom.

When it comes to health reform, a race to the bottom might develop if a state’s adoption of a coverage expansion led sick people to flock to the state.12 To avoid becoming a “welfare magnet,” individual states might decline to expand coverage, even if they would happily expand coverage if they could con- fine that coverage to their own residents.

But the welfare magnet story justifies federal intervention only if lots of sick people move to get health insurance. The evidence suggests they do not. In a 2014 study, Aaron Schwartz and Benjamin Sommers examined migration patterns in response to Medicaid expansions in four states.13 They found “no evidence of significant migration effects” and could “rule out net migration effects of larger than 1,600 people a year in an expansion state.”14 A similar 2016 study by Lucas Goodman used a broader sample and estimated that “the migration effect of Medicaid is very close to zero.”15 These findings, which accord with other research on interstate mobility,16 make intuitive sense. People don’t lightly move17 and they rarely do so for health reasons.18 Lower-income people in particular may not have the resources or the job flexibility to pull up stakes. If people don’t move to get insurance, there is no race to the bottom for federal action to forestall.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.