States have historical supremacy over health insurance regulation---the Court will defer towards the states on ERISA questions
Elizabeth McCuskey 16, Associate Professor of Law, University of Toledo College of Law, “Body of Preemption: Health Law Traditions and the Presumption Against Preemption,” 2016, Temple Law Review, 89 Temp. L. Rev. 89
Commercial health insurance. Since the 1850s, states have been the primary regulators of insurance; therefore, they have supplied most laws governing private health insurance.343 Insurers did not cover health care, however, until after 1908.344 The first two categories of true health insurance sprung up in the early 1930s: Groups of hospitals offered prepaid services (known as “Blue Cross” model plans), and groups of physicians offered similar arrangements (known as “Blue Shield” plans).345 Health insurance policies were rare until after World War II, when they became ubiquitous and largely employer-sponsored because insurance offered as an employee fringe benefit was exempt from the wartime wage and price controls.346
Over their roughly 150 years of insurance regulation, states have both exercised licensing authority over insurers and have regulated issuance of policies.347 Since 1945 with the passage of the McCarran-Ferguson Act,348 some state insurance regulation has enjoyed a form of reverse preemption in which state insurance law is supreme to federal law.349 The Health Maintenance Organization Act of 1973350 “marked the first time that Congress created a direct federal role in the regulation of health insurance;” the legislation was “designed to supplement, rather than replace . . . state functions” through federal funding and qualifications.351
State health insurance regulation thus can quite accurately be described as “primary” from its inception. The federal government, however, unintentionally assumed a major role with the passage of the ERISA352 in 1974. Although passed primarily with pension benefits in mind, ERISA applies to all employer-sponsored benefits, which has come to include health insurance. ERISA’s original purposes were to safeguard employees’ pensions and to encourage the provision of pension benefits by establishing a uniform system of federal regulation.353 To promote uniformity, Congress wrote into ERISA a “terse but comprehensive”354 provision expressly preempting state laws that “relate to” any “benefit plan[s]”355 covered by the Act. ERISA thus preempts vast swaths of state initiatives aimed at increasing access to employer-sponsored health insurance.356
ERISA’s savings clause exempts state regulation of “the business of insurance” from preemption under the statute.357 The difficulty of determining when state laws “relate to” employer-sponsored health insurance (and are preempted) versus when they relate to the “business of insurance” (and are saved from preemption) has resulted in one of the most contentious preemptions in health law—perhaps in any law, period.358 As the Supreme Court has noted in ERISA contexts, health insurance is a “field[] of traditional state regulation,” and Congress must not have intended ERISA to “displace general health care regulation, which historically has been a matter of local concern.”359 By that logic, the Supreme Court held that ERISA does not preempt a state statute requiring hospitals to collect a surcharge from commercial insurers, despite the impact on employer-sponsored insurance.360 On the other hand, the Court has held that ERISA does preempt state law remedies for health insurers’ faulty eligibility and coverage decisions, despite state law’s traditional role in supplying remedies.361