Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← SearchNorthwestern2023Affirmative
Opening Word document…

Government subsidization of medical innovation gets politicized---only market signals drive innovation in the right areas

The Economist 7---The economist is an award winning magazine. 4/16/07, “In the name of innovation” https://www.economist.com/blogs/freeexchange/2007/04/in_the_name_of_innovation

Can't the government just replace the lost spending? Then we could have all the drugs, without the nasty marketing spending! There are several potential answers to this.

The marketing spending isn't all it's cracked up to be; a huge percentage of it is free samples, which we don't want to stop.

Some of that marketing expense will then be replaced by grant-writing expense.

There's reason to question how well the government does at allocating research priorities, which often depend more on the loudness of the advocacy group than the incidence of the disease (this is why AIDS and breast cancer get a vastly disproportionate amount of research funds, relative to the number of people at risk.) Drug companies, it seems to me, allocate research dollars in a pretty efficient manner: the number of people who have a disease, and how desperate each of those people is for a solution to their problem (which translates into the price they will pay). You will notice that there are a lot more drugs for high cholesterol than for toenail fungus. As far as I can tell, the government allocates research dollars based on who looks cutest complaining about their condition on television, plus which diseases are most prevalent among politicians and celebrities.

There's no particular reason that efficiency at basic research translates into quality applied research. As far as I know, the Soviet Union had a pretty good research sector, with the notable exception of its Lysenko-infected biology facilities. But it did a miserable job of translating this research into consumer products, or indeed any products, except possibly weapons. You could chalk this up to some idiosyncrasy of the Soviet Union. But you might also consider the possibility that prices contain some sort of valuable information, which may not much hamper basic research, but makes it very difficult to develop final products without them. To take another example, the American's government's DARPA agency may have provided the seed capital for the internet's initial basic infrastructure, but who among us believes that the internet would exist in anything like its current size and scope had the government remained responsible for its subsequent development?

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.