Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← SearchNorthwestern2023Affirmative
Opening Word document…

The plan causes doctors to quit and crushes R&D---turns access and outcomes

Christopher Castaldi-Moller 16, Bridge the Divide, 11/14/16, “Against Single Payer,” https://www.bridge-the-divide.com/single-post/2016/11/14/Against-Single-Payer

Secondly, the ways through which some progressives propose to cut potential medical expenses are either infeasible or immensely problematic. Relying on an incredibly high reduction in pharmaceutical costs in America wouldn’t be very wise – while prices would surely go down under single-payer, they can’t such that the budgetary impacts of a national healthcare scheme would be minimal. What the government could do instead is cut the paychecks of American doctors to ensure that the cost of single payer can be at least slightly contained. But this would, of course, be an utter disaster for a broad variety of reasons. First, by reducing medical salaries, America's hospitals and clinics would see doctors either exit the profession or retire early. This is not a speculative forecast – as Dr. Robert Book of the Heritage Foundation explains, low Medicare and Medicaid payouts induce doctors to drop those patients covered by the two public plans in favor of the privately insured. Under a single payer system, the fact that there would be no private alternatives means that doctors might have no choice but to leave their field if they are frustrated by lowered salaries. Meanwhile, the deterrent effect caused by reduced physician pay would mean that many talented individuals – confronted with a plethora of lucrative career opportunities and the arduous process of earning a medical degree – may simply opt out of becoming doctors in the first place. In the short term, this would harm patient access to their doctors of choice, cause a ‘brain drain’ of experienced and trained doctors, and reduce the time doctors spend on individual patients by decreasing the supply of medical professionals. But more dangerously, a reduced pool of medical professionals and a cut profit incentive would cause reduced focus on and investment in advanced medical equipment and research projects. This would not only mean that specialized and cosmetic care would be hindered under a single payer scheme, but that the rate of treatment and cure discovery would be slowed. Therefore, single payer may not only cost Americans their favorite doctors, but it will also cost lives by slowing medical research.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.