The only way to control costs is to limit access to health care---that crushes the case
Dave Mordo 17, Director of Compliance & Broker Education, insurance company. 7/25/17, “Single-payer would be a nightmare for Americans” http://www.washingtonexaminer.com/single-payer-would-be-a-nightmare-for-americans/article/2629120
Single-payer systems control costs primarily by limiting access to healthcare. In the United Kingdom's National Health Service, 5 million patients will languish on waiting lists for non-emergency surgeries, such as hip replacements, by 2019. The president of the country's emergency room doctors association warned earlier this year that wait times are causing "untold patient misery" and that the NHS is "broken."
In Canada, patients wait more than nine weeks between referral from a general practitioner and consultation with a specialist. By comparison, American patients wait less than four weeks, on average. Fewer than 4 percent of Americans who need non-emergency surgeries must wait longer than four months, compared to 18 percent of Canadians.
In many cases, single-payer systems force patients to wait indefinitely for lifesaving medicines — again, to keep costs down.
For instance, Britain's NHS only permits 10,000 people per year to receive highly advanced drugs that cure hepatitis C, a deadly infectious disease that afflicts 215,000 Britons.
As of late 2015, the NHS covered just 38 percent of cancer medicines approved for sale in 2014 and 2015. Canada's national health system offered access to 24 percent of those drugs; Spain's, only 5 percent.
Those medicines that are available are subject to government price controls. Patients may feel like they're getting a good deal, but such controls discourage investment in medical research, slowing the pace of medical innovation.
In the 1970s, four European countries developed more than half of the world's medicines. But since they imposed price controls on drugs, those countries now invent only one-third of medicines. The United States, by contrast, developed nearly 60 percent of the world's new drugs between 2001 and 2010.
Single-payer systems don't just cap spending on drugs. They also insist upon artificially low reimbursement rates for hospitals and doctors. In many cases, these payments don't even cover the cost of providing certain treatments and procedures.
The result? Fewer hospitals and doctors. Canada has about 10 percent fewer hospital beds per person than the United States — and 35 percent fewer surgeons per capita.