Turns case---worsens quality and access to care
Amy Anderson 14, Health Policy Expert and Consultant, AACN Faculty Policy Think Tank Member, Assistant Professor of Professional Practice at Texas Christian University, 3/18/14, “The Impact of the Affordable Care Act on the Health Care Workforce” http://www.heritage.org/health-care-reform/report/the-impact-the-affordable-care-act-the-health-care-workforce
Unintended Consequences. Adding up to 34 million patients to an insurance and delivery system that is already struggling with workforce shortages cannot avoid adversely affecting patient access and quality of care. The ACA cannot by itself guarantee access or increased quality of care through the mandated purchase of all-inclusive insurance policies. In fact, the unintended consequences of the ACA’s complexity will ripple throughout the health care sector.
Quality Health Care. Quality of care has been a major focus in health care in the U.S. for many years, and America’s medical professionals have continually tried to improve practice and provide the best care in the world. Nonetheless, the results have been uneven.
The ACA approach to guaranteeing quality is to move the medical workforce from the fee-for-service model of health care reimbursement to pay-for-performance. Pay-for-performance is an umbrella term for initiatives that give incentives or penalties measured by patient outcomes and readmission rates.[72] The research shows that the number of physicians in a state is associated with better quality and better outcomes.[73] As the workforce shortages worsen, the quality of care in states with fewer physicians overall will suffer. States with higher physician-to-resident ratios will fare better under the ACA’s pay-for-performance system, increasing inequality and disparity in the nation.[74]
While the concept of pay-for-performance shows some merit in reducing cost, transforming the system could prove difficult with the current penalties and reductions in reimbursement rates. Inadequate staffing levels significantly affect quality of care.[75] Low nurse staffing levels and higher nurse-to-patient ratios have been shown to increase morbidity and mortality.[76] Working conditions—such as increased pressure to perform, workforce shortages, and increased demand for services—will negatively affect health care institutions in the pay-for-performance system.
A recent survey reported that “40 percent of hospitalists are already seeing heavy workloads that result in unsafe conditions, delays in patient admissions and discharge, and failure to discuss treatment options.”[77] Hospitals and providers with more limited resources and medical professionals working in economically depressed areas may have difficulty meeting benchmarks of progress if their payments are further reduced under the ACA.[78] Strained finances, limited operating budgets, and staff layoffs—aggravated by ACA financial penalties and payment reductions—will cause a downward spiral of low performance. The Office of the Actuary in the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, among others, has already projected that more hospitals will be operating in the red or hovering on the brink of insolvency.
Access to Health Care. Greater access to health care is a central ACA goal, but heavier demand for services will likely create a bottleneck in access. Individuals on the exchanges will likely experience a narrowing of networks and limited providers. In a survey by Jackson and Coker, 44 percent of physicians indicated that they will not participate in the exchanges.[79] A survey by the Medical Group Management Association found that 64 percent of practices are concerned with the regulatory burdens, and two out of three practices indicated that reimbursement rates were lower than commercial rates, heightening concern about participation. The negative impact on practice decisions and financial instability is motivating many physicians to avoid contracting with health plans in the exchanges.[80]