Single-payer eliminates hundreds of thousands of insurance industry jobs---causes a massive economic shock
Daily Kos 15, group blog and internet forum focused on liberal American politics.1/26/15, “The Case In Favor of Universal Health Cover but Against Single Payer” https://www.dailykos.com/stories/2015/1/26/1360024/-The-Case-In-Favor-of-Universal-Health-Insurance-but-Against-Single-Payer
Job loss is a major consideration in choosing a universal health scheme over single payer. Of course there will be some job loss from the private sector when a universal plan is introduced but those losses, by and large, would be quickly absorbed into the government’s health sector.
Eliminating all private health insurance, on the other hand, would instantly dump hundreds of thousands of jobs on the employment market, too many for the government sector to absorb at once and too many for which the government has no need such as those workers from accounts and promotion departments. A government health plan for all is not going to be sending out accounts to any of its clients nor will it have any need to promote itself in the market when it already encompasses everyone.
Turning thousands from employed into unemployed virtually overnight would deal a heavy blow to the economy and that’s the last thing a new government health plan needs to herald its introduction. It’s not just the bad publicity it would generate (though that would be severe and ongoing) but a huge new government initiative like universal health cover needs a healthy economy to ensure a successful launch and wide-spread acceptance.