Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← SearchNorthwestern2023Evidence
Opening Word document…

Nuclear war won’t cause extinction, but it will reverse development of industrial society.

Beckstead ’15 [Nick; September 2015; Program Officer for the Open Philanthropy Project, Ph.D. in Philosophy from Rutgers University; "How much could refuges help us recover from a global catastrophe?" Futures, Vol. 71, p. 36-44]

A first issue is that a global food crisis would not necessarily result in extinction. Extinction may even be extremely unlikely in such cases. The closest historical precedent to these crises was the supervolcanic Toba eruption that took places about 74,000 years ago. Many eruptions of this kind have taken place in the last tens of millions of years, but they did not extinguish our pre-human ancestors (Shulman, 2012a). Humans may now be in many ways worse prepared for such a crisis, with a much larger percentage of the population without hunting and agricultural skills, but we have many advantages in terms of technology and coordination. The 100+ isolated peoples would be relatively similar to pre-human ancestors who survived supervolcanic eruptions in the past, though—as noted above—they may have a notable disadvantage in re-establishing an advanced industrial civilization.

Second, in any of the global food crisis scenarios noted above, there would be a substantial amount of remaining food reserves in the form of grain stockpiles, livestock, fisheries, foods stored at retailers and private homes, and wild land animals that could be hunted (Shulman, 2012b). Therefore, if a refuge helps humanity survive a global food crisis, the mechanism could not be conceived of as “adding enough to the global food stock to help with survival.” More plausibly, there could be a scenario where there is not enough food for everyone to survive the global food crisis, but there would be enough food for some people to survive if they got a disproportionate share of the food. However, conflict (e.g., as in McCarthy's post-apocalyptic novel The Road) and/or egalitarian pressures could prevent a distribution that would allow at least some of the population to survive the crisis. Conceivably, if the refuge were sufficiently secret, isolated, and well-stocked, it might be the only place where these pressures could be abated, making the people in refuges the sole survivors of the global food crisis. While conceivable and perhaps plausible, refuges’ unique success in this kind of case is not automatic and perhaps unlikely. If some small, well-armed group seizes some grain elevators, refuses to share their bounty, and successfully defends what they have claimed, they could also survive the global food crisis. Alternatively, a single survivalist community might be isolated and well-defended enough to achieve the same purpose. This potential use case may deserve more detailed analysis.

4.6. Social collapse scenarios: increased coordination may help

As noted above, even if some initial catastrophe failed to kill everyone, it could lead to a collapse of the modern world order. This type of scenario might accompany a global food crisis, or could arise independently in cases of an unprecedentedly bad pandemic or global war that decimates the population. Conceivably, such a collapse to lead to extinction or a failure to recover industrial civilization.

In this kind of scenario, people in refuges are not the sole survivors of our hypothetical global catastrophe. Instead, it seems extremely likely that, some non-negligible fraction of civilization (greater than 1 in 10,000, say) would survive. But a greatly reduced global population would be unable to sustain many aspects of modern industry, manufacturing, trade, and agricultural production, and may be forced to retrace a substantial part of past technological development (see Hanson (2008) quotation below).

Most of the global threats consistent with the above scenario would leave most of humanity's material resources (housing, farms, streets, mines, grain elevators, supply centers, etc.) in place, though much of it may cease to effectively function (e.g. power plants, manufacturing sites, oil rigs, etc.). From the above list of doomsday scenarios, nuclear war or other wars seem like the only potentially-survivable catastrophes with any potential to destroy a majority of available material resources. And, as argued above, even a nuclear war would have a hard time destroying a majority of the world's population outright. Therefore, whatever resources are stockpiled in specially constructed refuges would be a small fraction of all available material resources following any realistic proposed civilization collapse scenario. How could refuges be crucial for recovery if they contain a very small fraction of the population, food, and material resources in the world?

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.